DHSS strikes and claimant
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
CPSA The Birmingham/Oxford DHSS dispute, Uctober - December 1704. UUM CPSA activist Rod Bacon spokr and Steve Battlemuch about th procedures during strike action Department of Employment.
Martin. As I understand, most people on the left in the CPSA are in favour of boycotting emergency procedures during strikes in the Department of Health and Social Security (DHSS).
There's an obvious rationale for that in terms of strengthening industrial action. But the obvious argument against it is that it means trying to hit claimants. In practice it would probably mean an opening for the government to organise scabbing under the pretext of humanitarianism.
Rod. The only way we are going to be effective is by involving every member of the union.
If you operate emergency procedures, that means cooperating with management to undermine the strike.
Cooperate I think we should black emergency procedures within DHSS and DE. We should get every member out on strike. But we should cooperate with NALGO and the UCW [post office workers] to set up emergency payments centres which will ensure that clai mants get some money.
There are a lot of people in the DHSS who say that the only way to take effective action is to pull out the plugs and have no emergency procedures being operated anywhere. I don't go along with that.
Martin. So you're saying that you want to provide some emergency cover - as workers in other essential services do when they strike - but you want someone else to do it for you.
And moreover, the people who are going to provide the cover are not going to do it as a matter of trade union cooperation - they are going to do it because local authorities have statutory duties and NALGO members will be forced to do it by their employers, and under incredibly difficult conditions.
That's not going to be very good for solidarity between trade unions, or solidarity between employed and unemployed.
Rod. No. If we're in favour of emergency procedures, we don't do it through approaching the employers in the local authorities or the post office. We approach the unions.
Now if they reject operatling emergency procedures, then we'll have to reassess the situation.
But there are certain advantages which -NALGO members and UCW members can obtain from their employers for providing this call extra service.
The thing is, within the DHSS we couldn't just operate emergency cover. You would have half an office doing the work while the other half was out on strike It just wouldn't work It's a differ SID TRE LI prauding emengen rtin TI e on e DHSS cover in a mine to stop it becoming dangerous, or running casualty services in a hospital during a strike.
If you put to our members that half of them are going on strike, and half of them are working emergency procedures, then the whole feeling of collective action begins to dissipate. That's certainly been my experience in my office.
I think there is a genuine sympathy for claimants in DHSS offices. A lot of DHSS workers are ex-claimants themselves. They would have no objection to an emergency service being provided in other areas, as long as the unity of their own action was not destroyed.
Steve. Another problem is that when the computers come out - Newcastle and Washington, or Livingstone and Reading - and we operate emergency procedures in the local offices to cover them, it is an absolutely intolerable work pressure for our members.
The overtime ban goes, whatever we say, and members get very demoralised with the union. They've got three or four times the amount of work, management telling them to do it -and the union telling them to do it too.
Martin. It seems to me that on the basic issue of principle we are agreed - in favour of some form of emergency cover. What we are discussing is ways of doing it.
Approaches
But you talked about approaches to NALGO and UCW rather than their employers. Have those approaches been made?
Rod. Only for a very short period - a matter of two weeks - and in a couple of areas has the CPSA in DHSS and DE not operated emergency procedures. That was in the 1981 pay campaign.
In Hackney we then approached NALGO. The NALGO members were willing to set up an emergency centre, and they screwed their employers for compensation for the extra work.
Now the policy of the tion - to approach those We can't talk about all-out strike action by CPSA if the two strongest elements of the union, the DE and DHSS workers, are to continue working. The strike would just never get off the ground. Steve. There is a motion up to this year's pay conference, on December 6, from DHSS South Notts, instructing the National Executive Committee to hold an urgent meeting with NALGO and UCW to draw up plans for emergency payments, and also instructing branches to hold urgent meetings with claimants and ocal authority and post workers Ma Iom eba mer the and the rank and file: Photo. John Harris DELINA 1000. hath Militant and the soft left let down
Scan page 11
November
----- pull-quotes -----
CPSA, as decided at confer- ence, is to go in that direc-