Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How COOk the figures

Socialist Organiser no. 207, 28 November 1984 · scan p. 3 · about 350 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

PARK'S OF HAMILTON THE NCB's auditors refused to authenticate the board's national figures last Monday and would only confirm those for North Derbyshire.

The auditors, Thomson McLintock, were called in at the suggestion of a part-time board member, Sir Melvyn Rosser, to reassure public opinion about the authenticity of NCB figures.

With little preparation they were drafted in to observe proceedings last Monday. A furious row broke out, however, when they would only confirm that about 51,000 miners were working that day, whereas the board had calculated the number to be nearer 60,000.

The auditors were persuaded that they had not understood the figures.

In July, the Prime Minister and the Energy Secretary, Mr Peter Walker, told the Commons there were more than 60,000 miners working.

The board's internal documents show that this figure could be reached only by including: more than 3000 men providing safety cover with NUM permission; 5,500 members of the pit deputies' union NACODS; 3,700 members of the white collar union APEX; and 14,200 members of the management union BACM - all of whom were not on strike.

The number of NUM mem bers breaking the strike was jus Curiously the NUM could sometimes be underestimating its own strength. In North Derbyshire it says there are 3,500 working miners.

Figures supplied to the Observer by colliery officials suggest that 3,326 NUM members were working in the middle of last week, just under a third of the union's area membership.

The NCB official figure is more than 1,000 higher.

But closer examination of the NCB's North Derbyshire figures shows a lack of consis. tency. First, there is confusion over the inclusion of Bolsover Colliery, where the NUM miners are members of the Nottinghamshire area, not Derbyshire. That accounts for 494.

Second, in some pits, such as Shirebrook, members of COSA the NUM's white-collar section who are not in the Derby NUM area, are also included.

Thirdly, it would appear that 68 apprentices attending Grassmoor training centre (with union approval) are also in the area board's figures.

Observer, November 25

----- pull-quotes -----

iners Jul their own

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 207

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →