How racism broke Billie
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
on the jazz singer Billie ' Fotel, so thaf the white guests est talent and the bravest spirit. 'THE Long Night of Lady Day" BBCZ's recent 'Arena' documentary on singer Billie Holliday, made pretty depressing viewing.
At the age of ten, Billie was raped by a 40 year old man. For this, she was punished and sent away to a Catholic borstal.
34 years later, as she lay dying in a hospital bed, New York's finest burst in and arrested her on a narcotics charge.
In between, she suffered more than her fair share of misery at the hands of cops, prison warders, pimps, pushers and rednecks - not to mention the various chancers and inadequates she had affairs with.
Despite (or perhaps because of) all that, she was beyond question the finest jazz singer of her time — and probably, the finest of any time. And it was the singing that provided the moments of joy in the 'Arena' documentary.
Young Billie, with her voice somehow innocent and worldlywide at the same time, singing 'I'll Never Be the Same"' , with Lester Young making the tenor sax sing along with her every step of the way. Middle-aged Billie, haggard beyond her years, singing Fine and Mellow" and shaking her head wistfully as the same Lester Young stepped unsteadily from the ranks of the "All Star" studio band to take a slightly out of tune, but beautifully constructed, solo.
and Mellow" was the best moment of the film — for a few minutes the pain subsided into the background and the music was all that mattered. Within a cuple of years of the 1957 TV special, both Lester Young and Billie were dead.
In many ways Billie was a pathetic figure. She was bitterly resentful of the oppression she experienced both as a negro and as a woman. But somehow she seemed to accept that oppression as inevitable — as the way things had to be and the way they always would be. Her 'escape' was heroin.
Billie was not, however, the most pathetic figure in the film. Artie Shaw achieved that distinction. The wealthy bandleader appeared in a present-day interview, describing how he agreed to ask Billie to use the freinht elevator in a New York looks at BBC2's would not be upset. "It's up to you, Billie.. it's your decision... I don'tike it any more than you do" , he bleated.
Shaw had hired Billie for his otherwise all-white big band because he wanted the best singer available as part of his bid to oust Benny Goodman as 'King of Swing'. He recognised Billie's worth as a singer, and he knew about racism: he has written books about his own experiences of anti-semitism. But Shaw went alonge with segregation.
Maybe he hoped to break down race barriers by stealth. Maybe he was only interested in a fast buck. Either way, he made Billie sit out of sight, backstage, between numbers.
When the band toured the Jim Crow southern states, Shaw's timidity was excusable. To have Billie shout 'Motherfucker' at red-necks in the audience would have been to invite a riot. But in New York, by the 1940s, some brave souls like critic John Hammond and record producer Milt Gabler (botti featured in the film) were taking on segregation and promoting jazz events where black musicians and audiences mixed on equal terms with whites.
We can only conclude that Artie Shaw lacked guts.
Perhaps it is unfair to seize on Shaw as the villain of the piece. His contribution to the film was particularly cowardly, but he wasn't responsible for the racism, the heroin, the prison term or any of the other manifestations of the Great American Dream that finally broke Billie.
If you missed the 'Arena' film, make sure you catch it when the inevitable repeat comes round, or chase up your wealthy friends with videos. To find out more about Billie Holliday and the jazz world of the '3Õs and '40s, read John Chilton's definitive biography, 'Billie's Blues"
To hear Billie at her best get hold of the classic '30s recordings with Lester Young and Teddy Wilson (available on the CBS albums 'God Bless the Child' and Billie Holliday German albums 'I'll be Seeing you' and 'Fine and Mellow').
Tögether with the 'Arena' film, these will tell you a lot -not just about a great singer, but also about how institutionalised racism can crush the bright-
----- pull-quotes -----
documentary Holliday
Story') and the Commodore recordings from the '40s (on the