Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Inner-city blues

Socialist Organiser no. 206, 21 November 1984 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,292 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Bari Maneko asks why tower have been a housing disaster TOWER blocks of family accommodation were the inevitable result of the way the state has developed its housing policy, especially in that period when the Labour Party was holding one of the reins.

In the sixties, when most of these stacks of 'dwelling units' were put up, the name of the game was numbers, and paternalistic politicians, busily eradicating the slums of terraced houses, lapped up the professionals' advice. You can bet your last raffled miner's lamp that the input from the working class, especially from women, at any level in the design, bureaucratic and construction stages of building those monstrosities was less than 2%.

The result today is that the Tories can point to these disasters and say, 'look, that's the result of state housing provision' ', we're for freedom. of choice. Buy a council house'.

Of course the tenants in the tower blocks aren't buying flats, but campaigning to get out and demolish the blocks.

Failure

No-one doubts that the tower block is a failure in social terms - with the isolation from street activity, the sky only views; the lift access problems, (ever tried to find an address on the 18th Iloor in a power cut?); and the noise transmission problems of having neighbours on four sides.

Tenants end up worrying whether their kids in the next room are about to fall out of the window, worrying how they are going to call the older children in for a meal; trying to locate the leak from the flat six stories above; trying to fix a shelf to a granite aggregate concrete wall; trying to stop the toddler leaning against the urinated lift wall when they're piled up with shopping; starting yet another campaign 70 .get the neighbours to stop dropping bottles down the refuse chute in the middle of the night and wondering if they'll have to stand upright in their coffin wher they're carried out.

The architects would tell !ou the blocks were designed as 'machines for living in'. And of course putting all these people up in the air freed the ground level for wonderful parkland.

Technically, alongside school buildings, tower blocks are the most obvious examples of attempts to apply industrialised methods to the building industry. The argument was that the workforce was becoming deskilled, and factory production would produce higher quality components, easier planning and higher production. Good for capitalism; bad for UCATI.

Untortunately, the powersthat-be did not correctly analyse the market, or the composition of the industry, and virtually all industrialised building systems have failed, through too small a scale of production and too much experimentation.

Most office blocks are openplan forms and frame construction. However the cell form of our homes, the fire regulations and noise insulation requirements led some of the systems firms to adopt precast concrete slab forms of construction.

The particular system for Ronan Point was Scandinavian in origin, but was never used much there for buildings over six stories. It basically stacks up like playing cards, the precast floor slabs resting on precast wall slabs, and relying on weight transmitted through 50mm wide grouted joints and friction to hold the whole structure together. (God help the tenants if there were an earthquake tremor).

Unfortunately, it seems that the building regulations were not necessarily correctly applied in terms of assessing wind levels, or properly proving details required to prevent spread of fire between flats.

Disaster

In Ronan Point, the biggest disaster to date occured when a gas joint leaked, which caused an explosion on the 18th floor. It brought down the five stories above. And because of the nature of the structure, it proBessively collapsed the 17 Want Stutt gas is banned from similar blacks over four stories!

Planning controls and building regulations, together with British Standards Institute and like bodies, have gone a long way to prevent probably the worst excesses of cowboy contractors, and most of those eontrols have developed out of a state and local authority funded building projects.

Everybody hears the stories of individuals getting ripped off by the cowboy outfits, and even the self-regulating complaint mechanism of devaluing your oun property hasn't stopped the stories getting out about the rubbish building in the detached box precast developments.

Tories

However, in the drive to privatisation the Tories are now introducing the concept of self-certification which means developers and contractors can hire their own "professionals' to certify that buildings are constructed in accordance with regulations.

The most immediate task for those Labour authorities in whose areas most of the tower blocks exist, must be to organise a campaign to get the government to recognise its obligation to pay for demolishing the structures and for rehousing the unfortunate tenants.

It seems unlikely with all the buck passing going on between contractors, engineers, architects and bureaucrats, that the real culprits will be held to account.

Chances are that it will all be blamed on sloppy work by the 'men at site', but it is quite evident that central government, with additional subsidies and expert quango advice, was forcing the pace, and therefore should cough up to pay the bill.

The Tories are already pushing the line that any cash available is likely to be on ternis which further privatise local authority housing, with land cleared being hived off to private developers.

A further dilemma for the 'abour Party is, of course, that its best housing stock is being ild off. leaving these less desirFp-r This, of course, means that those tenants remaining in council housing will become increasingly the poorer, lastchoice citizen.

Already current is the argument that the tower blocks, although not suitable for real families', could be adopted for the single parent families, old age pensioners and singles who convenientiy form a larger percentage of the waiting lists these days.

The Tories have sliced away the housing capital in the last five years and proportionally nore and more of the Labour controlled authority budget is spent on grants for owneroccupiers. We've probably passed the peak in terms of rehabilitating older properties and the renovation of interwar estates is in full swing. The Tories will now provide funding through the Housing Corporation to encourage authorities with land banks to use Housing Associations to develop New Build housing schemes.

Direct Labour Organisations will be cut back through the Planning and Land Act to provide maintenance programmes only, and even these will be further threatened through the Tenants Charter and legislation to enable tenants to organise their own maintenance programmes.

Local authorities will be forced to enter into package deals with developers for their future housing needs on lease and nomination rights, and will in the process secure some housing, but at the same time continue mortgaging local authority finance to the City.

Nationalisation

The Labour Party's housing plans must include nationalising ihe building industry, a state takeover of the High Street Building Societies, wiping out tine Incal authority debts to the City, first option buying of all property coming onto the market for local authorities, compulsory purchase of all second homes, establishing a national housing worker-controlled combine for the development of ex-US bases and the redundant stately homes and strengthening planning and construction regulations.

llowever in order to avoid a repeat of Ronan Point. we must ensure that the building of homes includes in the primess in all design sages, the derandment of a skilled workforce in design and build format. the adherence io regulations formulated to ensure high envirormental standards and the use of good; safe materials and technology. isks to health LOW TO MIDDLE TAR As defined by HiM. Go FILTER CIGARETTES

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no. 206 November 21 1984 Page 10

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 206

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →