Another new realism?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
John O'Mahony and John Bloxam conclude their open letter to Tribune's editor Nigel Williamson with a reply to his "be realistic" approach - which in effect means an accomodation to the status quo and the existing leadership and their aims.
They argue that a decisive, fighting party openly committed to working class struggle can and would provide a generating focus for anti-Tory and socialist struggle; and that to see this become a possibility, the fight to transform the labour moveIf the trade unions had campaigned vigorously for work-sharing without loss of pay when the unemployment figures began to spiral upwards, then the labour movement could have been roused to make Britain ungovernable, and things would be very different now.
If the leaders of the Labour Party had launched a vigorous campaign of agitation, the labour movement could have been given the heart and confidence for a big fight back against the Tories.
If the TUC had fought — agitated, campaigned for solidarity action with the miners, then the propaganda of the press could have been countered.
A better Labour and trade union leadership would have linked other workers' struggles with the miners' and created a combined offensive against the Tories.
Who says that a general strike cannot be delivered"?
On a cold calculation of existing quantities, of course, it won't be delivered. But a fighting, campaigning, labour movement leadership could still rally the movement around the miners. At any rate, it should still try, and socialists should insist that it is the duty of the existing leadership to try:
A year ago, who would have imagined that the miners - who had twice rejected Arthur Scargill's calls for action in ballots - would be capable of the epic ten-month battle they are fightng now and can still win?
This or that cold calculation ment must continue.
Nigel Williamson. Photo. John Harris TONY BENN BARBARA #GRENADA VOL 49 NO 1 CASTLE'S est case page five VAHERI WASSAM started THE will be won or lost over the and dramatic given that mal not come until I VICTORY lave seriess the year It /Reaganks 4064 100л 5л. vup contre page Win bilities collapse into accepting the best (or less than the best) option within the system. They become the blinkered politicians that Antonio Gramsci wrote about.
It is to be or not to be for socialists: do we fight for a different system, or make our peace with the best options within this system ('for the time being', and by way of accommodation to such of its organs as the Parliamentary Labour Party....)?
You present your case as a matter of being realistic. It is hardly realistic even in Gramsci's sense of seeing no further than the ends of our noses.
The truth of the matter is that the Kinnockites have no answer to Thatcherism. They have no coherent, credible "realisable aims and objectives" that answer the needs of the working class in a Britain rotting all around us. centre: You and the Kinnockite centre forget not only the lessons of the last Labour government, but also the lessons of all post-war British Resistance For most of the 1960s and 1970s the ruling class were prevented from ruling Britain as they wished and from 'modernising' it in their own way by the resistance of the working class. The working class was strong enough to stop measures of capitalist reform, and strong enough to knock Heath's government out of the ring in 1974.
But we were not able to solve the protracted crisis of decline which has afflicted British society for decades. Labour governments tinkered with a system that needed to be overturned and uprooted to make way for socialism.
The best elements of the working class confined themselves mainly to industrial struggle. We frittered away our chances. The Labour government of 1974-9, which rode to power on a great wave of working class direct action, cut working class living standards in the mid-'70s, pioneered "Thatcherite' cuts and monetarism, and went down to ignominious election defeat after the 'winter Antonio Gramsci of discontent' in 1978-9.
No wonder there was cynicism and apathy in the working class!
Then to that was added the grotesque passivity and failure to lead of the TUC, faced with the slump and the Thatcherites' attacks. The Tories had us on the run until the miners made their magnificent stand So now, one of two things.
EITHER we will learn the lessons, and transform the labour movement into a force capable of taking on the ruling class and imposing working-class solutions to the crisis of British society - in the first place, creating a workers' government radically ditterent from previous Labour governments in that it based itself on a mobilised labour movement and was prepared to cut through and across the ruling class and its property in order to secure the interests of the working class.
OR the ruling class will grind the labour movement down, and perhaps eventually destroy it, as once-powerful labour movements have been destroyed in other countries.
Anti-union laws and the attempt to de-politicise the trade unions are already upon us. Much worse things are possible - as the Chilean workers learned in 1973.
One scenario for such a catastrophe could contain a Kinnockled Labour government. Helpless to solve any of the problems we face, it would further discredit the labour movement, and prepare the way for vicious reaction, as Wilson and Callaghan prepared the way for Thatcher.
On the basis of the existing Labour leadership's present rimid politics, which don't even dare to propose restoring Tory cuts, such an outcome would be a certainty.
That's the true 'realistic" picture, Nigel. It leads to the conclusion that the fight to transform the labour movement goes on and must be won.
You are right that the Labour Party must win the next election - even if it is led by Neil Kinnock with its present policies. Such a victory would encourage the working class and open the way for a more radical working-class fight back. The victory of another wave of reaction would not be inevitable.
But we need realism here too. We will not win the battle for trade union allegiance by lying doggo. We will not encourage workers to fight back by telling them that they should let Thatcher do what she likes as long as she can get a majority of MPs for it. And we will not win the next general election by presenting a tame Labour Party.
The right wing and the soft left could add a postscript to your editorial, Nigel:
*If the Left had not started the struggle for Labour's selfrenewal in 1979; if re-selection had not been pushed through; if Benn hadn't stood for deputy against Healey - ther there would have been no SDP split, no orgy of anti-Labour propaganda in the press. And maybe there would have been a Labour victory in the 1983 general election".
That is a perfectly reasonable account of what has happened in the Labour Party over the last five years - from one point of of view. It is possible to sustain it only if you are more or less satisfied with the state of things in the Party as it is, satisfied with the last Labour government's performance, and content to aim for nothing better next time... or if you have come to despair of anything better.
You cannot say what you say about the future without adopting that view of our recent past - without concluding that we, and you, were wrong to set out in 1979 to change the Labour Party.
That's the measure of how far vour editorial takes ribune. Thinklabout it, Nigel.
----- pull-quotes -----
JAMJARY 4, 1985 Tribune Consider the last five years.