Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Was Lenin a technocrat?

Socialist Organiser no. 211, 9 January 1985 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 618 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

Gerry Ben-Noah (in his review of Jon Turney's 'Sci-Tech Report' SO 210) claims that Engels, Lenin, Kautsky, Stalin and Harold Wilson were all technocrats, united by "a curiously unbroken line of argument" which uncritically accepts capitalist science and technology.

It seems a strange consensus! Strange and, I think, imaginary.

Wilson did promote a version of 'socialism' which was little more than an efficient welfare capitalism. Some in the German socialist movement before World War 1, though more radical than Wilson, also had a rather limited reform-fromabove vision.

But Lenin? Take for example his interest in 'scientific management', cited by Gerry as proof positive of Lenin's lack of critical insight.

At the same time as Lenin advocated seeing what the USSR could borrow from US 'scientific management', he characterised the Soviet economy as state capitalism.

True, Lenin used this phrase to give extra sharpness to his efforts to debunk the romantics who thought that the backward, isolated USSR was going to move rapidly into full-fledged communism. Trotsky insisted anxiously (and I think rightly) that the term 'state capitalism' could only be used in a qualified way, as it were metaphorically.

But the basic idea was clear: that the USSR had first to attain civilised capitalist standards of technology, education, culture - and management - before it could move forward to socialist forms.

Lenin did not think that 'scientific management' was class-neutral. It was precisely because it was typically capitalist (but advanced-capitalist) that he advocated it.

And what of Marx and Engels? Marx wrote in 'Capital': *It would be possible to write a whole history of the inventions made since 1830 for the sole purpose of providing capital with weapons against working-class revolt"

Hardly uncritical applause for technology! And all the evidence is that Engels' views were the same.

They considered that science and technology were fundamentally progressive - to the same extent that, and with the same qualifications, that capitalist development is progressive.

This capitalist progress will have to be superseded by socialist progress (and the supersession will not be a sweet, gentle evolution - history advances always by the bad side, as Marx put it).

So I think we can look to a socialist science and technology superseding capitalist science and technology. But - and this is crucial - such a socialist science cannot be created at will, here and now, as a "proletarian science'.

The working class, as a slave class, cannot create its own proletarian culture. It can create a new culture only when it frees itself fully from its slave status - but it does that only by abolishing itself as a class and creating a classless society.

The productive forces created by capitalism are not classneutral. But they can be transformed only by way of the working class mastering them and gaining control of them — not by trying to erect a new 'proletarian' set of productive forces alongside them.

That - as I understand it — is the Marxist theory. It is as different from Harold Wilson as it is from romantic antiscience and anti-technology ideologies.

THOMAS, Islington. have only 22 matching pairs with one odd pair - an X and a shorter Y chromosome.

The gene for an essential blood-clotting substance called Factor 8 (F8) is on the X chromosome and in men there is no back-up copy.

We will now look at an actual case history, to see how this works out in practice.

Queen Victoria seems to have suffered a mutation in one F8 gene. This did not affect her health, but the eggs she proGet SOCIALIST ORGANISER each door by post.

RATES: £8.50 Name .

Address Please send me months' To: Socialist O r, 214 Sir

Scan page 10

211.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 211

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →