Behind famine, thr drive for profits 1he greatest plague of all
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
We know about famine in Ethiopia.
But 45,000 have also died, and millions are threatened, in north-east Brazil.
The greatest plague of all is not drought but exploitation, argues buying-power, in a world where in the Third World as a whole. the very basics of life are a An enormously rapid rate of matter of buying and selling - industrial growth after the milithat leads to famine. Food is tary coup of 1964 led people to there, but the poor cannot afford speak of the Brazilian 'economic it. miracle'. In steel production JAMES Bruce was a Scottish traveller who visited Ethiopia in the eighteenth century. Seeing that the farmers were "always poor and miserable", he tried to analyse the causes.
Natural disasters were part of the problem, but " ... to these plagues may be added still one, the greatest of them all, bad government"
Today, what has made disaster into a catastrophe is not just "bad government" in Ethiopia alone. It is an insane international economic system, made worse by the political needs of major powers, and the Ethiopian government.
Ethiopia has seen many famines - the earliest on record was in the ninth century. A faminen 1972-4 played a part in toppling the Emperor Haile Selassie.
But, like elsewhere in the world, famine is not the result of natural causes alone. Nor does famine cause the poverty of the people who are left alive when the rains finally come.
Rather, it is poverty — and terrible inequalities in wealth — that cause famine.
Rainy seasons followed by dry seasons are typical of the climate of many parts of Africa and other areas today afflicted by mass starvation. What makes a dry season into a calamity is not only the size and quality of the last harvest: it is the inability of the farmers to save their food for the dry weather.
Social and economic
Ethiopia is a typical example of the social and economic causes of this problem. Until 1974, when the new regime of the Derg introduced a land reform, the Ethiopian peasant was plagued by exploitation from landowners.
In the south and west, where land was — in the main — owned privately, the Ethiopian tenant farmer had to pay four different kinds of tax on the land: education tax, health tax, a tithe to the church (a tenth of the land's produce), and land tax proper — which could be up to three quarters of the farmer's total product.
Landlords, on the other hand, paid no tax at all. And the tenant had all sorts of other obligations to the landlord.
In the north, although land tended to be owned communally, peasants still had to hand over half their produce in taxes.
So the landlords got wealthier, whilst the tenant farmers or northern peasants were left with barely enough to survive. Drought would leave them starving.
At the same time, tens of thousands of kilometres of arable land remained uncultivated. It was in the interests of the landlords not to extend the area of land under cultivation, so as to maintain high rents for their tenants.
Capitalist
The development of capitalist agriculture, producing crops for the market, often made things worse.
The Chilalo Agricultural Development Unit (CADU), set up in 1967, aimed to 'increase the productivity of rich and middle peasants and tenants through agricultural innovation, credits and marketing"
In its first two years of operation, 538 tenants were forced to leave their land, 'and 500 or so families were evicted. By 1975 - after the Derg came to power - according to the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia, "more than 5,000 tenant households have been evicted since the project began"
Mechanical commercial farms did not need as much labour — si tenants lost their lands. Fur-her. commercial farming push=i de cents. pricing poor peas=..u o: the market.
= cate-herding communthe Arrash Clive Bradley Valley suttered even more. Since the early 1960s, the valley has increasingly been turned over to the commercial production of cotton and rice. Whilst the Afar's feudal overlord and various international companies were sold concessions to farm the land, the Afar nomads got nothing.
They were forced into the less fertile areas, which could not support all their cattle. So when drought came in 1972, the cattle starved - and so did the Afar.
It was a similar story elsewhere, where peasants forced off their land turned to less fertile areas in order to survive. The land was overworked, and serious erosion of the soil took place — until it was impossible to grow any more food. This contributed to the famine.
Simple techniques to conserve water from the wet season were not developed.
The Derg introduced a land reform - from above - when they came to power in 1974. But it left a lot of the problems untouched. Transport is not efficient, so food cannot easily be distributed, and too little money has been spent on improving agricultural techniques.
Also, the Derg is a dictatorship. which has brutally repressed opposition. In a country with about 40 million people but a poor economy, it is not surprising that the military rulers will cream off resources for themselves, contributing to the poverty of the masses.
The situation in the north -where most of the publicity has been concentrated — is aggravated by guerilla war. A war of independence in Eritrea began in 1962. With Soviet and Cuban backing, the Derg has continued Haile Selassie's war against Eritrea; and, since 1975, against the people of Tigray too.
Eritrea
These wars produce thousands of refugees, hinder food distribution and aggravate all the causes of famine. Granting the peoples of Eritrea and Tigray their right to self-determination would help the poor enormously.
The wars have added to all the social problems inherited from the past to produce the terrible scenes we have seen on TV of people dying in Korem.
Famine rages in the south, too, partly as a result of a huge influx of refugees from Tigray.
Soil erosion has also hit cattle-herders. If they are forced to sell badly-fed livestock, they get a low price, and cannot buy the grain they need to eat, because grain is in short supply and its price has soared.
Again, it is poverty — lack of Added to all this is the lack of overseas food aid from the West because Ethiopia is an ally of fast. the USSR.
So one of the characteristic causes of famine in Ethiopia — terrible poverty. and elsewhere — is the legacy of pre-capitalist society, given a particular tragic twist by elements of capitalist development.
The ruination of pre-capitalist peasant economy by the spread of capitalist relations in the countryside is a common trend in the Third World. It is a funda- mostly unemployed labourers. mental factor in causing famine right across the world. The detailed social background, however, varies widely in different parts of the Third World.
In Brazil there is also a terrible famine. But there it results not so much from feudal relations being maintained as the worst affected areas. from the brutal fashion in which capitalism is sweeping away those relations and pushing ahead its own development.
Brazil is the biggest induslosses stuff their faces while millions starv is 150% — unofficially it is nearer 200%. During 1983, rice and beans - the staple diet of Brazil's poor — rose in price by 188% and 769% respectively. Coffee rose by 200%. Wages have lagged far The poor are forced to buy elementary foods like cookingoil by the spoonful from local shops at marked-up prices.
Some 40 million people live in conditions of extreme poverty. Conditions are worst in the least-developed NorthEast.
Faminę has forced thousands of people to tiee to the coastal cities in search of work. But there is very little work there. 12 million are officially unemployed, but real unemployment is vastly greater.
The north-east, nicknamed the 'Drought Polygon' by Brazil's dictator Getulio Vargas trial power in Latin America or in the 1930s, has been hit by drought and famine many times before. In 1877-9, half a million people died of starvation.
The drought today is afflicting an ever wider area of Brazil. According to the BrazilBrazil matches the UK, and in ian government, over 15 million car production it is catching up people are currently suffering directly from hunger and thirst.
But the 'miracle' brought with In the state of. Pernambuco, it massive inequalities and 45,000 have already_died as the result of the drought. Disease Historically Brazil has been and malnutrition are widedominated by huge feudal-type spread. estates. Those feudal-type estates have been. more and 35 million people more transformed into capitalist enterprises. The peasants have live in Brazil's been forced off the land, creaNine years ago, an official 45,000, according survey found that two thirds of to official figures, Brazil's population were undernourished. Today, the north- have already died east of Brazil is hit by tamine of drought. Disaster threatens the 24 million people living in and 15 million are The miracle' is in severe suffering directly crisis. Brazil has the largest foreign debt in the third world, from hunger and standing at £80 billion at the thirs end of 1983. Officially inflation
Scan page 7
In the first two articles of this series on the causes of Third World poverty, Martin Thomas argued that those causes are not natural, but rooted in the history of capitalism; and he examined the history of colonialism in Africa. This third article is about British rule in India. guaranteed the hereditary use of Marx the ruling class would be allo- research, Marx was mistaken in cated districts where they held his belief that the British had sway as tax-collectors for the also allowed the decay of irriThe Brazilian government is planning investment of £153 jillion in infrastructure: a tiny raction of this money could irrigate the inorth-east and save the starving.
To pay off its foreign debt, he government is maintaining ts policy of agricultural export production - often foodstuffs or cattle abroad. Aid being sent o Brazil — for example, a pronised £202 million from the extremely rich. 9 per cent of landowners possess nearly 82% of the land in the north-east, and 15 landowners own as much acreage as the 363,776 smallholders put together.
From the beginning of colonisation by the Portuguese in the 16th century, agriculture in the north east has been geared to the export market. Slaves were imported from Africa when the local population would' not be forced to do the work - and slavery was not abolished until 1888.
From the 19th century, the semi-arid interior in the northeast, known as the 'sertao' was cultivated for cotton exports. Producing for export did little to meet the needs of the thousands of workers who migrated to the sertao.
The drought now is further shifting the balance in favour of capital-intensive agriculture. Thousands of smallholders have been forced off their lands and forced to migrate to the cities.or die.
Speculation
Government policy has worsened the situation. Funds for agricultural credit have been used to help the big landlords in agribusiness (who often have used the money for non-agricultural or speculative investment).
Irrigation schemes have most benefited those least affected by the drought cycle.
The Emergency Work Fronts in practice viciously exploit the victims of drought. One EWF labourer commented, "At the end of the drought, the landowners will have dams and fences that we've built and we will have nothing"
The landlords, on the other hands, are enormously grateful for the 'help' provided for them by the EWFs.
So, while the famine in Africa is in no small part the fault of economic backwardness made worse by the internatiomal capitalist system — poverty and famine in north-east Brazil is the social cost of dynamic capitalist development. The end result is much the same — and it shows that today capitalist 'civilisation' can only bring the old horrors back in new forms for the peoples of the Third World.
But there is a difference.
ui WHEN black Africa was put under colonial rule by Britain in the late 19th century, it had already been shattered and devastated by four centuries of the slave trade. But the India conquered by the British from the mid-18th century was a great and splendid empire.
European trading bases had existed in India since the early 16th century, but they had exported manufactured goods — for India had an industrial sector producing luxury goods which Europe could not match."* But Britain: imposed restrictions on textile imports from India, and promoted exports from the new cotton mills of Lancashire. 'The handicraft industries were destroyed - the same which had supplied the eastern trade of more than a thousand years and had provided Greek and Roman, Arab and Venetian, English and Portuguese traders with their wealth. 'The bones of the weavers' -and an English GovernorGeneral said it [in 1834-5] — were 'bleaching the plains of India'."** Elite The Mughal Empire - the regime before the British conquest — had not been a progressive system. A tiny elite, musuy anen m urgm drersian vi mantle aline in rainin /Doorion no Afghan) and in , 'religion (Muslim), lived in luxury through extremely heavy taxation of the peasants.
But the British continued many of the evils of the old regime and added some new ones.
Under Mughal rule, all land had been owned by the Emperor: these positions were not hereditary.
The British half-transformed this set-up. In Bengal and some other areas, the Mughal taxcollectors were given a status which was half landlord, half tax-collector. This, landlord/ tax-collector classrapidly expanded under British rule, generating a sub-class of middlemen.
In southern India the British worked differently. There, the higher-caste peasants were given quasi-smallholder status, but with the colonial government as overlard., Karl Marxy/commented: "In Bengal, we have a combination of English Landloraism, of the Irish middlemen system, of the Austrian system, transtorming the landlord into the tax-gatherer, and of the Asiatic system making the State the real landlord.
'In Madras and Bombay we have a French peasant proprietor who is at the same time a sert and a metayer [sharecropper| of the State.
•The drawbacks of all these various systems accumulate upon him [the peasant] without his enjoying any of their redeeming features."
The peasants had no access to resources to improve their agriculture. And if by chance they should get access, the benefit of any improvement would immediately be confiscated by the landgation works established under the Mughals: the Mughals' irrigation works were slight, and were in fact expanded in certain districts by the British. Overall, however, agricultural productivity increased barely at all, or maybe even decreased. during two centuries of British rule.
Above the relentless peasant poverty, the British replaced the Mughals, with the same vast luxury, display, and armies of servants. By the 1930s, maybe one-tenth of India's whole national income was flowing to Britain, and another slice was being consumed by the British administration in India itself.
The maintenance, in modified form, of the old social structures in the countryside also enabled cheaper and easier rule. Britain's land reform, wrote the Governor-General in 1829, "though a failure in many other respects and in most important essentials, has this great advantage at least, of having created a vast body of rich landed proprietors deeply. interested in the continuance of the British dominion and having complete command over the mass of the But there was after all a difference between Britain and the Mughals. The Mughals' wealth was just luxury and display. The wealth of the British was capital. and degradation?
'The Indians will not reap the fruits of the new elements of society scattered among them by the British bourgeoisie, till in Great Britain itself the now ruling classes shall have been supplanted by the industrial proletariat, or till the Hindus themselves shall have grown strong enough to throw off the English yoke altogether."
In any case the growth of factory production in India was very slow. There was a spurt of industrialisation around the First World War, and steel production was started then, much earlier than in most Third World countries. The Indian capitalist class, by the time of independence, was far stronger than any capitalist class in black
----- pull-quotes -----
ting a huge army of landless and North-East.
following five successive years from the famine,
hypered How Britain ruined India