Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Lenin today

Socialist Organiser no. 206, 21 November 1984 · scan p. 8 · about 978 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Continuing

our 'Socialist Bookshelf' series on Marxist Colin Foste looks at Lenin's What is to be Done?' LENIN'S pamphlet 'What is to be Done?' has had a strange tate.

All the declared enemies of Leninism cite it as proof of Lenin's 'dictatorial' politics. The pamphlet, they say, advocates a militarily-organised elite which will control and substitute for the struggle of the working class: the horrors of Stalinism are only the logical unfolding of that programme.

Meanwhile Stalinists interpret the pamphlet similarly but with different valuation. The struggle for socialism, they say, requires rigid ultra-centralised discipline, and in 'What is to be Done?' Lenin lays out the arguments to prove this.

Many would-be Trotskyists, unfortunately, have had much the same view as the Stalinists.

To read the pamphlet after hearing all these polemics is a puzzling experience. True, there are odd sentences which can be cited to give a shine of plausibility to the conventional interpretations: but the bulk of the argument is clearly about something else altogether.

Far from being a tract against loose, liberal Menshevik concepts of organisation, What is to be Done?' was written (in 19012) before Bolshevism and Menshevism emerged (in 1903). The future Mensheviks supported 'What is to be Done?' - only in the heat of later polemics did they discover "dictatorial' tendencies in it.

Rosa Luxemburg When Rosa Luxemburg joined in these accusations that Lenin was 'dictatorial', Lenin merely replied that she did not understand the actual situation in Russia. And indeed, Lenin's Bolshevik party was never the dissent-suppressing monolith of Stalinist and hostile legend.

A look at the circumstances in which 'What is to be Done?' was written sheds light on its real meaning and its real relevance for today.

From the middle of the 19th century, masses of student youth in Russia had been in rebellion against the Tsarist system.

For decades, however, there was no substantial revolutionary social force to which they could attach themselves. They tried to go to the peasantry. They tried to 'electrify' the masses by assassinations of leading Tsarist figures.

Then in the 1890s the Russian working class came onto the scene. as añ independent force. Revolutionaries a Lenin among Early Communist poster shows L capitalists and priests from the ea them - threw themselves into supporting strikes and writing factory leaflets.

So far, so good. But towards the end of the 1890s, so Lenin thought, many would-be Marxists went overboard and did nothing but agitation on economic issues.

The political agitation and theoretical debate which used to be the staple of Russian revolutionaries were pushed aside. Politics and theory would grow out of the economic struggle in due course, said these 'Econom: ists' Formally all the Russian Marxists -operated under the banner of the Russian Social Democratic Labour Party, founded in 1898. In fact the 1898 Congress had done little more than adopt a declaration of principles before all the delegates were arrested, and no centralised party structure existed. Nor would it exist for some time, if the Economists' exclusive focus on day-to-day local factory agitation were allowed to dominate. nin sweeping kings, emperors; th.

political and ideological struggle to ensure otherwise.

•'The working class spontaneously gravitates towards socialism" - that, said Lenin, is true. But there is also a "spontaneous" tendency i.e. a tendency inbuilt in capitalist society, for capitalist politics to impose itself on even a militant working class.

1905 Three years later, during the 1905 revolution in Russia, Lenin wrote: "The working class is instinctively, spontaneously Social-Democratic [i.e. in the usage of the time, socialist], and more than ten years of work put in by Social-Democracy has done a great deal to transform this spontaneity into consciousness"

The efforts of organised revolutionaries could in no way substitute for the tremendous creative potential of mass working class struggle. But unless organised revolutionaries did their work adequately, that potential would be dissipated; spontaneity would not be transformed into consciousness.

To weld together a coherent, conscious working class offensive, capable of victory, something was needed from "outside" the immediate spontaneous struggle. That something from outside was the effort, by a minority of socialists organised in advance of the entry into revolutionary struggle of the mass of the class, to develop a consistent revolutionary theory and give it organised expression.

Lenin quoted Engels: Socialism, since it has become a science, demands that it be pursued as a science, i.e. that it be studied" • And he added: •Without a revolutionary theory there can be no revolutionary movement. This thought cannot be insisted upon too strongly at a time when the fashionable preaching of opportunism goes hand in hand with an infatuation for the narrowest forms of practical activity."

This emphasis won Lenin, throughout his life, accusations of being a doctrinaire hairsplitter, a fanatical dogmatist, someone who pursued intricate theoretical arguments at the expense of the real practical work.

But Lenin told the Economists that the world of politics and the battle of ideas would not disappear just because the Economists ignored them. If socialists did not take up the class struggle on the political and ideological fronts, then they would just leave the battlefield open to the capitalist class, its media, and all its agents.

RelevanceR

The central practical proposal defended in 'What is to be Done?' is thus the publication of an all-Russian socialist newspaper, giving political agitation and theoretical debate equal weight with economic issues, and preparing the groundwork for a real party.

Today, paradoxically, Lenin's arguments are most relevant both against the 'anti-party' non-aligned socialists, who believe that the movement would somehow turn out all right if only the Left would suspend theoretical arguments; and against the formally 'proparty' socialists of the Socialist Workers' Party, whose attitude to the Labour Party comes down to saying: "Let Labour take care of the parliamentary politics. The SWP takes care of the rest."

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 206

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →