Benn's speech Renewing Labour Party
Socialist Organiser1984 1984-12-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
above politics - we've seen the button from his nuclear all that being exposed. shelter. rights won by earlier genera- having its founding confertions, we've got to fight as ence now, all the groups 1. 1 In mannin tham ac they that are represented here comprehensive in its nature. "Socialism in our time" was We want dignity for the put as a slogan for immediate old. We want to get rid of consideration. I believe that Reagan's missiles which will nothing less than that is on easily destroy the whole of the agenda and that we have civilisation when he presses the power to bring it about.
If we are going to defend fought to win them.
We've got to use the energy and commitment released by the mıners strıke to make fresh demands: we want jobs for all, because there is work to be done, mainly in the expansion of the public services.
We want education open to everybody. We want homes for everybody. We want a proper health service free at the point of use and If the Labour Party were would be at that conference. The women's sections would be an autonomous group affiliated, the black sections, and a whole range of others. A Labour Party that can do its job has to be comprehensive in character. It has to be appropriate to the magnitude of the struggle that faces us, and truly representative of all interests ana SuaraoId that confront working eople.
Socialism
It is a long time since
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser no. 208 Tony Greenstein and Andrew Hornung take up a debate with Gerry BenNoah's review (SO 199) of Lenni Brenner's books ' Zionism in the Age of the Dictators' and "The Iron Wall' TO reply to Gerry Ben Noah's review article, "Re-writing the holocaust" (SO 199), we shall ignore some of the detailed remarks concerning, for instance, Lenni Brenner's books. On some of these questions Ben Noah is right, on others wrong - most of the time his points are simply not relevant.
What we are concerned with are the central issues raised by Brenner and others and raised again by Ben Noah; we are concerned with "the sense he makes" (to use Ben Noah's own phrase) of the history of Zionism.
A second preliminary remark: for an article that accuses certain writers of creating a grotesque "amalgam"' — of equating Zionism with anti-Semitism - the review itself offers a pretty bizarre example of this Israeli tanks in Lebanon attack and obstructed efforts at saving Jewish lives. If he believes it did not, let him say what part of the overwhelming evidence - "events (which) are real and publicly known" , as he himself calls them - is wrong.
The truth is that the overwhelming evidence demonstrates that Zionist leaders were concerned about the fate of European Jewry only insofar as it concerned the establishment, of a Jewish state. To understand why, it is necessary to realise that Zionism was never about saving Jews but redeemingthem.
To the logical Zionist, then, a great stream of refugees to nonNazi Europe or the US could only marginalise the effort to build up a Jewish state - the! precondition for • "redeeming" Jewry from its Diaspora mental ity - and threaten the existing communities in the countries of reception.
Ben Gurion put it most succinctly when he said, by way of warning the Zionist Executive at its December 17 1938 meeting: "If Jews will have to choose between the refugees, saving Jews from concentration camps, and assisting the national museum in Palestine, mercy will have the upper hand and the