Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

A hell-hole for

Socialist Organiser no. 210, 2 January 1985 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 2,081 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Some Third World countries have de atically. But this 'development' is ofter on the roots of Third World poverty). CAN Third World countries escape underdevelopment? Yes and no. Last week's article looked at Egypt, Cuba and South Korea. Those three countries have "developed" dramatically. But how, to whose benefit, and at what cost?

South Korea is now an industrial power. But it is a hell-hole for the working class.

Its factories probably have the longest working hours in the world - 60 hours normally, often 80-odd, and. that at an incredible pace. It has the highest industrial accident rate in manufacturing in the world, atter Sri Lanka: in its huge Masan Free Trade Zone, one worker in five has a serious accident each year.

Wages are higher than in most other Asian countries: but in 1980 they averaged only £60 a month in manufacturing.

The trade unions are extremely weak and kept under tight control by the dreaded Korean CIA. it is illegal to form new unions. Strikes are banned. According to the sober Financial Times (25.6.84): "There is a real climate of fear. In many cases union officials will consult the police before putting any grievance.."

Christian missions in the working class areas have been smashed up by the police. Even the mildest forms of political opposition to the government are ferociously repressed.

Every citizen is registered, with their fingerprints, in a central computer bank, and kept under watch by a governmentorganised neighbourhood surveillance scheme.

The condition of the working class in South Korea combines the suffering typical of early industrialism with those typical of modern, high-technology capitalism.

The examples of South Korea, Egypt and Cuba indicate that three things are necessary for national development in the Third World. All radical break from of colonialism.

represent a the heritage Child labour being used to sort potatoes the working class.

(Seventh in a series of articles by There must be a land reform, to release resources trapped by out-dated methods of exploitation. A strong state machine must be constructed, capable of effectively enforcing the land reform and constructing the groundwork for late 20th century industry - education and health services for the working class, roads, airports, telephone systems, efficient administration.

The state itself will have to organise major industries like steel and the energy industries: no other unit will be big enough.

If the state is not strong enough to maintain a high rate of exploitation of the working class, then industry will not be able to compete on the world market against more advanced capitalisms.

Funds

And, generally, a substantial flow of funds from abroad will be necessary to finance all this: otherwise the land reform will collapse back into a mass of poverty, with only a few rising capitalist farmers making good, and new industries will falter because of lack of infrastructure and balance-of-payments crises.

South Korea got $12.5 billion from the US between the late '40s and 1970; Cuba got $8 billion from the USSR between 1961 and 1976; Nasser's Egypt sought funds from many sources.

Listing these conditions, 1 think, tells us why the development of the Third World has been so uneven and crisis-ridden. Almost all the Third World states are small and weak veloped' dramn a hell-hole for units in a world overwhelmingly dominated by the big multinationals and banks based in the richer countries. South Korea got massive aid on easy terms for political reasons: most Third World countries still get ripped off by the richer capitalisms.

To write a land reform law is easy, and almost every Third World state has done it. To enforce it against the opposition of the landowning classes is more difficult. Having enforced it, to provide sufficient resources to the new units - smallholdings, cooperatives, or state farms - so that. they do not collapse in a spontaneous 'counter-reform' , is more difficult still.

Some Third World states especially large ones, like Brazil, Mexico, India and partly Indonesia - have been able to promote fairly fast capitalist growth without radical social reforms (or, in the case of Mexico, with social reforms that have been rolled back and corrupted over decades). The result there is that the horrors typical of South Korea (if in less efficient and ruthless form) are compounded with the horrors of a huge mass of people in absolute poverty, pushed out of agriculture yet not absorbed by modern industry.

Exploitation

So: can Third World countries escape underdevelopment? They can develop capitalism, but for the workers and peasants the evils of underdevelopment are replaced — or, worse, supplemented - by the evils of especially brutal capitalist exploitation.

Nasser's 'Arab socialism' was fundamentally just as concerned to secure the conditions for capitalist exploitation as the South Korean dictatorship.

Its methods were different. A number of economic concessions were given to the working. class (protection against sackings, legal limits to the working day), and for many years Nasser undoubtedly had mass support. He wished to form an alliance between the working class and the middle class which he represented, against the old upper classes and against imperialism.

But he suppressed independent working class action: the trade unions were government-controlled, and strikes were banned. And once the middle class had itself become the upper class, the methods shifted.

Under Nasser's successor Sadat they became more similar to those in South Korea.

In fact, the gulf between regimes of the Nasser type and regimes of the South Korean type is by no means as wide as it appears. The Nasser-type regimes tend to shift towards the South Korean pattern over time: and South Korea has a large dose of state capitalism and nationalism.

It is not just a production platform for the multinationals. In fact foreign direct investment in South Korea is quite small — no more than 2% of the total capital. The government directly owns a greater share of industry than in the UK, and heavily controls the rest through its command over credit.

Other fast-industrialising Third World countries have a bigger presence from the multinationals: Brazil, for example. But there, too, the local state has the "central role in the process of accumulation'*, allying with but also bargaining with and imposing restrictions on the multinationals.

So local capitalist classes can develop themselves in the Third World today.- but with the aid of a state machine which they use heavily against the working class.

Cuba

What about Cuba's alternative? A static 'snapshot' picture of Cuban society looks quite similar to Nasser's state capitalism, but the fact that the rule of profit has been broken makes its dynamic quite different. The nationalisation of the means of production and the establishment of a planned economy represent permanent gains for the working class.

Most Cuban workers. it seems, feel freer now than under the old regime, even though their formal democratic rights are fewer. Castro's government has mass support. It is more flexible than the political systems in the USSR and Eastern Europe. Yet it is fundamentally similar.

There is a system of elections, known as Popular Power, introduced in 1976. But it is dominated and controlled by the Communist Party.

No other party can organise. The CP controls all the media. The trade unions are arms of the government. There is no right to THE Tory government has been forced by a middle-class revolt to back down on its plans to abolish the minimum grant for higher education But they will still be charging tuition fees to many students. And they will still be continuing their cuts in money for higher education.

Cutting back extravagance? No. Britain (as of the latest figures, covering 1981) has a smaller proportion of young people getting higher education than any other advanced capitalist country except Switzerland.

The number in higher education is 20% of the population aged 20-24. The figure for other industrialised coun tries varies from 58% for the US, through 37% for Sweden and 30% for Japan, to 21% for Southern Ireland.

Many Third World coun tries educate their children better than Britain does. Thailand has 20% in higher education; the Philippines, 26%; Cuba, 20%; Jordan, 27%; Argentina, 25%.

The Financial Times on Monday 10th reported "a growing trend among major British public companies to make small donations to the Alliance parties, alongside Squalid living conditions of Egyptian workers strike.

There is not even any right to form factions inside the CP. In fact, the CP is not in any real sense a party. It is an administrative machine. Its first congress was held in 1975 - 16 years after the revolution. All major decisions of national importance are taken by a few people round Fidel Castro.

Friend

Rene Dumont, a French socialist and firm friend of the Cuban revolution, wrote in 1970: 'The delegation of full powers to those whom Fidel trusts is almost feudal...His right-hand men have Just received, free, luxury AltaRomeos...that they can use for their personal needs...

*Add in the beautiful villas of the magnificent beach at Varadero, where the officials and their families take free holidays...Add in the sexual privileges of the 'new class' which count for a lot in Cuba...

*And so a new leading group is being constituted in Cuba, certainly benevolent towards workers and the poor people, but in a sense often paternalist; for the latter no longer have the right to speak out if they become larger contributions to the Tories".

Contributors include Pearsons, Commercial Union, General Accident, Norwich Union, Tate and Lyle, John Swire, and Morgan Crucible.

"Dr David Owen", the FT notes, "has started a series of lunches in the City with leading businessmen which have apparently produced promises of financial support"

The Guardian on Wednesday 12th reported on "murder, ambush, rape, torture, and the burning down of entire villages" to make way for agribusiness and mining projects in the Amazon region of Brazil.

"The EEC is investing $600 million in the Greater Carajas project, a vast mining and agri-business complex covering thousands of square miles. The project has involved building a 1,000mile railway, the world's fourth largest hydroelectric dam, ports and factories and developing more than 2,500 miles of navigable rivers.

"Father Ricardo Resende, from the Church's Pastoral Land Commission said that 28 peasant farmers and smallholders have been killed this year. Some 2,500 families are too critical". *** In time the Cuban workers will rebel against the austerity they face and the lack of true freedom. They will want to form their own trade unions, like Solidarnosc. They will want a new revolution, to establish direct workers' power.

In the meantime, Cuba is not socialist. Its experience is in fact a new proof of the impossibility of socialism in one country.

For a period in the 1960s Castro and his comrades tried to act as revolutionaries internationally: But the USSR bore down on them; and they submitted to the USSR.

National development is possible in the Third World, in various ways. But it is suicidal for working-class socialists to set such development as their aim. It can be realised only on their backs. National revolutions can truly serve the working class only if they become bridgheads tor an international working class struggle.

*Peter Evans, Dependent development: the alliance of multinational, state and local capital ın Brazil' **'Cuba, est-il socialiste?* threatened with eviction.

"Brazilian congressmen believe that the violence is an attempt to clear the region of peasant farmers for the mechanised farming projects of the Carajas scheme. The landowners behind the violence, who reportedly buy judges, bailiffs and police with bribes, claim the land so they can then sell out for high prices when the agribusiness projects get underway.

"The government appears to do nothing to prevent the violence in the belief that foreign investors will find an area free of subsistence farmers more attractive."

The shape of things to come? According to the Financial Times (December 11), Hitachi has invited all workers aged 35 or over at its television factory in Hirwaun, South Wales, to quit, offering a £1,800 tax-free pay-off.

The Japanese company has told its workers that over35s are too slow and inflexible.

This move would bring the factory a step towards the norm in the electronics industry in the Third World, where the vast majority of the workers are young women aged 14 to 25. Above the age of 25 they are considered worn-out and too slow.

Scan page 9

Science - with us or •Revi Socialist Organiser no. 210. January 2

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 210

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →