Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Break away in Notts

Socialist Organiser no. 207, 28 November 1984 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 2,032 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Tories become, the greater Labour's electoral chances.

Kinnock's strategy leaves him dithering on the miners' strike, discrediting himself both with scabs and with strikers.

He vacillates on whether or not to join NUM leaders at their rallies. For Kinnock, to be closely aligned with the miners might 'alienate' too many potential voters, and damage Labour's election chances.

At the same time he can't be too distant. Outright condemnation of the strike would be too risky.

Kinnock wants the NUM to get round the table with the NCB and come to a compromise. He has tried to play 'mediator'.

He has condemned Mrs Thatcher for 'needlessly prolonging the strike' due to 'political vanity on a manic scale' There is no reason, according to Kinnock, why the NCB and the NUM cannot come to a 'negotiated settlement' What such a negotiated settlement would look like is not at all clear. Kinnock's basic thought seems to be that any settlement is better than the strike continuing.

To want victory means to be in favour of the methods needed to win - and Kinnock, plainly, is not.

This is an account of Kinnock's activity in his own constituency, from a London Labour Party delegation which recently visited.

"Hardly anyone had a good word for Neil Kinnock. The general feeling was that he had sat on the fence and had let them down.

"They want and need his support. They want him to take the lead and argue their case, something that so far he has singularly failed to do.

"What really disgusted me was the fact that not once during the duration of the strike has Kinnock visited the striking miners in Oakdale. In actaal fact he has not visited any of the Lodges in the area, nor the food distribution centre at Abertillery • "He has not even written Kent miners in Londor them a letter of support. And this from someone who is not only the leader of the Labour Party but who is also their MP."

Kinnock's plans for Labour have an undercurrent to them which is even worse.

At this year's conference, he insisted in his speech that Labour would have no truck with the Liberal-SDP Alliance. During the miners' strike he could hardly say otherwise. But is he sure?

Hobsbawm

At last year's conference -when he was elected leader -Kinnock chaired a meeting addressed by Eric Hobsbawm. Hobsbawm is a member of the Communist Party who has argued in favour of Labour forming a coalition with the Liberals and SDP, or at least an election pact.

The argument runs that the Tories now represent something so new and terrifying that they must be defeated no matter what the cost. It is a stale and vacuous re-hash of old Stalinist CHICA • Police in the Midlands: Photo: Jolin Harris 2. Photo: Andrew Moore arguments from the 1930s about a 'popular front' to beat fascism.

As Hobsbawm put his case, Kinnock nodded in agreement. And it is well known that some of Kinnock's advisers share Hobsbawm's line.

For some time, Kinnock had been the spokesperson for the party 'centre' - for those who talked left but could be relied on to do nothing left wing.

He opposed Benn in his contest with Healey for deputy leader in 1981. In the 1983 leadership elections he represented the centre option -opposed on the left by Eric Heffer.

Kinnock's victory represented a combination of ex-left wing pessimism, denioralised by the June 1983 election defeat and the industrial situation, and never-left-wing hope for a respectable future. And under his leadership, many of the soft left became even softer and found themselves a niche within a slightly altered Labour Party estabishment. not regained the initiative. Some attempts to push home the Kinnockites' advantage have been stopped - like the proposed change in selection procedure. But the right wing has held on to its positions after this year's conference; Kinnock still managed to get a standing ovation; and, even more significant, an economic policy document reflecting Roy Hattersley's mixed-economy thinking went through without serious opposition.

The problem is not just Neil Kinnock as an individual. If it weren't Kinnock saying the things he says, and doing the things he does, it would be someone else. He represents a definite force within the Labour Party and trade unions which has consolidated its position since the fall of Foot.

But there is more to it than that.

The Labour Party is the political party of the trade unions. Trade unions set it up; it was formed to be a political voice for the trade unions. But the trade unions are not controlled by rank and file workers.

They are controlled by a more-or-less entrenched bureaucracy which generally, so long as it is able to do so, opts for a cosy relationship with the bosses and with the state.

But the nature of the Labour Party means that the leaders constantly have to watch their backs. Unlike Liberals, Tories and today' 's Social Democrats, they have to keep one eye on the working class base that has given them their position in society as big (or small) name politicians. If they just abandon ship, like the SDP did, they take a terrible personal risk.

The left itself often shares a big responsibility for Labour leaders like Kinnock being able to carry out their "balancing act' between Labour's working class base and capitalist policies. Often the left does not fight the right wing and so-called 'centre' leaders.

Left-wingers knuckle under — or buckle under the pressure -or abstain from the struggle within the Labour Party, leaving the field clear to Kinnock, as if they hoped to build a whole new labour movement in parallel rather than changing the existing organisations of the working class.

To defeat the Kinnocks of this world, we must organise a left wing throughout the labour movement that is prepared to fight all the way - to transform, democratise and politically re-arm the labour movement to be able to win, and to drag the trade unions and Labour Party out of back-room deals in the corridors of power and onto the THIS broadsheet is produced as nart of this week's Socialist Organiser.

Socialist Organiser is a weekly paper produced by organised left-wingers in the This week's issue includes *The story of the tenacious solidarity of railworker in Leicestershire, and other miners' strike news, *The facts on new tech= nology in the mines.

*Peter Hain on the Tory law's challenge to the trade unions' political levy.

*Interview with strikers at Barking Hospital - out for nearly nine months against private contractors Crothalls, *CPSA national executive member Rod Bacon on why the CPSA Broad Left, the biggest in the trade union movement, has split, and what to do about it.

*and much more.

25p, 10p to claimants and strikers:

strike dia Paul Whetton is secretary of the Notts miners' rank and file strike committee, writing in a personal capacity.

EVEN WITH the Coal Board's crooked figures, it has been proved conclusively that the drift back to work is no more than a drift of odds and sods.

Now that we're getting nearer to Christmas, we can say that the lads who are out, are out solid.

The new cash they're offering to those returning to work is another sign of weakness by the Coal Board.

We heard a story that a certain well-known Manton scab was walking round the market-place in Worksop with a roll of notes big enough to choke a donkey and putting €300 straight in scabs' hands, no questions asked.

The underlying fact is that Notts is not coming up with the goods. Even though they have got the vast majority of men working, output down.

In Yorkshire there are no deputies going through at any of the pits except Manton, and so all the police presence is just to get a few scabs through the picket lines to sit on the pit top.

MacGregor

And then every time the Coal Board seems to be getting something together, MacGregor jumps straight in and puts his foot in it. Last week he announced that he could not guarantee no compulsory redundancies, which obviously is going to harden the strikers' determination.

I dare say the government will have him on the carpet again, probably walking to the office with a plastic bag over his head.

We're planning now for local meetings. We're going to group a few communities together - Ollerton, for example, will probably have a march that includes Bevercotes, Thoresby, maybe somewhere else. We'll be having those demonstrations between now and Christmas to show our solidarity.

I've heard one commentator say that Dave Nellist's act in ripping up the Tory government's statement on taking another £1 off strikers' families' social security was an act of violence. He seemed to forget that the government decision itself was an act of violence - mass violence.

It's about time that Labour MPs organised a demonstration like that, and I would hope they are going to follow it up with more direct action.

Otherwise Parliament is just a talking shop, full of hot air.

In Russia Neil Kinnock said there was hardship in the mining areas, but not starvation. How the hell would he know whether miners are starving or not?

Once you become removed from the people who put you where you are, then you "see things through the eyes of the media. If Kinnock wants to find out whether or not miners are starving, then he should get himself down to a picket line, and he can also see the truth about violence there.

There's been a big outcry about a scab was supposedly beaten up by strikers. The local NUM branch said that they didn't think their members were involved, but they were setting up an inquiry.

I think it's to be expected if a man sells his principles down the river that people will react in violent ways, especially when they are undergoing such terrible hardship. But why doesn't the press play up the other side of the coin, where striking miners are getting physical violence and intimidation from working miners?

There's a case coming up in court shortly of a striking miner who had scabs trying to saw his head off.

We had our Bevercotes NUM branch meeting on Sunday. The scabs sprang on us a vote on acceptance of the 5.2% pay offer and lifting the overtime ban. None of the strikers voted, because we believed it was totally out of order.

The branch has now gone against area policy and national policy. We warned them quite specifically that they were out of order, but they still insisted on doing it.

A lot of the lads on the floor obviously don't understand what it's all about, but those on the platform do, and they are manipulating to bring about a breakaway union.

Spencerism

People who have got nothing whatsoever to do with the NUM are spending quite large sums of money in order to set up Spencerism again in Nottingham.

At the power stations we're getting quite a lot of hassle now from the police.

This morning, for the third time, our shelter at Westburton power station has been destroyed by the police, and they used labour and machinery from out of the power station to do that.

I was surprised that the High Court today [Monday] went that far against the TGWU. I would have thought that they would have wanted to take a low profile and not stir things up.

But if we can get the TGWU stirred up that much that they will come and stand alongside us, then we're starting to get somewhere.

On Sunday December 2 I'll be speaking at the support conference in London. I hope we can galvanise the rank and file.

We've seen exactly what change we're going to get out of the leadership, and that's absolutely zero. We just get words from them, and a lot of rhetoric. I'm hoping that the rank and file will start to mobilise itself from that conference. * *

Scan page 8

November Editorial•

----- pull-quotes -----

STRIKE Fund

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 207

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →