Ethiopian Jews
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-09Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
ON Monday December 17, CPSA members at Newcastle return to work to be negotiated, thus ending their eight month old dispute.
An unanimous vote of no confidence in the leadership at the same meeting, showed how the strikers felt about the role of CPSA general secretary Alistair Graham and the National Executive Committee.
The strike began last May, when management introduced new shift rotas which would have meant sizeable pay cuts for the shiftworkers (up to £14 a week in some cases).
The strike leaders, influenced by the Militant tendency originally declared that the dispute could be won in Newcastle and opposed escalation of the strike to local offices. By August, with the fight into its fifth month, the strike committee had begun to call for the action to be widened.
Initially, the National Executive Committee agreed in principle to escalate the strike to computer centres in Reading and Livingstone. Votes at these two sites showed majorities in favour of joining the dispute when the NEC called them out.
But by this time NEC memBy Steve Battlemuch and Mike Grayson and Mike Grayson bers from the Department of Employment were arguing against this form of escalation because of the effect it would have on local Unemployment Benefit Offices. Reading and Livingstone send out dole giros, and if they were stopped, UBO workers would have to write out 1½ million giros a week by hand.
At the next NEC meeting, the vote to bring out the two computer centres was lost. The strike remained extremely solid, but it became increasingly clear that Alistair Graham wanted to be rid of it, especially after members of the management union SCPS voted to return.
Matters came to a head at the NEC meeting in mid-December.
Alistair Graham tabled a motion saying that the strikers had got as far as they could get and should negotiate a return to work. This was defeated, since some of the soft-left (Broad Left '84) NEC members voted with the Broad Left.
Militant supporters then moved that all computer centres be brought out. This was also defeated, with the soft left voting against.
Then, after some NEC members had left the meeting, bers had left the meeting, Graham's initial motion was Graham's initial motion was resubmitted by a member of Broad Left '84. This time it was passed.
The Newcastle strike committee then felt it had no alternative but to recommend a negotiated lost.
28% of those voting backed the proposal to give £5000 a month to the NUM in the form of food vouchers, and to offer an interest-free loan of £100,000. but the majority was against, and the number of votes cast - 45,500 — was disappointingly low.
This is a severe blow to CPSA activists who have been supporting the miners - and, obviously, to the miners themselves. But rank and file support will continue, whatever ine view or the NEC in light of the vote.
CPSA's conference last May voted to give support to the NUM, but a number of resignareturn to work. return to work.
The role of the NEC members The role of the NEC members who recently left the Broad Left to set up Broad Left '84 should be a lesson to all activists who will shortly be recommending NEC nominations to their Branch AGMs. out endorsement by the members: but then they failed to put in the necessary work for a successful campaign.
For the duration of the strike, the left has had a majority on CPSA's National Executive Committee, but its main achievement has been to tear itself apart, rather than to campaign for the miners.
Activists in the branches must take the disappointing result in the December vote as a spur to step up their solidarity work. Inere is a lot. or support for the NUM amongst civil service vorkers: more effort must be made to coordinate and build on it.
By Emma Nichols 12,000 Ethiopian Jews are safe from starvation, and it is an enormous propaganda coup for the Israeli state.
It is an effective propaganda coup precisely because the Ethiopian Jews deserve to be rescued. To use anti-Zionist phrases to denounce the airlift — as Arab regimes have done -or to complain about 'an infringement of sovereignty" as Ethiopia has done, is to try to use democratic principles to justify inhumanity.
But the airlift also highlights many sordid features of the Israeli state.
The 12,000 are safe from starvation (though 7,000 Jews remain in Ethiopia now that the Ethiopian government has called on Sudan to halt the operation). But millions of other Ethiopians are starving, and the Israeli state shows no concern at all for them.
Zionism
Central to Israeli ideology -Zionism — is the notion that the Jewish state is the only way to save the Jewish people. It is not necessary to assume that the Israeli government had no genuine concern at all for the Ethiopian Jews, but for sure they were glad of the chance to "prove their point" so spectacularly.
Although some Zionists do not see the safety and survival of Jews alone as their only concern, the practice of the Israeli state, and of the Zionist movement outside Israel, shows very little concern for other victims of oppression.
Operation Moses, in that sense, is similar to Zionist campaigns to allow Jews to leave the USSR: their concern is with Jews alone, and their concern is that the Jews should emigrate to Israel, rather than anywhere else. (In fact most of them don't go to Israel, and many prefer the US).
More macabre still, the Ethi opian Jews owe the airlift only to the fortunate outcome of a theological argument nine years ago. If the majority of the rabbis had decided differently that the peculiarities of Ethiopian Jewry made them not Jewish at all - then the Ethiopian jews could starve to death without Israel feeling much concerned.
Then again, comments from Israeli sources not fettered by official hypocrisy indicate that the Ethiopian Jews will find Israel much less than a warm and welcoming haven.
Israel's European Jews are notorious for their racism towards black Jews. The mayor of Eilat (a port on the Red Sea) is quoted as having said: "[only] send us those who know how to sing and dance, so we can set up a folklore group for the tourists"
Israel was originally established as primarily a white-settler state — in 1948 only 8% of the Jewish population were of African or Asian origin.
A huge influx of African and Asian Jews followed in the early 1950s - pushed by the reflex anti-semitism of Arab regimes, pulled by the Israeli state eager to prove its point that Jews could not live in peace in non-Jewish societies, and to secure cheap Jewish labour so as to continue their 'Jewish labour only' policy.
The Zionist promised land, however, turned out to be a capitalist state. The Jews of African and Asian origin -now 45% of the total, as against 40% of European and American origin, and 15% second generation Israelis — are oppressed by a mainly-white establishment.
Racist
The Ethiopian Jews can expect resentment both from white racist Jews and from many other black Jews. The poorer oriental Jews already feel threatened by Arab cheaper labour. The Ethiopian Jews are seen as a further threat.
And the final irony is this: many of the Ethiopian Jews, whose plight is in part due to the legacy of imperialism and racism, are now being trained for military service for the Israeli state — a state sponsored by imperialism and founded on racist expropriation and oppression of the Palestinian Arabs.
The Israeli state is also a major supplier of arms to the repressive Ethiopian regime, and the Sudanese government has alleged that the whole airlift operation was linked with an arms deal.