Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

What tactics on pay? Militant invites

Socialist Organiser no. 210, 2 January 1985 · scan p. 11 · about 1,958 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

McCalman reviews the current state of the Senttich Glasgow teachers' day of action against cuts in education. Photo: I THINK the recent letter of Callum MacRae (SO 208) raises questions of general significance as to how socialists behave in the trade unions.

The call for a Pay Review campaign for Scottish teachers was initiated from within the Council of the EIS [the main teachers' union in Scotland] and came before the 1984 AGM of the EIS with the recommendation of the Executive Committee.

I and others within the Campaign for a Fighting Union (CAFU) decided that there were, on balance, sufficient arguments for supporting the Pay Review campaign as a tactic.

We were strongly attracted by the possibilities of initiating industrial action from August onwards and building up the combativity and consciousness of the membership through a series of escalating struggles. That perspective has proved to be correct.

Since the beginning of the session we have had a very effective ban on any curricular development for the new S Grade to replace the present O level and Higher exams.

George Younger, the Secretary of State; had invested a good deal of prestige and money in the launching of these new courses.

The devolved nature of the campaign has also enabled activists to intensify action at a local level. In Ayrshire there has been picketing of in-service courses and in Glasgow a tussle between Left and Right in the local leadership over a ban on administrative duties.

There have been two one-day strikes in the course of December, with an 80% turnout on the first day and hopefully an equally good response on the second day, December 12.

inally, 1 there is now to be i ballot on intensified industrial action in January with a strong "yes" recommendation from the Executive.

Keyed up

Never before in my 15 years of teaching have I seen the membership so keyed up for action on an officially-led wages campaign.

Would that have been possible without the Pay Review focus? We think not.

More likely we would have gone through the motions of drawing up a claim and then left it lying around, as we have seen the NUT do in England and Wales, until the annual ritual of pay-jousting began in February and fizzled out in April. It was precisely to avoid that scenario that we went for a Pay Review and have so far been vindicated in that.

Callum does not dispute any of the foregoing. But he raises the spectre of the Pay Review being la trojan horse for a productivity deal which will trade off conditions of service for more money.

Surely Callum is guilty of a certain naivety on this score. He must know full well that wages and conditions of service are negotiated through the same body, and the management try to link the two issues on some sort of "productivity deal" at any time, irrespective of Pay There are added dangers of such an approach with the Pay Review tactic. So we in CAFU moved a resolution against any "trade off" at this year's AGM, and it only missed being endorsed by 30 votes.

We have not let up on that issue. As a platform speaker at a rally in Glasgow last week, I again spelled out the message that "we have nothing to sell" to strong support from the audience.

Non sequitur

Callum's remark about placing "our future wage levels in the hands of such an unaccountable committee" is a total non sequitur. The demand is for a Pay Review, comparable to the Houghton Report in 1974 or the Clegg Report five years ater. It is not for a standing Pay Review Board which, as Callum knows, is completely against union policy as spelled out at previous conferences.

If the Pay Review demand is such a fiendishly clever manoeuvre dreamed up by the right wing in which the muddleheaded CAFU supporters have become enmeshed, why is it that Younger should not have seized the offer with both hands? Why is it that he should have resisted since August, and now, after a good deal of sustained pressure, seems likely to reply in the negative?

Can it be that he realises that any such Review will reveal a 30% drop in real wages for teachers since 1974 and that this will then provide a focus around which teachers will mount an even more intense campaign of disruption?

We enter a truly Alice in Wonderland situation when Callum tells us that the extraction of such a Review from the Secretary of State would be a blow to Scottish teachers. That view can only have validity if it is based on the assumption that we will passively await its findings and their implementation or non-implementation.

Callum refers to a statement by "the leadership" (which body he does not say that there will be a "moral obligation" on the government to honour the findings of such a Review. I doubt that a majority of the national executive believe that the government will hand us the findings of a Review on a plate. In any case, such innocence is not shared by CAFU, whose supporters have always been Rick Matthews (IFL) well aware that a major campaign of industrial action will be needed to implement such findings.

From the beginning of this campaign CAFU supporters have spelled out consistently on paper and platform that the Pay Review campaign is a tactic, to mobilise the membership and provide a tocus tor the struggle.

end of January Younger is still holding out against a Keview, then the focus must change to this year's claim to be submitted in February..

CAFU supporters gave notice of this change in emphasis at the November Council and will fight for that shift in focus by the February Council meeting.

In comparison to the record of CAFU - endeavouring to tie down the national executive to no "trade off'; initiating and leading action since August onwards, especially through OU mittee of Management; trying to grapple with the changing nature of the campaign what has been the record of Lothian Rank and File? Monotonously to reiterate their demands for the NUT claim and all-out strike action.

