Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

'Selling' riot police

Socialist Organiser no. 208, 5 December 1984 · scan p. 9 · about 874 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Susan Carlyle reviews the Panorama TV programme [Monday 3rd].

ORGANISED! Panorama (BBC-I) returned to the miners' strike on Monday 3rd.

Entitled "To the Bitter End", the programme tried to focus on the back-to-work move, coupled it conveniently with highly emotive incidents of violence showing a burned-out house and badlyinjured scab miner Michael Fletcher, and tried to generalise for the North Yorkshire area. Neither of those incidents took place in that specific locality.

It didn't work. The programme tried to build up an image with elaborate presentation of the police's planning meetings, with earnest discussion based on a series of anonymous tip-offs about petrol bombs, explosives, and nails being strewn on roads. But it showed nothing happening to the police beyond routine picketing and patrolling!

Cameras accompanied the police to picket lines, on escort journeys with scabs, through villages and across country, along motorways Labour Against the Witchhunt AGM 1984 Saturday December 8:

registration from 11.30am at County Hall, London SEI The meeting will review the year's work, consider future activities, and elect a Secretariat for the coming year. Make sure your Labour Party or trade union organisation is represented Contact: Keith Lichman, LAW secretary, Il Wilderton Rd, London N16. and back to the police centres.

The main interest was the police talking about their tactics and their 'need to adapt to the new pattern of violence' • They could have been discussing a new product in an advertising campaign and how to sell it painlessly.

The programme showed an alarming machinery of intelligence-gathering, movement of individuals, convoys, vehicles and picketing. General Frank Kitson would be proud to see his "counterinsurgency" methods being used. But on TV they got the stamp of approval.

Tolerance

The police chiefs back at HQ talked of their tolerance but said they needed "positive firmness, because no miner likes a softie. They would be the first to see through it". So that's why so many pickets have been injured! Just in case they suspect the British police might be soft!

The programme showed the escalating cost, four times higher since the summer at £600,000 a week for the area. The operation is too big for local forces to cope and 560 extra police from Avon are permanently drafted in.

Crime is generally increasing and the detection rate has dropped.

This section was rounded off with a clip that seemed straight from a Tory political broadcast. A police chief, looking straight into the camera, said "I have confidence in us to get you back to work"

Maggie Thatcher would be proud. Saatchi and Saatchi should book him up.

Another TV crew spend their time at picket lines and in cars following scabs.

The union, with resigned but methodical competence, was tracking each scab as they left the bus in order to keep a record of who was going in to work. No scab could expect to have a job come the end of the strike but any miner who only went in for a day and then came out again would not face retribution.

Was this harassment, Panorama asked. "We have a divine right to speak to our members. They're our members, not the police's members, not the NCB's. If they believe they're right, then they've nothing to hide.

One scab approached the union car and complained about violence. Challenged, he admitted that no miners from that pit had been intimidated!

The media now provide every scab's excuse. *We saw violence at the picket line. The team had been told to go and film behind police lines, and we saw a young copper being restrained by a senior officer after using his truncheon.

Panorama remarked how different the picketing looked from the picket's angle. What an admission after picket-baiting!

The film showed the North Yorkshire panel meetings. The representatives weren't in a winning mood. The secretary was cagey. His feeling was one of being bound to fellow miners. "You can't be isolated in a pit. It's unique our union. It describes the life you lead where you're dependent on eachother.

"We've fought nine months for issues, not for Arthur Scargill, but for loyalty to the National Union of Mineworkers"

Lacking direct material on violence, the film had to keep dipping back to Michael Fletcher on crutches.

Nobody apart from scabs and management had anything to say about it. It just was not part of the strikers' experience or apparent intentions in those areas.

Candid

Only one candid striker was prepared to say that scabs must know what they were doing when they went out and betrayed not only themselves, but their father's and grandfather's jobs.

"For months Notts men and wives have been living surrounded by scabs, and have endured intimidation and violence. Where were you reporting then? There's no mention of the violence they experienced"

For the scabs in Yorkshire there is virtually nothing to do except drink tea and do odd jobs on the surface. No coal is being mined and the police operation must be highly 'uneconomic', but it's good practice in counterinsurgency Get Name Address month minimum (20p unwaged) contriution from supporters.

I want to become a Socialist Organiser supporter/ I want more information.

Send to. Soctalist Organiser, 28 Middle Lane, London N8 8PL.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 208

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →