Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How Italian workers see the miners' strike

Socialist Organiser no. 210, 2 January 1985 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,406 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

The Committee for Solidarity

with British Miners in Padova (near Venice) invited Colin to travel the province of Venice and put the miners case to Italian workers. Glyn Cousin, who accompanied Colin (to translate) reports or what they discovered.

Some of the men and women back in Keresley who wished us good luck imagined that we would see as many gondolas and historical monuments as factories. In fact the Solidarity Committee in Padova crushed any similar fantasy we may have had; they committed us to a tight schedule of meetings from morn to night for nine days.

We left Italy with ony a dim impression of its physical attractions, but our picture of Italian workers, particularly of their warmth and solidarity, was very -strong indeed.

We took with us an exhibition of photographs culled from Socialist Organiser: photos of demonstrations, women's participation, police, the picket -lines, the soup kitchens, etc. This was invaluable, because many Italian papers and the television reports were as selective as ours in their comments on the strike (though Unita, the Communist Party daily, carries regular and sympathetic reports).

This was also clear from the many questions raised about the Labour Party. Workers scratched their heads and asked: 'If Thatcher is as bad as you say, if her union-bashing is at the level you state, if unemployment is so high, if democracy is threatened in the way you describe - why hasn't the Labour Party been able to provide an effective opposition?" Why indeed.

We talked of the unevenness of support. We spoke of the excitement and energy the strike has generated among many workers, the support it has won from progressives and radicals generally, and the unique role played by women.

But we also debated the failure ef the Labour Party and union leaderships to fight -their ambivalent support or their outright hostility.

In the course of our discussions, workers were developing a growing awareness that Britain is not the genteel democracy that it appears to be in some European imaginations. Many factory delegates, voicing support for us, declared to their We garbled a passage in Stan Crooke's article in the last issue on the Communist Party. It should have read follows:

With workers at a factory in the Venice area the Venice membership that the miners"

struggle is more than a fight against pit closures. It is a frontal attack on the trade union movement in Britain - and all the governments of Europe may well take pleasure in a miners* The erosion of civil liberties in Britain, particularly in the sphere of trade union rights, and the presence of a very authoritarian government in the Common Market, was seen by many workers as a general threat to labour movements throughout Europe.

Interviewed at a radio station Both factions claim to represent the cause of democracy. The Eurocommunists fly the banner of the 'broad democratic alliance' and a critical attitude to the undemocratic regimes in the USSR and Eastern Europe; the Moscow-liners defend their control of the Morning Star in the name of freedom of the press.

Both factions have tried to tally support outside CP ranks.

area Italian workers dug deep for the miners not only because they were moved by our tales of the extreme hardship the miners and their families must endure, but also in recognition of the political relationship between their own struggles and that of In two factories, the factory delegates proposed that workers give two and one hour's pay respectively. They won their motion easily.

In other factories collections had preceded us. In others, they followed our departure.

The Moscow-liners seem to have had more success, getting Tony Benn to contribute a foreword to their 'Class Politics' pamphlet.

In fact the political divisions are not at all clear-cut.

One recent - unpublished letter from six leading Eurocommunists to the Morning Star referred to the *Hungarian counter-revolution' when they meant the workers' uprising of Workers sported 'Coal not* Dole' stickers and placed NUM posters on their union boards.

We visited many factories, in areas that do not make the travel brochures.

Workers wanted to know what the papers never reveal: why were the miners striking? Next, do they have a chance of winning?

They asked about home support. Why don't other British unions strike in solidarity with They asked again and again OR DID 1956.

Many Eurocommunists are also utterly hostile to Solidarnosc; and those who are not would be horrified at the notion of the Polish workers making a revolution against the bureaucrats. Their vision goes no further than advising the bureaucrats to be more liberal.

Conversely, the Moscow-liners are not against broad democratic alliance"

why British workers choose indefinite strikers. In Italy, when strikes are called by the three big confederations, workers usually down tols for a day, half a day or by the staggered hour. They are never asked to come out indefinitely.

This kind of orchestrated "general' strike across the various trade unions made more sense to the Italian workers we met than one section of workers doing battle on its own through an indefinite strike.

The debate was intense on this point. Of course, it's a terrible weakness in the strike that the TUC equivocates and shows no willingness to commit itself to solidarity strikes. We spoke about this frankly and Colin frequently raised the problem of getting people to strike when they fear for their jobs.

But some workers did point to problems with the Italian formulation of a general strike: it's really a one-day stoppage, and this has not always produced the results the Italian labour movement needs, especially now.

Italian workers are suffering their own setbacks and much mention was made of this. They face rising unemployment and a specific attack at the moment on their inflation-linked wages system (which is called the scala mobile).

Weaknesses

Thus the weaknesses of the British trade union movement led us on to some discussion about the limits of the European trade union movement generally.

These discussions made us realise how isolated British workers are from debates and developments across the channel. Italian workers seem to. be much better informed than their British counterparts.

Colin left most factories having shaken more hands than the Queen Mum in her lifetime.

We spoke also to peace movements, solidarity committees. partisan associations, Christian workers, Communist Party branch and regional meetings, trade union officiers, Democrazia Proletaria (a group to the left of the Communist Party), the police trade union (the latter meeting deserves its own article), and a 'democratic magistrate' We gave a number of local radio interviews, taking questions and greetings from listeners who phoned in. We even managed five minutes at a punk concert.

Each meeting deserves its own account. In general the support was impressive.

On a more sober note - the strike has also provided a focus for the expression of local divisions and factions. For example, the union confederations' plans to give miners' children a holiday is seen by some Italian workers as a cosmetic job, as a way of feigning deep commitment where in fact it is shallow.

Our own argument, and that of many in the solidarity committee, was that any initiative from the union officials is welcome. The point is not to denounce it but to build on it, to place further demands on the leadership, and to create wider rank and file support on the back of official initiatives like this.

There is truth to the view that official leaders promote a sort of internationalism to divert attention, from problems on the homefront. It's not all roses in the Italian workers' movement garden - and. of course, the arguments reflected the different political perspectives united in the solidarity committee. But certainly we witnessed a genuine and widespread concern for the future of the British trade union movement.

We came away from Italy convinced that solidarity work of this kind can have many political pav-offs both home and abroad - and more aware of the narrowness of British trade As Colin said, no holiday in Italy would have brought him so close to Italian workers.

Scan page 6

9 was a year of turmoil all over Europe. he confusion following the break up of ee great empires in World War 1Russian, Turkish, and Austrian empires the working class began to assert itself. Russian the young Bolshevik republic

----- pull-quotes -----

Reynolds, a miner from Keresley Colliery, Coventry,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 210

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →