Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[against racism and fascism ment - not merely…]

Socialist Organiser no. 208, 5 December 1984 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,850 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

against racism and fascism ment - not merely individual neded to be made, the British Zionists - collaborated with the Board of Deputies — the over- Nazis (why they did is another whelmingly Zionist "represen- matter) and, more to the point, tatives" of the Jewish commun- even obstructed attempts at ity in Britain — has opposed rescue does not minimise the them. Nazis' guilt, as Ben Noah states. their refusal to fight has always asserting that Trotsky, by insistbeen to claim, falsely, that the ing on the responsibility of Left who organised opposition in Stalinism for Hitler's rise to these cases is anti-Semitic power, was minimising the Of course, the inactivity of happened as a consequence of the BoD today is hardly differ- Hitler's victoryBoD before it was overwhelm- to see German Social Demoingly Zionist. Zionism does not cracy's class collaboration as a determine - in the above cases decisive element in the victory of - the BoD's stand entirely, German imperialism over the rather it gives an ideological labour movement? Perhaps he Secondly, Zionism justifies is simply a sentimentalist's its general programme by claim- confusion. It is utterly alien to ing that no country, no regime Marxism. provide a "solution to the responsible for the holocaust. Jewish question" because all The Nazis' responsibility, are inevitably anti-Semitic. It is however, should not be used to one of the many crimes of Stalin- obscure or conceal the role of very technique when it equates Nazi apologists who rewrite the history of the holocaust (note the title!) with people with a proven record of combatting racism including anti-Semitism.

Running through the article is the argument that there exists a "left" anti-Semitism equivalent to that of the right, as if the Left has, from the days of Marx onwards, constituted a second wing of anti-Semitism.

While examples of antiimmigrant campaigning of a decidedly anti-Semitic character are not hard to find before World War 2, it is the Left, the working class movement, that has proved the most consistent opponent of anti-Semitism.

Nutshell Indeed, here we have the whole issue in a nutshell: it is the Left (with all its imperfections) that has been the opponent of anti-Semitism while the self-styled movements of national salvation of the Jews, Zionism, has manifestly failed.

That Zionism should seek to falsify this - indeed, claim the contrary - is not surprising. How else should it justify itself? By its colonial conquests alone?

ınis alstoruon — me picture TLiN 1: tha nintere of "left" anti-Semitism - is peddled by the Jewish establishment in Britain today. Firstly, it serves as a cover for their own inactivity in fighting the real anti-Semites of the fascist and Tory Right. Whether it has been the Lewisham demonstration of 1977, the formation of the ANL, the fight to exclude Patrick Harrington from North London Polytechnic or other situations where a stand The simplest justification for because it is anti-Zionist.

ent from the inactivity of the cover to its inactivity.

No solution and no social movement can ism that anti-Semitism in the Soviet Union under Stalin appeared to prove the truth of this view. The consequences of this for Soviet opposition movements can be felt to this day.

Just as it is ludicrous to place the Left in the same camp as the Right when it comes to antiSemitism, so it is nonsense to talk of a "left" version of fascist revisionism which seeks to deny the holocaust took place. What some Leftists are, however, trying to do is measure Zionism against its implicit and explicit claim to be the movement which saved Jewry and which offered a resistance to fascism that non-Jewish movements could not do.

Collaboration

Stating that the Zionist moveTo claim as much is like Nazis' responsibility for what Or perhaps Lenin was wrong was whitewashing German imperialism!

Clearly this line of argument Ot course, the Nazis were others. Despite the good intentions of many Zionists - and many people joined the Zionist movement when all else had failed, more out of desperation than ideological conviction — we have to say (and Gerry Ben Noah nowhere denies it that Zionism's starting point was the abandonment of the fight against anti-Semitism.

No wonder then that the Nazis looked to the Zionists to run the Judenrat's Jewish Councils and the Jewish police. As many have testified, they played an important part in pacifying the Jewish communities and in Hungary and elsewhere actually helped in rounding up victims. his is why the Judenrate were so despised and hated.

Let us emphasise one thing: we do not say simply (as an antiSemite might) that Jews betrayed Jews. It is neither a matter merely of individual Jews nor of Jews in general — we are talking about Zionist organsations. Gerry Ben Noah's whole article bases itself on just the kind of confusion - the confusion between "Jew" and "zionism" - that he rails against.

Small

It is essential to remember that before World War 2 Zionism was almost everywhere little more than a small trend within Jewish communities.

In order to increase the confusion, the article claims that the Polish Bund - the majority party of the Polish Jewish working class — collaborated on the same scale as the Zionists. It did not: it had a record of unswerving opposition to Nazism. Again, we are not talking about individual members but about the movements as a whole.

Ben Noah's defence of Zionism on these matters leads him to try to justify Herzl's meeting with von Plehve, the Tzarist Minister of the Interior and a noted anti-Semitic pogrommist. But it won't do simply to brush this off as a "hard-headed calculation" , an alliance with the devil by a movement with its back to the wall.

The fact is that Zionism sought to ally with Russian autocracy against the progres sive forces amongst whom the Jewish workers and petty-bourgeoisie formed a sizeable number.

Sentimentalism

Again, Ben Noah's sentimentalism breaks through. Perhaps he would prefer to see Herzl as a basically noble man. Who cares? The argument is not about good and bad persons, people acting in good or bad faith. The argument is about political affinities and political logic.

If Herzl, Weizmann - and, yes, why not? - Jabotinsky were all good people and devoted to the survival (as they saw it) of Jewry, then it is all the more clear how reactionary an ideology Zionism is when it was capable of getting the first to praise von Plehve, the second to praise Mussolini and the third to support Petlyura, the leader of the White Russians with over 200,000 Jewish lives on his hands.

Note well: Jabotinsky did not simply parley with Petlyura, he supported him against the Left! To Ben Noah this is all "tragic confusion", the product of desperate circumstances. Weizmann's comparison of the bolshevik Revolution with the advent of Nazism was perhaps such a "tragic confusion" - a confusion between those who outlawed pogroms and those who instigated them!

Perhaps the leaders of Hungarian Zionism whose 'Rescue Department" worked under the aegis of Eichmann and Becher and without whom Nazism could never have been so successful in their exterminatory drive in Hungary - perhaps they were also tragically confused?

Or perhaps the economic transfer agreement between Nazi Germany and the Zionist settlement in Palestine - an agreement approved by the Zionist Congress of 1935 which helped break the anti-Nazi boycott was both a "hard-headed calculation" and a "tragic confusion'"

The only "confusion" here is in Ben Noah's own head. And it is a double confusion: firstly, he is confused about the facts (Weizmann was well aware of the genocidal drive of Nazism as his speech in 1937 to the 20th Zionist Congress made clear) and secondly he is confused about the point under debate.

No one argues that the Zionists were just as willing to kill six million Jews as the Nazis.

Disarmed

The point under debate is whether or not Zionism as an ideology disarmed its followers in the face of persecution, whether it minimised the implications of anti-Semitism by its belief in the worthlessness of Diaspora Jewry (Weizmann in the above. mentioned speech refers to the millions about to perish as "dust, economic and moral dust in a cruel world"') and whether as a movement it didn't always put the building up of the Jewish settlement in Palestine before the saving of Jewish or other lives...even to the point of obstructing emigration if it wasn't to Palestine and of rounding up Jews for the gas chambers.

Let Gerry Ben Noah answer the simple question as to whether Zionism as an ideology and as a movement disarmed its followers in the face of fascist whole energy of the people willbe channelled into saving Jews from various countries. Zionism will be struck off the agenda not only in world puble opinion, in Britain and the United States, but elsewhere in Jewish public opinion.

Palestinians

If we allow a separation between the refugee problem and the Palestinian problem, we are risking the existence of Zionism."

Ben Noah knows that such quotations can be produced in great quantity from spokespersons of every wing of Lionism. He knows Zionism opposed the anti-Nazi boycott; he knows Zionism opposed the opening of the US to Jewish refugees in excess of the numbers stipulated in pre-war rulings; indeed, he recommends to us Nathan Weinstock's excellent book, "Zionism, False Messiah'" as an alternative to the books he condemns though that book tells us (p. 136) that, "The role of the Zionist Organisation's refusal to contribute to the rescue of European Jewry elsewhere than in Palestine remains to be written. Sometimes, this attitude was akin to outright sabotage."

So what is he saying? That Ben Gurion was joking? That he was lying to the Executive, playing a diplomatic game as Herzl had done with von Plehve? Or simply that the coincidence between the words and actions of Zionism's leaders is just that ..a coincidence, a fluke of In the final analysis, all Ben Noah has to say is this: even if Zionism as an ideology aided the Nazis and other reactionaries before them and even if there are documented acts of collaboration between Zionists and reactionaries (not just diplomatic agreements), the ultimate aims of the Zionists and those of the anti-Semites were different: the former wanted to redeem Jews while the latter didn't.

Needless to say, that is not something we deny, nor is that very surprising. But that is not what the dispute is about, A final word to Socialist Organiser. It is a good thing that you publish views that you don't agree with. This only becomes a problem when it is not clear what your own position is. Is it the position contained in a review some time ago which did not dispute the interpretation that Gerry Ben Noah attacks or is it Gerry Ben Noah's? Or have you no view at all?

It is time you pinned your colours to the mast before others do it for you.

Scan page 9

Socialist Organiser no.208

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 208

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →