Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Working to lose

Socialist Organiser no. 211, 9 January 1985 · scan p. 10 · about 1,146 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Last week's editorial in the Labour Left weekly, Tribune, lambasting 'ultra-leftism' seemed to mark shift from that paper's recent 'Bennite' alignment. John O'Mahony and John Bloxam write an open letter to Tribune's new editor, Nigel Williamson.

CASTLE'S test case 1984 50p Nigel Williamson Photo: John Harris Dear Nigel, Your editorial in last week's Tribune caused the press to write about new divisions on the Left and of Tribune breaking with Tony Benn.

It is easy to see why. You write with an even-handedness as between the Left and the Kinnockites that suggests someone parodying the standard parody of a Guardian editorial.

It is a spurious even-handedness. The sharp edge of your criticism is turned against the serious Left, while the gist of what you write is to suggest that the Left demobilises itself and accommodates to Kinnock in the hope of weaning him from his close links with the right wing.

Your criticism of Kinnock is muted and perfunctory, like the comments of a man who inwardly accepts the status quo. Your comments on the serious Left express irritation and something very close to denunciation.

Far That you implicitly denounce Tony Benn is the measure of how far the editorial takes Tribune.

Now, of course, an editorial does not necessarily make an entirely new outlook. But if Tribune is going to be guided by last week's editorial, then it will be truly back in the fold -perhaps back to what it was in the days of good king Richard Clements.

You are right in some of the basic things you say, and right also in your starting point. It is a life and death question for Labour to win the Tory-imposed trade union plebiscites on the political levy. The Left must do everything it can to win the next election. You may even be right that the election will be won or lost in the next year, though that is not so calculable.

Your conclusion from these general considerations seems to be that the Left should lean to the Right, forget about most of its own concerns of the last period, and go for an alliance with the so-called centre. In other words - that the Left must now substitute the goal of winning the next election under Kinnock, with Kinnockite policies and prospects in office, for the goal that has defined the serious Left over the last five years: to change the Labour Party and thus provide a real alternative to Thatcherism.

That goal was nicely summed up in the slogan the Left adopted after the end of the last Labour government: 'Never again' -Labour must never again put forward a government like that one.

It is, of course, easy to understand the mood and psychology of your editorial. Even a Labour government led by Dennis Healey would be preferable to the Tories. The five year battering the labour movement has taken since 1979 naturally nourishes a feeling that the Wilson/Callaghan government was not so bad after all. Labour's defeat in 1983 softened and un-nervered many who boldly set out in 1979 to make sure that 'never again"

And the experience of the Left in local government in the last few years has also undermined the drive for a new start: the Left has put itself to school in the old Herbert Morrison school of reformist politics, working within the capitalist system and makling choices within its confines.

All this explains the mood that now expresses itself in Tribune. It does not justify it, or TONY BENN VOL 49 BARBARA GRENADA NO 1 page seven:

coming year. THE next general election elections are not decided in the #MessAess the year it go five VALERIE HASSANI to come true started contre page next election. age our chances of winning the and the man from the Holy Office surrounded by armed guards.

Unconditional commitment to parliamentary democracy even though the ruling class revise, or break, its rules as they go along, like they have done during the miners' strike — is not up for discussion. It is being laid down as the fixed dogma of the Party establishment of the Parliamentary Labour Party, and of official socialism. It will be used against the Left as Kinnock has already used it against the miners.

There will be no debate about parliamentary democracy and class struggle - about what happens in a long-stable parliamentary democracy (like Chile's) when the class struggle rises very high - about the crippling incompleteness of the democracy we have won so far in Britain, or about the democracy we need to develop in a socialist society.

Parliamentary

There will not be a debate, but an attempt to re-define membership of the Labour Party in terms of unconditional commitment to Parliamentary democracy.

For the socialist Left, democracy is an irreplaceable part of the socialism we strive to establish, and an aspect of the struggle to overthrow the system. For the centre and the right, present-day parliamentary democracy, with its cross on a ballot paper once every five years, is the pinnacle of achievement, in a capitalist system that they do not want to overthrow and replace by socialism.

There is no real common ground on this question, except on such questions as defending our existing hard-won rights. And even here there is a difference. Neil Kinnock has been much less vehement against the police-state regime established in the coalfields for most of the last year than he is in demanding of Labour councils that they should keep within Thatcher's Central to your whole picture of where we are now, and the choices we have in this situation, is the idea that the labour movement and its leaders are passive creatures to which things happen.

Thus, for example, we must refrain from raising the call for a general strike that is, for generalised solidarity with the miners - because it "cannot be delivered"

This approach softens your attitude to Kinnock and the trade union leaders, and leads you to be grateful for anything positive you can discern in them. Kinnock deserves praise because he has stopped (or paused in) adding his voice to the chorus of condemnation of the miners' strike - that is, helping the scab-herders - and he should, not now be condemned for refusing to throw everything he has behind the miners.

We must stick to "winnable and realisable aims and objectives". . And since the Left controls none of the existing levers of power (not even Tribune!), we must accommodate to the status quo and the leadership — to the "winnable and realisable aims and objectives" they set, or can be persuaded to set.

With this approach no radical socialist politics are possible -except perhaps in freakishly favourable circumstances."

Continued next

----- pull-quotes -----

1988, but one of the lessons of (VICTORY/ the image which a party presents TO THE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 211

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →