Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[El Dorado was the 16th century European freebooters'…]

Socialist Organiser no. 207, 28 November 1984 · scan p. 9 · about 919 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

El Dorado was the 16th century European freebooters' name for a mythical city stacked with gold In fact the continent was a real El Dorado for infant European capitalism, filling huge treasure fleet of silver and gold. The price was the decimation of the local population and a legacy of economic underThis article bv Martin Thomas is the fourth African slaves in the, diamond mines of Brazil under Portuguese rule. somewhere in South America.

development.

series on the roots of Third The huge gains made from the silver trade have convinced many Marxists that Spanish America was fully capitalist.** But not every trade economy is capitalist. Capital is not just wealth from trade, but wealth which constantly expands itself through reinvestment.

Although fortunes based on the silver trade played a big role in the emergence of the capitalist world economy, they were generally not capital in America. - Even metropolitan Spain's economy was still based on feudal privilege rather than capitalist enterprise. The treasure of the 'Indies' (as the Spanish called America) was consumed in luxury and military display.

Antwerp

Spaniards of the time complained that their country was *the Indies of other foreign kingdoms" . The silver quickened capitalism not in Spain but in Italy and north-west Europe. Much of it went to Antwerp, which in the 16th century was "as much (if not more) the true capital of the Atlantic as Seville or Lısbon...a system of exchange, circulation and banking came into being, centred on the Scheldt port, and extending as far as Germany, England and even Lyons"*** And in Spanish America a new feudalism was established.

Spanish settlers grabbed huge areas of land - the 'latifundia' A fantastically unequal distri bution of landownership was set up which continues in most of Spanish America to this day. In 1970, over 60% of Latin America's land was in big holdings (more than 500 hectares), whereas in Africa and Asia 75-80% of land is in holdings less than 20 hectares.

The Indian and mestizo peasants were tied to the latifundia by a system called debt peonage. The Spanish land-grabber would grant the peasant a little land, some implements and some seed or livestock, in return for labour and loan repayments.

Formally the peasants are wage-labourers. In fact they can never get out of debt, and the landowner is local magistrate and governor as well as employer. This system is by no means abolished in Latin America even now.

At the beginning of the 19th century almost all the SpanishAmerican colonies won independence. But there was no great stride forward into capitalist development.

In fact the hold of the landowning oligarchies tightened.

Manufacturing industry which had been quite active under Spanish rule, though in feudal guild forms - initially declined.

Spanish-American feudalism, World poverty. resting as it did on the superexploitation of the Indians, lacked the dynamic conflict between cities and countryside typical of West European feudalism. Landowners generally lived in the cities. There was not much of an urban merchant/ industrial class fretting against feudal limitations.

The British politician George Canning greeted Latin American independence with some excitement: "England will be a workshop, and Latin America its farm" . This prospect suited the Latin American oligarchies quite well.

Trade increased. SpanishAmerican manufacturing industry, relatively robust against the feeble competition of Spain, was crushed by the competition of Britain's new factories. But. cities were still rich.

Dependent

Capital circulated increasingly in Latin America under this "imperialism of free trade' , and towards the end of the century new industries arose in Mexico, in Brazil, in Chile and in Argentina. But its scope was limited. Most Latin-American countries became economies dependent on a single export - coffee, bananas, tin for Bolivia, nitrates and later copper for Chile.

Some leaders of the independence struggle had hoped to unite former Spanish America in a single state. They failed. The division of the region into several states led to those states N H HIH being integrated into the world economy as separate (relatively weak and small) provinces, relating more to Europe (and later the US) than to each other. In 1966 only 10% of the trade of the Latin American Free Trade Area was within LAFTA, whereas over 60% of Western Europe's trade was internal.

Worse: from the late 19th century, large parts of Latin America became semi-colonies of the US. In 1895 an official US diplomatic note declared: *Today the US is practically sovereign on this continent, and its fiat is law". The US never quite acquired that full control, and especially not over the larger states to the south; but it was a powerful force backing up the oligarchies, and in Central America it regularly interyened with direct military force at the least sign of reform.

Depression

The depression of the 1930s. threw the old oligarchic export economies into crisis: between 1928-9 and 1932-3 exports declined over 60% for every major economy in Latin America. Nationalist revolutions and reform efforts, from below and from above, followed. The local industrial capitalist class began to play a bigger role.

Latin America today, alongside tracts of poverty as bad as any in the world, has a sizeable middle class not very different in living standards from Western Europe. But the old oligarchies only began to fade seriously, in most countries, after the Cuban revolution in 1959.

**The Modern World System' vol 1. **Andre Gunder Frank, 'Capitalism and underdevelopment in Latin America'. ***Fernand Braudel, *The Mediterranean in the age of Philip II.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 207

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →