The left wing must itself on the rank ar
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-11-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
On November 3 the Broad Left in the civil service union CPSA - the biggest Broad Left in the British trade union movement - split. The rival groups - the official Broad Left, in which 'Militant' is strong, and the 'Broad Left 84' - are holding conferences on December 8 and 7 respectively, after the CPSA special pay conference on December 6.
Rod Bacon is a member of the CPSA National Executive Committee, vice-chair of the CPSA DHSS Section Executive, and a leading activist in the Socialist Caucus faction of the Broad Left. He spoke (in a personal capacity) to Martin Thomas of Socialist 350 CPSA shiftworkers in the Newcastle and Washington DHSS computer centres have been on strike since May 14 over management's attempts to alter the existing shift system.
These changes involved workers starting an hour earlier in the. morning shift and finishing 51 minutes earlier on evenings. The real motive was to cut the Shift Disturbance Allowance by At a meeting on November 1 management's latest offer was rejected by a majority of ten to one. During the dispute about 2500 workers out of the 7000 on site have been threatened. uSS disnute Octoher - December 1982: both Militant and the soft left let down Organiser.
Martin. Why did the CPSA Broad Left split?
Rod. It was a bureaucratic action fight between two roups - on one side the Militant tendency, and on the ther the Labour Group/ Communist Party.
Both groups have always lad a bureaucratic attitude -ighting for leadership, elecioneering, election slates -nd they felt at National Exeutive Committee level that hey could no longer work toether.
On several issues they were in opposite sides - the Newastle/Washington dispute, lonations to the National Unon of Mineworkers.
Martin. My impression is that major issue behind it was •lectoral calculations. The abour Group/CP — now callid 'Broad Left 84' - thought hat they could do better in inion elections than Militant.
However, if they were vithin the same Broad Left as Militant, they had to agree to lates which gave relatively food representation to Miliant. If they had their own roup, they could run against Militant. defeat Militant. and then either steamroller them or force them into agreements favourable to the Broad Left 84.
Rod. I think that's probably a long term objective. Nobody in Broad Left 84 that I've spoken to recently is naive enough to think that they are going to win a clean sweep on the National Executive in 1985.
They may well be building up a centre ground, inviting a lot of the people who are now part of the right wing organisation to join with them in an anti-Trotskyist, anti-red, sensible middle-ofthe-road Labour Party type of grouping, to win elections in 1986 But basically it was the battles on the National Executive Committee that caused the split - with Militant moving fast towards the left. They're leading a strike at Newcastl. and Washington that's been going on for 26 weeks now, and that's made them a lot more left wing than they've been in the past. And the Labour Group really cannot work with that kind of political drift, though two years ago they could work quite well with Milita Martin. What will the immediate effects the split?
Rod. The right wing control of the union.
Socialist Caucus, along with the Socialist Workers Party and the Socialist Labour Group is fighting for a united left slate of the Broad Lefts.
But the probability is that both the Broad Left 84 and the official Broad Left will run full slates against each other - and the right wing will win the NEC.
Martin. How would assess the Broad Left NEC's record on the Newcastle/ Washington dispute?
Rod. The pretty record diabolical.
92%, or between £10 and £20 a week.
with suspension.
The Militant tendency, who dominate in the Newcastle DHSS branch - the largest branch in the CPSA thought they could win it as a localised dispute.
They engineered a motion that went through CPSA conference in May saying that we should support the Newcastle shiftworkers but also operate emergency procedures in the local offices. You couldn't actually vote against that motion because if you voted against it, then you were voting against the strike of the Newcastle shiftworkers.
They localised the dispute: After 20 weeks they had got nowhere. The members out on strike were looking for escalation.
So Militant went for bringing out the other computer centres - Livingstone and Reading. Socialist Caucus. comrades supported this, but wè also argued that we should not be operating emergency procedures in the local offices. It is a national dispute, and all elements of the DHSS, local offices included, should be involved in it.
The Broad Left 84 members on the NEC voted against bringing out Livingstone and Reading. They came up with an alternative suggestion, rather cynically cobbled together in my opinion, to bring out a few selected offices of the DHSS and Department of Employment (DE).
That alternative strategy has collapsed. There is virtually nowhere where members in DHSS and DE are prepared to come out on indefinite strike on their own. There is more of a feeling for bringing out Livingstone and Reading, and then escalating the action through the local office network. So the end result is that no action has been taken to escalate the dispute.
There was an NEC meeting last week in which myself and Kevin Roddy of Militant put down a motion for the NEC to support blacking emergency procedures in the DHSS and to bring out Livingstone. and Reading. That motion was defeated.
Martin. What lessons do you think there are for Broad Lefts in other unions?
Rod. I suppose there is a tendency in all Broad Lefts, once they get into positions of power within the union, to drift towards the bureaucracy and detach themselves from the membership.
Most Broad Lefts are based on electoral polities. The two leading groups in the CPSA Broad • Left are not arguing principally over policies to fight for among the membership - they are fighting over who has the biggest control of the leadership of the union.
You do have to bear in mind that the Broad Left in the CPSA, even dominated by Militant, is a lot better than