[We are now three weeks into the latest…]
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
We are now three weeks into the latest Coal Board-Government offensive, using a hardfaced refusal to negotiate plus the payment of accrued bonuses before Christmas to push miners into strike-breaking.
Thanks to the pressures of over eight months on strike, the offensive has had some success. But it is still a matter of limited bleeding rather than a cut at the jugular of the strike.
Significantly, some of the largest return-to-work figures have been on the edges of the Notts coalfield, where there has been large-scale scabbing throughout the strike. The Coal Board has not qualitatively shifted the balance between scab pits and striking pits on a national scale.
The point of the offensive was to break the strike — or to go a significant way towards that — and in that it has clearly failed. Even using the NCB's own figures, their campaign has scarcely dented the main strike-bound areas. The number working is still only 0.4% in South Wales and a claimed 3% in Yorkshire.
And it has begun to slow down. On Monday, 19th, they were claiming a record number of new starts - 2282 - but on Tuesday, 20th, the figure had slumped to 900.
One of the main ingredients in the latest offensive - the offer of accrued bonuses, etc., before Christmas — finishes by the end of the week. The Coal Board could possibly extend their deadline a second time, but to do so would undermine their present confident, arrogant face.
The NUM points out that the Coal Board's figures massively overstate the number scabbing - overall, the NUM puts the figure at around 51,000. 140,000 miners are solidly on strike.
One miner pointed out to socialist Organiser that TV pictures of coal on a conveyor belt, supposedly just mined by a colliery now working, hau bcci in fact taken off a stockpile.
Closer look Even in the individual pits where the NCB has had some success, a closer look reveals the continued strength of the NUM. At Ellington colliery (Northumberland), where on Sunday, 18th, branch secretary John Cunningham made a much-publicised announcement that he would be scabbing on Monday, less than 200 crossed the picket line.
At the two pits which come under the South Yorkshire NUM but are geographically in Nottinghamshire - Manton and Shireoaks - significant scabbing started last week.
About 300 have gone back at Manton, 400 at Shireoaks. But this is just 25% and 40% of the workforces.
The refusal of NACODS members at Manton last week to abide by branch decisions and respect picket lines, creates the possibility of coal producWOMEN AGAINST PIT CLOSURES RALLY In Cardiff, December 8 March from Cardiff Museum, Civic Centre, at noon to rally in Sophia Gardens. Speakers include Anne Scargill; speakers from Barking Hospital and Greenham Peace Camp also invited.
The event is primarily for women but not women-only by the miners.
succeeding."
tion there — but the state of the pit makes it unlikely for a number of weeks. At Shireoaks, the depunes nave ottu respruung picket lines so far.
In other areas, the deputies are not crossing and underground production is still impossible. Indeed, an attempt by the NCB to force deputies to cross picket lines in Scotland last week came close to provoking a new clash with NACODS. Taken as a whole, most new scabs are not the coal-producing face-workers.
In fact, the value of the scabs to the NCB over the last three weeks has been for propaganda only.
Possibly, at a later date, they "1. 1 1 - 1 - 41. could facilitate an attempt to try to use and move coal stocks at strike-bound pits. At Kiveton Park it is reported that the 26 scabs are being trained to use the washeries at the pit, which the stock-piled coal will have to go through before it is useable in power stations.
With the rapid winding down and failure of the latest offensive, and the continued strength of the strike, the pressure will shift back to the NCB and the government.
With 'General Winter' now arrived, there are reports of massively coal stocks and action Willis and Kinnock plant a tree for the Tolpuddle Martyrs.
Breaking the law is fine as long as its 150 years ago.
already reduced by workGeorge Foulkes, Labour MP (Carrick, Tumnock and Doon Valley) ers at power stations having an effect.
The POEU reports that ronountras hard hoon haunht in generalis nave vecu uvuğı m by British Telecom because of reduced power. 'Energy conservation' is the name given by the Generating Board to the reduction of power elsewhere.
A number of trade union leaders would clearly like to try to force the NUM into a sellout — but they do not feel strong enough to make a move. TUC general secretary Norman Willis condemns pickets' violence, right-wingers Alan Tuffin and Tony Christopher say the NUM must make concessions - but the transport unions ana major eleciricity ____. manindo alantainites supply unions are still officially giving support, and met on Monday, 19th, to coordinate solidarity action. Even Neil Kinnock felt forced to attend a miners' meeting in his own constituency to explain his disgraceful role.
The NUM Executive last Thursday decided to move in two directions — a series of pit village rallies up until Christmas, aimed to keep the strike strong; and approaches to organisations that have supported the strike. Among others, Salmon the NUM is approaching the bishops — a move which some rank and file miners see as a sign of weakness.
But other strikers reckon that the NUM is right to use any backing it can get as long as that does not mean weakening the rank and file struggle — and the NUM leaders' main call has certainly been to the rank and file of other unions to take action.
The situation at Austin Rover underlines the urgency of that appeal.
