Split will help right wing
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
THE Broad Left in the civil service union CPSA split last weekend, November 3.
95 supporters of the 'Labour Group' and the Communist Party walked out soon after the start of the almost 400-strong conference. -The CPSA Broad Left has been the strongest such body in the British trade union movement, with a large active membership and currently a majority on the union's national executive.
This split wil! help the right wing. Rank and file left activists will be dismayed by a split which has been generated by factional rivalries at National Executive level: and the CPSA's first-past-the-post election system means that the right wing can walk straight through the middle of two rival left slates.
The stated reason for the split was that 'Militant's current drive for hegemony and unflinching orthodoxy is incompatible with other socialists attempting to work with them in the same organisation."
Hard left But the hard-left Socialist Caucus faction — which opposes Militant politically just as much as, and perhaps more than, the soft-left splitters do - rejected the walk-out. Speaking on behalf of the Caucus, lan Leedham said that the arguments of the soft left were just like those used by witch-hunters in the Labour Party against Militant.
In fact the specific charges cited by the soft left were all to do with Militant allegedly being harsh or "sectarian " in criticism of the behaviour of soft-left NEC members. The truth is that - whatever exaggerated language may or may not have been used - those NEC members deserve criticism.
Behind their talk of "tolerance" and "open debate" 11 seems that electoral/careerist calculations motivate the soft left's split.
Militant did not have "complete control" of the Broad Left, but it was strong enough-to get supporters at last weekend's conference voted to censure all the Broad Left members on the NEC. (Steve Battlemuch, moving the censure motion, underlined that it was not directed only against the soft left.)
As the Socialist Caucus bulletin put it, "Neither side of the fracture has any right to claim the original heritage of the Broad Left as a body which aspired to campaign and fight for socialist policies on the basis of mobilising rank and file support...
The split therefore makes il very urgent to build the Socialist Caucus and to give it a higher profile as a principled, rank-and file-oriented, Left in the union.
There are good possibilitie: for doing this - especially if the Socialist Workers Party, who have just come into the Broad Left, and other hard left activist: who have stayed outside thi Caucus until now, join in.
A bold effort to build up thi Socialist Caucus is vital — and i must include a policy for reuni fying the left.
While Militant and th CP/soft Labour Left faction wer the biggest groups in the pre split Broad Left, a lot of Broa Left members are outside th main factions. It seems tha most of those members outsid the main factions stayed wit the Broad Left last weekend.
But developments in th membership at large will no necessarily mirror those at th conference. Partly because ( the press propaganda, an partly because of Militant wooden politics and heav handed methods, a lot of th less-committed Broad Le supporters are likely to grav tate to the soft left bloc.
It will seem more mainstreal and not much less militar industrially.
In other words, a large pr portion of the activists on who!
efforts to develop militant trad unionism in CPSA must deper are likely to be pulled behind th soft left leaders. Serious socia ists will have to find a way relate to them and combat ti leaders' influence.
Conferences
The Socialist Caucus needs draw up detailed proposals f united left action both on cal paigning issues and for ele tions.
All these questions will debated closely among CP!
activists over the coming wee!
in preparation for a series meetings in early December.
On Thursday 6th there is CPSA special conference decide on the 1985 pay claim.
On the 7th the soft le (Broad Left '84, as they ha now styled themselves) | called a conference. The Soci ist Caucus is planning to have open meeting on that eveni and the next day, Saturday& there is a reconvened cont ence of the Militant-major Broad Left