Single scale

I have not read the fine print of the NUT claim. I gather, however, that it is not a simple "across the board €1,200 claim" as Callum suggests. It contains, I believe, much larger percentage increases for the promoted.

It certainly does not appear to be applicable without modification to Scottish conditions where we have fought a long battle for a salaries strategy which prioritises weighting towards the upper end of the unpromoted scales and the achievement of a single salary scale with a common maximum.

Once we have studied these issues fully, CAFU will formulate our view of the 1984/5 wage claim. We are not in the UMEENSCOUAND SE I. business of mindlessly reproducing other people's slogans.

What of that other demand -"all-out strike action"? A recent Inthian Rank and File leaflet calls for "All out action in January"

R-r-revolutionary

I presume that means all out, indefinite, unpaid strike action from January 9 onwards. Why then was that specific demand not raised at the November Council meeting by Lothian Rank and File supporters?

How many schools in Lothian, or anywhere in Scotland, have passed that specific demand? (In how many has it been even put forward as a motion?)

I have not heard of any, but would be thrilled to learn that such an advanced level of consciousness existed among teachers. Or is it just another slogan dreamed up to prove how r-r-revolutionary its authors are?

Callum's points on the SWP are also germane to the argument. Callum refers to my "trying to exclude them [the SWP] from the organisation of a Scottish left teachers' conference"

Just for the record - I work amicably with members of the SWP in a local miners' support group. I have collaborated with SWP teachers to organise a meeting billed Teachers in AT its most recent meeting the General Management Committee of Springburn Constituency Labour Party (Glasgow) voted to shut down the constituency's Labour Party Young Socialists (LPYS) branch, while further enquiries are made into events at the LPYS branch meeting of November 15.

The reason given was that at that meeting the Militant supporter chairing the meeting had allowed two non-Labour Party members to vote, in an attempt to ensure that Militant supporters were elected as delegates to the LPYS Scottish regional conference., This decision by the CLP, backed by both the right wing and the Labour Co-ordinating Committee supporters, is a witch-hunting move. Militant deserves unconditional support against any witch-hunt.

But it must be said that Militant virtually invited the latest attack by the undemocratic machinations of its supporters. Socialists have to condemn such actions.

There are a number of other current examples in Scotland of Militant behaving less than democratically and then finding themselves on the receiving end of a witch-hunt.

The Labour Party Scottish Council has recently carried out a survey of Scottish LPYS branches to establish how many members they have. (It turns out that there are only 700 official LPYS members in Scotland -just over ten per branch). Anyone who believes that the LCCdominated Scottish Council will not use the contents of the survey for witch-hunting purposes is naive in the extreme.

But Militants' protests are weakened by the bureaucratic manner in which it controls the LPYS and stifles attempts to set up the democratic forms of organisation which would have denied the Scottish Council the pretext for holding its survey.

The Scottish Council is also asking LPYS branches for details of how much money they have collected for the miners and stressing that all money collected should be sent to the NUM itself (as opposed to individual pit villages). This constitutes an attempt to break the growing links between mining communities and the rank and file of the labou movement.

Yet it cannot be denied that Militant's ultra-sectariar behaviour in many miners support committees and their subordination of support for the miners to their own factiona concerns have left it isolated and wide open to attack on this issue from the Scottish Council.

And Militant has left itsel open to attack in many other ways. The well-known refusal o the Militant-controlled LPYS paper Socialist Youth to prin articles expressing non-Militan points of view, for example must weaken its own denuncia tion of undemocratic attacks or itself.

sumiters in hasgow Polo CLP voted for the expulsion of : socialist (myself) and thei Militant supporters in Glasgov Central CLP successfull opposed my attempt to re-appl! for membership of that CLP that did nothing to strengther its arguments against the expul sion of its own supporters.

Militant is 100% correct ti say that a witch-hunt is unde way in Scotland. When the lates issue of the LCC's Scottisl magazine states that "nowhen else in the Party would suc intolerance and sectarianisn be accepted - there is n reason why we should accept i in the LPYS", it is clearly no merely an abstract attack or 'intolerance and sectarianism but a very specific attack o Militant as part of a genera And Militant is also 1009 correct to expect the serious lel to defend it against this witch hunt. But the serious left ha consistently done this, even i the face of Militant's persis tent refusal to involve itself i united opposition to witch hunts.

What Militant cannot expec though, and what no socialis should be prepared to provide is freedom from criticism fo its factional, often dishones sectarianism.

----- pull-quotes -----

Ian McCalman reviews the cu teachers' pay campaign, and with Callum McRae (Socialist

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 210

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →