[This is the second part of Michael Farrell's…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
This is the second part of Michael Farrell's article on the 1919 Engineers and Shipbuilders strike in Belfast. It tells the story of how unity between Catholic and Protestant workers was destroyed by the employers and Belfast. By mid-June 1922,23,000 Catholics had fled from Protestant terror in Northern Ireland the strike committee hesitating to the strike and after the strikers' ble display of loyalty to their bosses - was ripe for negotiations. Lord hairman of Harland and Wolff, and ment Controller of Merchant Shippin Belfast for Cuming's funeral. On day February 5, he met a delegation strike committee. Pirrie's proposludicrous: he would arrange a with the shipyard directors if the ervices were restored immediately shipyard went back to work with a week with overtime paid after 47 The strike committee rejected this und but a meeting with the directors inged anyway, without conditions. negotiations dragged on over the 1, but on Monday February 10, the is proposed settlement terms. The uld return to work on the basis of a week and the employers would call tonal" conference of engineering ers within 30 days and recommend forking week shorter than 47 hours. inference didn't accept this then the fast shipyards would settle with orkers independently within three Protestant bigots.
Meanwhile the strikers had several setbacks. The National Executive of the ASE meeting in London had announced the suspension of its Belfast and Glasgow District Secretaries for involvement in an unofficial strike, the Committees were also suspended. The Negotiating Committee of the UK Federation of Shipbuilding, Engineering and Allied Trades had called on all shipyard workers to return to work. The government too took a hand.
Solidarity
Faced with a threatened strike by London electricians in solidarity with the Belfast and Glasgow strikers, the government made a new regulation under the war-time Defence of the Realm Act. The DORA regulation made it an offence to deprive the community of light or to encourage anyone to do so. Guards were mounted on all power stations and troops stood by to take control. The electricians' strike was called off and this broke the back of the Glasgow movement. It weakened Belfast too.
By now the strike committee was in favour of the settlement proposals. Charles *McKay, the Chairman, told a crowd of strikers "The 44 hour week was as good as won. It might indeed be shorter than 44" The committee began to make arrangements for a ballot of the workers.
There was still fight in the strikers. On Tuesday February 11, the Corporation suddenly restored the public services, gas, electricity and trams. This was contrary to the settlement terms; the men were to stay out till the vote was taken. The Corporation thought they had the workers on the run and attempted to press home the advantage. They were wrong. Strike pickets stopped the trams at Castle Junction, ordered the passengers off and told the drivers to go back to their depots.
The Gas and Electricity Departments were warned that if they didn't go back to the agreed level they would be closed down completely, hospitals or no hospitals. By Tuesday evening the public services had stopped again and the Newsletter was screaming with impotent rage at the "supreme dictators" of the strike committee.
The ballot on the terms offered by the employers was taken on Friday February 14, two days after the Glasgow strike committee had admitted defeat. But a serious problem had arisen. The negotiations had only been with the shipyard employers. It was assumed that other employers would accept the same settlement terms. However the engineering, building and electrical employers refused. They insisted on 47 hours.
So the workers voted on Friday knowing that the settlement might mean shorter hours for the shipyard men but leave the others as before. On the other hand the strike was about to enter its fourth week with many men not getting strike pay and with the Red Clydeside in retreat. If Belfast continued the fight they would be on their own.
Rejection
The result of the ballot was 8,774 for the settlement terms and 11,963 against - a majority of 3,189 for rejection. The skilled workers had voted 2 to 1 against, with the ASCJ five to one against, while the more numerous unskilled workers had a small majority for acceptance. The strike committee reluctantly accepted the verdict and agreed to continue but at the Custom House meeting on Sunday, Clarke declared that if the settlement had been accepted it might have meant the "44". This was countered by a tough speech from Sam Kyle of the Workers' Union but already events were moving fast.
On the Tuesday before the ballot Parliament had re-opened at Westminster and Lloyd George had strongly attacked the strikers, saying "Anarchy is their aim, anarchy is their focus, to destroy not merely trade unionism, bui the state. We are determined to fight Prussianism in the industrial world exactly as v the Continent of Europe, might of the nation. " The st support from William Adams of the Labour Party, who si had been fomented by "re — "as the speaker for a cons he would encourage neither unofficial action"
Military
At the same time in Belfa newspapers, and City Col growing louder in their dem measures against the strike day the Lord Mayor met Sir Frederick Shaw, Comman Ireland and was promised r tion for blacklegs and for ke RIC officers stand guard outs On Saturday the Mayor issu tion inviting "all member munity who are prepared to: an end to the prevailing law unjustifiable attack on the co the citizens (to help) by off vices as workers" and to cor City Hall.
On Saturday night, troops gasworks and power station in battle gear. The men wer to work and most of them stewards who refused to wor and charged under the DO The trams were put back though only a tenth of the up and only a skeleton servi
Scan page 7
SErT ,Ly e fought it on ith the whole ikers got little in MP, Leader id the strikes volutionaries" itutional party revolution nor tion st, employers, incillors were ands for stern rs. On ThursLt. General der-in Chief for lilitary protec/ installations.
