Praise for capitalist ruler
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
SOME strange things have been said about Indira Gandhi since she was killed. Michael Foot, for example, gave her a touching obituary in the Observer.
Gandhi, says the ex-leader of the Labour Party, was "closer to the Indian masses than any other leader"
He paints a picture of her as a virtual saint, a kind, caring, loving benevolent world leader. (She was after all a member of the Labour Party in her time as a student in England).
Of course, Foot has to recognise a few unpleasant facts. In 1975 she refused to accept a parliamentary decision that she resign, suspended parliament and declared a State of Emergency. Her opponents, from capitalist politicians to trade union militants, were rounded up and imprisoned.
Comrade Foot benignly comments on her "power of decision in a crisis, a readiness to act alone". When he met her during the Emergency, he was deepiy impressed.
*I was told she would never another democratic election; I came away with the certainty that she would do exactly that.
The Indian people were so impressed with the whole affair that when Gandhi did call an election - in 1977 — they resolutely refused to elect her. For Foot, the whole episode merely showed how marvellous Gandhi was: "when she accepted defeat with such grace and nobility and resilience [it] was probably the most important moment in the history of Indian democracy."
Foot - who places great emphasis on his credentials as a 'democratic socialist' - thus puts forward the astonishing argument that when a self-appointed dictator is forced to accept defeat in an election, it is the dictator who wins a glorious victory for democracy by having the grace to get out.
Of course tris was not the only example of Indira Gandhi's taste for overruling democratic decisions. When her party lost a state election in Andhra Pradeshi last year. she promptly dismissed the candidate - NT Rama Rao — who had had the audacity to beat her although he was later reinstated. She has made similar moves in many other states. Foot makes no comment.
As for her family, Foot thinks it is a wonderful institution. The late Sanjay may have committed few excesses during the Emergency — like a mass sterilisation programme - but Foot prefers to forget it (except to say that "she suffered a mother's agony when she saw them pilloried or, as she believed, defamed").
Power
Nor does the fact that power now goes into the hands of Gandhi's son - an old-fashioned dynastic succession if ever there was one - call for any comment.
Foot even makes a virtue ouf of Gandhi's notorious insistence that more and more power be concentrated in her hands.
Foot can only praise the programme of a relatively powerful copitalist class for al united India' — an India where a superwealthy few rule over millions in absolute poverty, and where ethnic minorities, Muslims, and now even the relatively well-off Sikhs are harassed and persecuted.
It says a lot about Foot's democratic, never mind his socialist credentials.
The Morning Star, meanwhile comments that Mrs Gandhi was *the current chair of the Non-Aligned Movement and a powerful, progressive figure internationally on the Third World and United Nations stages."
Such a shame that she was *increasingly adopting repressive right wing policies at home"
The Morning Star does not mention that the Moscow-line Indian Communist Party supported Gandhi's Emergency decrees in 1975-77, saying that it was necessary to protect the 'national democratic Congress regime against 'reactionaries' The chief recommendation for Gandhi cited by the Star is her "policy of close friendship with the Soviet Union"