Capital and inequality
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
it: from the time of Marx and capitalist Martin Thomas concludes a series on the roots of Engels, we have always argued would 1 Third World poverty by summarising the mechanisms from the international integra- What w that socialism must take off workers' within capitalism which create international inequal- tion created by capitalism, and Russian ity, and arguing that the way to eradicate poverty and therefore is not possible in one for the r exploitation is through international class struggle. country. ies of mo An alliance with elements of the local pre-capitalist ruling classes was politically useful to the capitalist colonial rulers. And in a limited range of lines of production - cash-crops, mining - large profits could be made with low-skilled forced labour.
The drive for profits could be satisfied by pre-capitalist methods, or sometimes (as for example on the sugar estates of pre-revolutionary Cuba) by the most backward and stagnant forms of capitalism; and these forms of exploitation did not call for the prior social revolution and heavy investment (both social and industrial) needed for modern, large-scale, mechanised capitalist production.
Capitalism is evangelical. It always wants to expand. It spreads geographically, and its market economy tends to dissolve and overwhelm the fixed privileges fundamental to feudal or Asiatic modes of production.
The State But this does not happen automatically. It happens through the actions of men and women, and especially of social classes.
The main instrument of an exploiting class developing a new mode of production is the state. Capitalism does not create a world state. It creates nation-states.
Over time, and especially this century, capitalism internationalises economic life. Even around 1800 few countries traded more than three or four percent of their income. Most capitalist countries today trade at least 20 or 30 per cent.
But at the same time capitalism 'nationalises' economic life. The nation-state becomes more and more central to capitalism.
The dual process of internationalisation/'nationalisation' creates all sorts of contlicts and unevenness. The peoples who do not have nation-states, or have weak states, become "underdeveloped"
As well as its levelling tendency, capitalism also has an inbuilt tendency to reinforce inequalities. Unlike previous modes of production, it can grow rapidly not only "horizontally' (by geographical expansion) but also 'vertically' (by continuous revolutionisation of production winın a given geugrapucar narmanhina area).
Growth in a particular state breeds more growth. 'Nothing succeeds like success' is a quintessentially capitalist proverb. Investment flows to the states which already have large markets, good communications, stable administration, and healthy, killed and trained workforces.
Thus gross inequality between peoples moulded, by colonialism, reproduced by the modern capitalism of the multinationals and international banks.
Over time capitalism does erode the pre-capitalist economic forms in the Third World out the process is still often very slow.
National capitalist development is possible today in the Third World - but only, on the backs of the workers and peasants. The prospect of such dar . + -11 L the peoples of the Third World up to West European standards of living is utterly hypothetical. Here and now, and in the foreseeable future, developmeri means brutal exploitation and mass pauperisation as peasants are pushed onto barren land or off the land altogether to make way for capitalist agriculture.
But socialism does not promise better national development*. It never has promised it: from the time of Marx and Engels, we have always argued that socialism must take off from the international integration created by capitalism, and therefore is not possible in one country.
Socialism cannot deliver A reve Socialism cannot deliver better national development: doualanmant. othar socialist revolutions in individual countries can do many things, but they cannot provide a magic potion for economic growth in isolation from the world market.
Cuba's revolution has not ended its dependence on sugar; nor, isolated in one country, could it have done even if it had been led by the best of Marxist parties. In China a go-it-alone policy was viable for a period because of the huge size and resources of the country; but now China, too, is re-entering the world market. The way it does it is determined by the politics of the privileged bureaucracy which rules China: the fact that it has to do it is not.
Socialist revolution cannot change the basic facts of inter-. national interdependence. After Russia's revolution, Lenin and Trotsky repeatedly pointed out that the new workers' state was dominated by the capitalist world market, and would face disaster without workers' revolutions elsewhere. What was true for the huge Russian economy is doubly true for the relatively small economies of most Third World states.
A revolution not extended to other countries will either collapse or lead to a USSR-type regime, as in Cuba:
With the resources of the international economy geared to the task, Third World poverty could quite quickly be wiped out. And there is no other way. people or he him orace This does not mean that, the wait for socialism to com the richer countries. The Third World could lead the richer countries into socialist revolution. And the economic unification of areas like Latin America or Africa, under a socialist government, could permit serious progress even while capitalism remains in the richer countries.
But the alliance we must international socialism - not an alliance of the Third World (all classes included) against the richer capitalisms, with the aim of national development. imperialist trade unions in the Third World. The Labour Party and similar parties support such groups in the Third World as the ruling parties of Mexico and Singapore.
And the majority of the Left in the West European labour movement. who object to such links. have links instead with Moscow and, its network of dependent states.
We must fight for the resources of our movement to be directed instead to helping independent workers parties and unions in thei Third World. Direct links with the emerging black unions in South Africa, and the development of international combine committees in multinationals. are obvious priorities. Alongside such links. we may perhaps be able to rebuild an international workers Marxist movement of the same: quality as the Communist International of Lenin's day. *Most Marxists disagree: they argue that capitalism prevents Third World development by constantly draining surplus from the 'periphery' of the world economy to the 'centre'; that the development which has taken place in the Third World is phoney and bogus; that as long as Third World countries remain capitalist, they cannot escape colonial (or, at least, 'neo-colonial or 'semicolonial') status, that socialism, and only socialism, can break Third World countries from the world economy and thus permit national development; and that. the fight for national development thus 'grows over' into social: ism.
The basic texts of this school of thought are Paul Baran's 'The Political Economy of Growth' and Andre Gunder Frank's 'Capitalism and Underdevelopment in Latin America'. . For some concise. criticisms, see the relevant chapters in Anthony Brewer's 'Marxist Theories of Imperialism', • and Robert Brenner"s article in New Left Review no. 10,4.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser no. 211. January 9 1985. Page 9
----- pull-quotes -----
fight for is of the workers of diff- erent countries, with the aim of