O CER ide a warehouse ed a proclamas of the comissist in putting ess and wholly mmon rights of ering their sertact him at the moved into the fully armed and e told to return did. Two shop k were arrested RA regulation. on the streets workers turned ce ran. Strikers Launching a ship returning from a Custom House meeting attacked the trams and fought a running battle with police in Royal Avenue, but they couldn't stop the service and by Monday more tram workers turned up for duty.
Power, gas and trams were restored by Monday and the strike seemed to be collapsing. Seizing their advantage the engineering employers announced that they would re-open their firms on Tuesday and the shipyards on Thursday, all with a 47 hour week. The demoralised strike committee made no attempt to picket the power station or gas works and on Monday night, february 17, they decided to recommend a return to work on Thursday. The decision was unpopular and they refused to reveal it to the crowd outside their offices. Charles McKay announced that there would be another ballot and there were shouts of "Sell-out" and "Who kept the transport workers in when they should have been out with us?"
Broken
The strikers voted union by union on Tuesday and Wednesday but their morale was broken. 20 out of 22 unions voted to resume and the others accepted the majority decision. By Thursday the strike was over. A fifth of the workers stayed out but it was not an organised protest. By the following Monday all were back at work and the troops were withdrawn. The cases against the power station shop-stewards were dismissed - to avoid further trouble - and the greatest industrial dispute in Belfast's history was over.
The shorter hours movement had failed, in Glasgow and Belfast as well as the smaller centres. The workers went back to the 47 hours they could have had for the asking without a strike. But the movement had a sequel.
Legacy
In Glasgow, where the strike was less widespread and sooner defeated than in Belfast it left a legacy of working class consciousness which made Clydeside the stronghold of the ILP and their apparently militant politics for 20 or 30 years. In the 1918 election the ILP had put up 19 candidates in Scotland and won two seats, only one of them in Glasgow. In the local elections of 1920 they won 45 seats on Glasgow Corporation and in the 1922 General Election they won 10 of the 15 Glasgow seats and 20 in Scotland as a whole. From then until their deaths the "Clydeside" MPs dominated politics in the West of Scotland.
Belfast had the same industrial background as Glasgow, the same miserable slums and grinding poverty. The strike had" lasted longer there and had been more widespread. At first the great industrial conflict seemed to have the same effect. In Belfast Labour had been politically weak, Labour candidates four Labour candidates in the 1918 election had come well down the voting list. But on the first Saturday in May 1919, despite the inflammatory attacks of the Newsletter, over 100,000 workers took part in a May Day march from the City Hall to Ormeau Park. At the subsequent meeting the platforms were dominated by leaders of the strike earlier in the year, and they called for Troops and tanks on the streets of Belfast Labour representation in the city.
The opportunity came in January 1920 with the first - and only - Corporation elections held under proportional representation. Labour nominated 20 candidates for the 60 seats and 13 were elected; two of them, Sam Kyle in Shankill and George Donaldson in St Annes, topped the poll. Five of the 13 including Kyle and Donaldson, were leaders of the 1919 strike. This was the strongest ever Labour representation on the Corporation and they were jubilant. They were sure they could smash the Unionist grip on the city inside a few They were sadly disillusioned. As the war of independence in the South gained momentum so tempers rose — or were inflamed → in the North. There was bitter sectarian rioting in Derry in May and June and the speeches at the 12th in Belfast were highly inflammatory. Then Col. Philips, a Banbridge man, and Divisional Commander of the RIC in Munster where his brutality provoked a mutiny, was shot dead in Cork and brought home for burial.
This was made the occasion for a meeting outside. Workman and Clark's shipyard, held with the collusion of the management. One speaker called for a show of revolvers and the expulsion of Sinn Feiners from the yard. It was the signal for an orgy of terrorism in which all "disloyalists" were driven from both shipyards, and most of the engineering works as well. Some had to swim for their lives across the Lagan. That night rioting erupted in the city and continued for five days, leaving 17 dead and hundreds injured.
Tragedy
Perhaps the greatest tragedy was that the expulsions started and were fiercest in the very shipyards and engineering works which had been the backbone of the great strike scarcely 18 months before and where working class solidarity should have been strongest. Charles Mckay the Chairman of the strike committee was expelled: he was a Catholic. But James Baird, a Protestant who had presided at early strike meetings, went as well as did John Hanna, a former Worshipful Master of an Orange Lodge._ Altogether 12,000 men were expelled and about 3,000 were Protestants, most of them socialists, Labour men or militant trade unionists. Thus ended working class solidarity in Belfast. It was no accident that the meeting on July 21 passed a resolution to stand by the employers as: well as expel their fellow-workers.
A sad little footnote was added to the story when the Belfast District Committee of the Federation of Shipbuilding, Engineering and Allied Trades met on October 18, 1920. A letter was read from the management of Harland and Wolff refusing a further request for a 44 hour week and *the Federation decided to defer this matter owing to the unsettled and uncertain position at present prevailng in Belfast" (Northern Whig).
In the face of the pogroms the trade union movement was impotent. The employers must have been well satisfied. The Orange Card had worked again.
next
Scan page 8
211.
THROUGHOUT history most people have been poor. Until recently the main reason for this was that science and technology were undeveloped. The productivity of labour was low.
Such a Third World alliance: is not possible because of competitive capitalist conflicts between the different Third World ruling classes. And if it