The Tories are out to break the arms and legs of effective trade unionism. The open treachery of right-wing union leaders like the EETPU's Eric Hammond and the AUEW's Terry Duffy, and the inaction of supposed left-wingers like Moss Evans and Ron Todd of the TGWU, is allowing them to do that.
When the Tories deployed their anti-union laws against the Austin-Rover workers, the AUEW and EETPU leaders actively sided with the Tories -while the TGWU sat silent, saying no evil, hearing no evil, seeing no evil...taking no action.
They let the strike be sabotaged — and they will not necessarily have saved themselves from legal action.
Now — according to the well-informed Financial Times "senior trade union leaders... feel the time may be approaching for the TUC to reconsider its blanket refusal to comply with the government's labour laws rather than constantly see union finances threatened by legal action"
Let the miners go down to defeat, and the 'New Realism' — open collaboration with the Tories — will be in full flower.
But the miners haven't gone down! and they aren't going down!
So the TUC leaders can't rush openly into the arms of the Tories. They can't avoid giving the rank and file a limited opening for action by verbal support for the NUM.
Potential
And despite the terrible defeat at Austin Rover, the potential for spreading the struggle is still there. Council workers in London are organising against the cuts as never before. Ford women workers are on strike, in a repeat of their historic dispute of 1967.
Talk of a general strike seems light-years away now. But that remains the logical response by the labour movement to the Tory offensive. The situation still has explosive potential. The arguments still need to be pushed. The political preparation for future crises still needs to be done.
Stand firm, fight for solidarity, and the miners will win!
Paul Whetton is secretary of the Notts miners' rank and file strike committee, writing in a personal capacity.
KEN LIVINGSTONE coming up to the miners' welfare was quite a boost for us.
It was obvious that the police were prepared for him - they were so nice and so polite on the picket line.
But then Ken Livingstone addressed quite a crowd in the welfare. He spoke briefly, but it was very much to the point. When we asked for questions and comments at the end, there was only one, and that was a sound condemnation of Kinnock for refusing to address the rallies or to come down fair and square on the miners' side.
I've seen Kinnock has been claiming that he has supported the miners from day one. I suppose he may be correct in a certain sense. He has said, I support the miners' • But his actions have declared exactly the opposite.
I don't think the rope at the Aberafan rally was so much a noose meant for Norman Willis, as for the trade union leaders generally. Unless they pull their fingers out and come up with the promises that were made at the TUC conference, then the leadership of the TUC might as well go and hang themselves.
And we'll go to the rank and file. In fact, we're doing that already, even in power stations and places where we wouldn't expect 100 per cent support. The attempts are bearing fruit.
We've started picketing the power stations regularly in Notts, but it's too early as yet to give any definite results.
I think over the next week or two the Coal Board attempt to persuade the public that there is a mass return to work is going to be shown up for what it is.
I don't think a general strike will come before Christmas. But the state of the pound, and the balance of payments and so on, could well move into crisis. Big business is going to start to get the shakes.
Also, we're looking forward to the first snow. Let's see them shift coal when there's a couple of feet of snow on the ground.
24*- mister it *73.
I think possibly around Christmas time or the New Year could all come together.
The Church of England has been called the Tory party at prayer. When they start coming forward, it just shows you how serious things have got.
But I would urge every• body not to tie great hopes to the Church coming across with anything. I'm not look. ing for any miracles.
Rallies and meetings in every pit village are very important now. The fat has been stripped off the strike and all we've got is the hard core out. We ought to go out to show that we're not ashamed of being on strike. We're not apologising. We're out, and we're out till we win.
At the weekend I was down in London for a demonstration in Hackney. It was well-attended, and there was a speaker from the car workers.
Some people took excep. tion to my remarks in the col umn last week about twin ning.
At the start of the dispute we tried to dissuade people from twinning, because we saw problems that some pits were going to get well looked after and others weren't. But at the same time, twinning is important insofar as people actually meet people .people who would otherwise never have come together are starting to do that, and | think that's the positive side of twinning.
It's also made sure that the finances to keep the dispute going are not affected by al the Christmas stuff being bandied about - plum puddings and turkeys. We can't put turkeys in petrol tanks to get people to the picket lines.
It is important that fami lies get that sort of thing for Christmas, but it is vital that communities that at any other time have no common ground are coming together now. That's part of the class consciousness that's coming out of the dispute.
So I think twinning is important. But twinning and support work can go hand in hand.
I've heard that some of the new scabs have been getting into fights with the old scabs. That's an indica tion of the depth of feeling. Most of these scabs who have just gone in have literally been forced back and were quite aware that if the other scabs had come out in the first place the dispute might be over and won by now.
The fighting also points to the great difficulties we're go. ing to have when we go back.
Coal stocks in the Notts coalfield have virtually gone now, and the only stuff they're taking out now is current production. Our information is that the current production is down by as much as a third.
But we haven't got accurate information on the stocks at the power stations: • •
Scan page 4
Socialist Organiser no. 206 November 21 1984 Page 4 Back miners
----- pull-quotes -----
DG DI STORY
ranks Paul WI strike
etton's diary