[you make, comrade Williamson, may be reasonable: your…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-16Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
you make, comrade Williamson, may be reasonable: your basic approach is wrong. It rules out of the picture the force which can transform it — working class action. It rules out the pioneering role that the Left must have in generating that action.
Gramsci
Some of Kinnock s entourage, and occasionally Kinnock himself, are fond of citing the Italian Marxist Antonio Gramsci. Gramsci long ago wrote a crushing picture of the basic politics ot your editorial:
"It is certain that to foresee means only to see well the present and the past as movement: to see well, i.e. to identify with exactness the fundamental and permanent elements of the process. But it is absurd to think of a purely 'objective' foresight.
*The person who has foresight in reality has a programme' that he wants to see triumph, and foresight is precisely an element of this triumph... since reality is the result of the application of human will to the society of things... to put aside every voluntary element and calculate only the intervention of other wills as an objective element in the general game is to mutilate reality itself.
*Only those who strongly want to do it identify the necessary elements for the realisation of their will "*Too much' (and therefore superficial and mechanical) political realism, often leads to the assertion that the man of State must work only within the sphere of 'effective reality" not interest himself in what should be', but only in 'what is". This would mean that the man of State must have no perspectives onger than his own nose... List The decisive n element tim every situation is the force, permanently organised and preordered over a long period, which can be advanced when one judges that the situation is favourable (and it is favourable only to the extent to which such a force exists and is full of fighting ardour)..."
So we should believe in miracles? On one level, yes! But not miracles created by "outside' intervention into the processes going on in society.
The 'miracle' is the sudden transformation of working class consciousness. History shows many examples of such miracles. The 1968 general strike in France, for example. It erupted spontaneously only weeks after a call for a half-day general protest strike had been resounding flop.
Explanation
The explanation for such "miraculous' transformations is to be found in the fact that the normal consciousness of most workers under capitalism does not correspond to their own interests. Once changes begin, transformations of attitudes can take place with the speed of an explosion.
Millions of workers voted for Thatcher and acquiesce in the demolition of the welfare state, the scrapping of a council hous ing policy, and the anti-union laws. But it is not in their immediater or long-terminter= next electi ests to do so. From that basic fact comes the objective possibility of quick, explosive transformations.
Of course, we cannot just decide to have a miraculous '1968' next week. But socialists who do not orient towards such possiInference 1984, Photo,
Scan page 11
212.