Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Left Press Saviours from out

Socialist Organiser no. 210, 2 January 1985 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,907 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Gerry Ben-Noah reviews "Sci-Tech Report', edited by Jon Turney. Pluto Press, £8.95.

CAPITALISM presents contradictory images of science and technology. Sometimes, as in the BBC's 'Horizon' series, science is a tool which reveals and solves the mysteries of the universe. Or else, as in "Tomorrow's World', science is a wonderful bag of tricks, from which flows a never-ending stream of useful technological goodies.

Occasionally, though, we catch a glimpse of the dark side of science - nuclear weapons, chemical and radiation hazards, job-destroying automation and computerised surveillance by the State.

These same contradictions run through socialist ideas about science. For Engels, Marxism presented a true picture of the world because it was scientific. Lenin, who knew that the revolution could not take over and use the bourgeois state machine, believed that it could make good use of capitalist technologies of production, including "scientific management"

Argument

There is a curiously unbroken line of argument which stretches from the German Social-Democrats, through Lenin, and Stalin, and back to Harold Wilson, which claims that the "white heat of the technological revolution" is above politics.

On the other hand, some socialists, confronted with a capitalism in which racism and sexism are paraded as justified by scientific truth, and in the jobs, lives and comm of the working class are reshaped by a seemingly nomous and alien force technological progress, concluded that science inherently oppressive tool hands of the ruling class.

Revolutionary SO have tried to reconcile contradictions, often wil formula: science and tech were, in themselves, things, but in the hands bosses they were being bad uses; when we took o would be put to good uses The formula is not 6 wrong, but it is insufficie rapidly becoming more the very midst of the rec capitalism is busily rest ing itself, using scien technology to transfor organisation of producti consumption - both de and industrial - and t seeking to take the initia the class struggle.

Entire sectors of the e are being reconstituted sectors are being create existing ones being des Microprocessors Microprocessors offer the tunity to impose tighter discipline in the mine factory and the office, an away with many jobs entir New technologies of co ication and information rich pickings to those in tion to exploit them, an biotechnologies which ultimately remake the e food, chemical and drug tries, are claiming life it the capitalist market.

All this does not come If the ruling class has it: the workers will pay the and especially in the World" , many workers v with their lives, as parts which unities being autocalled have is an in the cialists these th this inology put to ver the entirely nt, and so. In session, tructurse and m the on and omestic thereby ative in conomy d, and troyed.

opporr work e, the d to do rely. mmuni offer a posiid new will energy, indusself for cheap. s way. bill -* Third vill pay Harold Wilson - "technology above production process are shifted to cheap-labour zones, where repressive regimes guarantee a strike-free environment, and whole armies of workers are broken and blinded in factories where nineteenth century conditions meet twenty-first century products.

But if the working class is to successfully resist all this, if we are to put science and technol ogy to work for us rather than against us. then the first requirement is that we understand what is going on. We must know what the new technological developments are, and what they mean politically: and we need to know about plans and projects that are still on the drawing boards in iversities and offices around the world, not just about technologies that are already arriving in the factories.

Excellent.

There is no better place to start than with Sci-Tech Report. The book is excellent.

It is organised as a series of short articles, 2-3 pages long. There are about 200 of these, each including basic informa tion and references to sources for further reading. They do not assume a high level of scientific knowledge, and should easily be understood by the average SO reader; in any case, the emphasis is on the political implications of new technology, rather than on the technical details.

Most important, the articles are written from a socialist perspective - which makes a welcome change from most accounts of new technology, which effectively ignore the class dimensions of scientific advances.

The book is arranged in three sections. The first, "Technological Horizons" looks at the uses to. which new technologies can be, and are being, put to in industry, agriculture and medicine. The second part, "Producing Science and Technology" looks at the organisation of research - and the experiences of the often-forgotten scientific workers - at laboratory, national and international level.

The final section considers the impact of science on everyday life and culture, at home, at work, and through education and the media. Of special interest, for obvious reasons, will be the item on the future of coal as an energy source, and the one on the poitics of technical progress in the car industry.

But many of the other articles, especially on apparently "nonpolitical" areas of science, will also prove to be extremely valuable. Of course, the politics of the book are not beyond criticism; with more than 100 contributors, there is bound to be some variation, and some of the items are closer to a reformist than a revolutionary socialist analysis.

Overall, though, the collection is virtually essential reading for socialists; and is an antidote to an overdose of "Tomorrow's World' ' it takes some beating. Socialist Action, apparently demoralised about the class struggle in Britain, is looking, if not for saviours from on high' , at least for 'saviours from out there'. Third World revolutions, they say, are the only immediate hope of progress. Colin Foster reports.

BEFORE THE French general strike in 1968 quite a lot of socialists in the US and Western Europe thought that revolution was impossible in the richer countries and would have to come first from the Third World.

Socialist Action seems to be going back to that view.

-On the centre pages of SA of November 16. John Ross argued that the revolutions in Central America are the pivot of politics today And "the conquest of power by the working class is far... further away in time than the conquest of power by the working class in a whole series of semi colonial countries"

Ross put the same argument that workers revolution will be possible here only "in a later phase" in a centre page on January 13 this year. This time he spells it out further, saying that revolution was not even on the agenda in France in May June 1968 "Since the Second World War, with the arguable exception of Portugal in 1974-5 the objective conditions for a working class socialist revolution have not existed in any imperialist country ..

Now obviously the situation in Britain today is nowhere near revolutionary. But to recognise this is different from saying that revolutionary explosions are ruled out for a whole historic era.

As recently as 1976 the same John Ross and his comrades had the opposite view. They were insisting that all southern Europe, including France, was already in a "prerevolutionary situation" and "revolutionary upsurge" , and Britain would be the same within "12 to 18 months"!

Their somersault into pessimism does not make for clear ideas. In 1973-4 they shouted 'general strike' every week. Last week's SA (Dec ember 14) features Tony Benn's call for a general strike in support of the miners. But editorially it proposes only a 24 hour general strike, very diffidently and as a second string to SA's main proposal, a national demonstration to back the miners.

The courts are out to break the NUM - and the revolutionaries' main answer is a march through the streets of London! No wonder they think revolution is so far in the misty future!

Ross's ideas are also not very good for political guidance in the Third World coun tries that he sees as prospects for revolution. In those countries, especially the workers' movement has often been di verted and subordinated by Stalinism. But Ross, in the whole of his long article, has not a word of criticism of Stalinism Also, his panorama of world revolution since 1945 omits all mention of the workers' uprisings against Stalinism. Hungary 1956. Czechoslovakia 1968 Poland 1980-1 His scheme shifts there of politics from class struggl to a conflict between powel blocs: US imperialism on on side - and the Stalinist state! the Sandinistas, the El Salva dor rebels, etc., and (doing it little bit as best it can) th working class on the other.

Fortunately two othe Socialist Action writers, Ph Hearse and Bob Penningtor have taken Ross to task in S. of December 14. "the logic: conclusion of his positio would be to make... solidarit work with the colonial reve lution the decisive task revolutionaries".

But there is more ami: than just John Ross's wal ward pen. Another startlin article, by Oliver Macdonak appeared in SA of Decembe "The Kinnock Chernenk Moscow agreement... was triumph", , Macdonald decla es excitedly. "We can hav security guarantees from th Soviets that will take Britai out of the target area an make Britain more secur than at any time in the la: 35 years". The editorial intro duction says that "the let has to take up and campaig on the Soviet offer"

Naive

the left takes this advi we will look very nai indeed. In a blow-up leadi to World War 3, is a bit paper going to stop the USS re-targetting its missiles? A we really going to campaig in the factories and on th doorsteps with the messag trust the Kremlin?

What do we say to th people who retort: tell th to the Afghans and the Pole (And what do we say 1 people who ask us why we so sure that a threat to th security of Britain' cou only come from the USSR?)

The realistic argument f unilateral nuclear disarm ment is not that it wou somehow make Britain a litt patch of peace in the event a nuclear holocaust. It is thi every working class must di arm its own ruling class, an not wait for the warmonge to agree among themselves i disarm.

Trotskyist

Macdonald and SA, pro ably think that their positic is somehow based on ti Trotskyist policy of defen of the nationalised econom in the USSR against imperia ism. If so, they are wron The economic base of ti USSR is one thing: tl bureaucracy that rules it ar lives parasitically off it is a other. If the economic base potentially progressive, does not follow that the bu eaucrats are well-meanin kind-hearted peace-lovers.

Oliver Macdonald recent suggested in SA that the le should try to develop ti good sides' of the USS while combatting the ba sides' Exiled Solidarno leader Zbigniew Kowales wrote (1 thought) a convi cing reply, arguing for a rev lution against the Stalini system.

Let's hope some SA wri ers do an equally good rep to Macdonald's latest piec But more important. let hope some SA readers sta putting two and two toget er. and concluding that SA editorial board is far from th solid Marxist leadership claims to be.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no. 210. January 2 1985 Page 10 —Christmas films—

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 210

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →