The two Labour Parties Kinnock's rank and
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
file Labour activists have been workthe fence. Why? And what can we do nothing! What the judges say, scabbing on the needs of the a defeat in the here and now for goes. Kinnock's pleas for obedience class struggle now. They tell us the labour movement is likely to to the state machine are, it to stand by and watch, with a lead to a 'Labour victory' in a seems, ii attempt to recapture few words of protest, but no few years' time. votes. If the Tories can portray action, as the bed-rock organisa- The truth is that the more victhemselves as the party of 'law tions of the labour movement tories the labour movement. and order', then (he thinks) are defeated and crippled. Labour will lese out. Therefore, Even if Labour were to-win in 1 and confidence, the weaker the they had been picketed out did they decide to strike.
Throughout, many local officials, while supporting the strike, have said that there should have been a national As a result there has been a steady drift back to work in the North Staffs coalfield, with probably more than 50% now working.
However, Kinnock is likely to be wrong again. The scabs are unlikely to turn out to the meeting, and the hard core still on strike have become more and more hostile to Kinnock as the strike has gone on. Increasingly they say "Kinnock must go" • Miners who went to the NUM rally in Birmingham were not at all impressed with Kinnock's front man Orme. They are unlikely to be any more sympathetic to the organ-grinder himself.
A sign of the politicisation of the local striking miners is the number joining the Labour Party. Socialist Organiser spoke to two of them from Wolstanton Colliery.
John Ratcliffe told us: *1 joined the Labour Party three weeks ago. I wanted to take more interest in it, to see what goes on. The strike has encouraged me to join because I want to get a Labour government in and the Tories out.
Cripple
*We are getting backing off the rank and file in the Labour Party, while she's out to cripple us. After I heard Kinnock the other day, though, 1 nearly came out again.
A few strikers have in fact -wrongly, but understandably — left the Labour Party in protest at Kinnock's role. Jimmy McMillan's letter (see inset) is an example.
Alex Robertson said: "It's our right to belong to the Labour Party because we are working class. I think Kinnock is a tosspot, and I'm thinking of joining the Labour Party to get a decent leader, but I think the one I want — Denis Skinner — wouldn't be accepted."
Already twelve miners from Wolstanton alone have joined the Labour Party, and more forms are being given out every day. This influx should also shake up the soft left in the local Party because miners are no more happy with their role than Kinnock's.
As Alan Lockett, a picket at Meatord Power Station told us, *The Counci's been dragging its feet for too long, and a lot of blokes have lost all faith in the local Labour Party.
The meeting is at 7.30 p.m.
on Friday November 30 at the King's Hall, Stoke. Admission is by ticket, from the Stoke District Labour Party, 4 Robert Street, Tunstall, Stoke on Trent, or from the Regional Labour Party office in Birmingham.
For Kinnock it could be makeor-break time. Failure to come up with the goods in front of 2,000 angry miners who've been out for nine months could sound the death knell for Kinnock's credibility as Labour Leader. NOT so long ago Neil Kinnock was the blue-eyed boy of the Thor Darty Hic election to the Labour leadership was applauded by many in the Party as both a victory (or a halfvictory) for the left, and a blow for Party unity. Left and right in the Party could stop their squables and get on with the business of winning elections.
Kinnock had a good sense for publicity - Tracey Ullman videos, appearances on the T..hn And no danht it made a change to have a leading poli- ruDe. Anu, no uvuut, it tician with a nice lilting Welsh accent rather than an Oxford plum in his mouth.
He seemed to get results in the opinion polls.
Weaseling
Now Kinnock is despised by the majority of striking miners because of his weaseling and equivocation on their struggle.
At Labour Party conference, Kinnock condemned the notion that Labour should embark upon "a political charge of the Light Brigade". More recently, referring to a First World War defeat, he said he didn't want a 'Gallipoli". Condemning 'all' picket line violence and equating pickets and the police, he declared: "I deprecate violence. I damn violence - all violence without fear or favour: And that is what makes me different from Margaret Thatcher - I do not have her double standards."
For Kinnock, "democracy the only system we are prepared to use to wield power" ". Labour could not emphasise legality "as our main weapon for the future and then simultaneously scorn legality in the present"
When the Courts ruled against the NGA last year, Kinnock was forthright that all opposition should keep 'within the law'. No unlawful pickets, no unlawful solidarity strikes, TATI While rank and ing hard to sup been sitting on about it? Clive Neil Kinnock. Pnoto: Jonn nurs Labour must prove itself to be a 'respectable' opposition party.
Kinnock's line is also a distinct political answer to the Tory attacks, and in particular to the attacks on legal rights for the unions. That answer is perfectly simple: wait, and a future Labour government will repeal the laws. Do nothing now.
Roth lines of reasoning mean port the miners, Neil Kinnock has Bradley discusses the issues.
La future election, after years of the labour movement submitting peacefuly to Tory. attacks, then a Labour government based on such a humbled and demoralised labour movement would barely be a government worth having.
In pure. vote-catching terms, too, Kinnock's strategy is idiotic. It amounts to saving that secures, the greater its strength