Organising NUM in Notts
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
GB. The state of the strike is that it is still as solid as it was nine months ago.
SC. They thought the return to work would take place in the New Year but what they didn't realise was that the Christmas period was the hardest to get over, and once people got through that they felt that there was nothing else that could hurt them.
There's also this initiative by the national union to expel the Notts area. It's given a new focal point to the strike in this area and thoughts of a return to work have been pushed to the back a bit.
JB: It has had a good effect, but I think it will have a good effect in other areas, too. Firstly, they can see thạt something is being done about the Notts area, and. also, those thinking about George Broo miners from Bloxam and going back to work may now think twice. But do you think they should have done it earlier?
GB. Yes, but the hands were tied courts.
Delay
SC. For ten months we've said expel them, and it has taken ten months for them to do it. I don't know the reason for the delay, but in Notts the strike is going to take a turn one way or the other. Either men will come back out on strike because they don't want to be diskes and Stan Bevercotes N Pete Radcliff union's by the Crawford, both striki! UM (Notts), spoke to associated from the NUM or the drift back will continue.
JB: The argument, as 1 understand it, about not taking action against Notts earlier on, was that you would push the scabs into the hands of the right wing organisers, the likes of Blessington, Lynk, Prenderghast.
SC: The argument against that is that if you made an example of the ones you've mentioned, and then said to the rank and file, look you've got a decision to make for yourselves, either you stick with the NUM or you get the same treatment as these have got then that gives them the conscious decision which way they are going to go. But they aren't going to do that, they're going to expel the lot.
GB. I think they should. expel the lot.
SC. The trouble now, is that with the Tories today there is no such thing as a closed shop and the mining industry has always been a closed shop I can see there being an NUM and a Spencer-type union and men who don't belong to any union.* JB: wnat should the attitude be to the rank and file who are currently working?
GB: In my opinion, there's mo way they should be allowed to join.
SC. I think there are arguments. The first is that if you cross the picket line you're not in, if you don't cross the picket line you're in.
After the dispute is over, obviously you are going to have to try and build up the NUM and the only people you can do that with is the Action GB. You've got to take some sort of action. After all, some of these scabs have been working for the last ten months, while we've been suffering hardship.
The only thing I can think of is not to give them as much voting power as we have got, because there is a danger, when the strike is over that if the scabs move back into the NUM and take it over in Notts, we'll still have a scab union in the area..
Ashamed
JB. Those who do ioin are not going to be the leading scabs, they are going to be the rank and file scabs who are ashamed of what they've done, want to stick with the NUM because they recognise the need to be, in the union, but who are going to keep pretty quiet.
But isn't the initial problem going to be that if the new NUM starts off. with 2,000 members you are going to be very weak in the area. GB. Weak in the area, but strong nationally.
Difficulty
SC I still think the stumbling block is going to be the fact that strikers who've been out for ten months are not going to like the idea of recruiting scabs to the new NUM.
JB: You've got to find some way of bringing them in, though, or come the next strike, they'll be scabbing again, making it more difficult to win the dispute. GB. Well, I know what I'd do, it there was a dispute involving those who have scabbed and the management, I'd scab on them, an eye for an eye.
PR: I know from my own experience in the steel industry, where we had the National Union of Blastfurancemen scab on a strike, which you get all the time in multi-union organisations. The trouble is that it just continues indefinitely.
POEU
JB: A good example of the problem is the 1971 strike by Post Office workers. When the POEU comes out on strike, the reaction in some offices is to say, to hell with them, they scabbed on us in 1971, I'm going to walk through their picket line.
The best people in the union say, well the 1971 strike is past history, we've got to join together with the POEU to make sure that it never happens again. You can only do that by breaking the chain.
Anyway, I can't see you really scabbing on these scabs when it actually came to it. GB: I suppose not but that's the way 1 teel at the moment. PR: What you have to try and do is continue promoting the morale of this dispute while preparing the ground for a more united struggle in any future dispute. To talk, at this stage of allowing scabs into the new NUM as if everything was forgotten would destroy the morale of this dispute. But if you are thinking in terms of future disputes, you've got to think in terms of getting them organised behind you. SC. If you turn round now and say to a lad who has been scabbing, be it for ten months or two months, that he can reaffiliate to the NUM, the lads on strike are going to turn, round and say I might as well have been at work all the time'. But if you don't say that, the rank and file inside the scabs, like those at Ollerton who signed a petition to stay in the NUM, are going to turn round and say Well, they won't let us into the NUM, so we might as well join Lynk and his mob.' So you are faced with a very difficult situation. JB. Perhaps the only way you can do it is to say to the scabs that if they want to join the union now then they've got to come out on strike, otherwise they can't join the union until the dispute is over, when they will not be allowed to hold office. So you are establishing a link with them, Democracy SC. Talk about democracy! If the scab organisers had a ballot over the rule change which is leading to their expulsion from the NUM, it wouldn't be so cleàr-cut as the division between working and striking miners. But they won't do it. They demanded a national ballot on the strike, but they won't have one on the rule change.
If they balloted every miner in the Notts area, think you'd see a different result. And even if we lost the vote, we'd see more than the 2,000 striking miners voting to stay with the NUM.
It would expose the hypocrisy of the scab leaders and make a lot of people think again.
JB. At today's Ollerton branch meeting, a majority voted against leavchair ruled the vote out of order, claiming that it needed a two-thirds majority. SC. The vote was 117 to 94 and when the meeting was told it had to be a two-thirds majority, some of the scabs got up with the strikers and walked out.
But the way it's coming over is that the Notts miners want to break with the union. A ballot would demonstrate that this isn't true, both to the lads on strike and to the scabs who want to stay in the NUM.
JB: When the union is reorganised in Notts is there any chance that the structure of the two rank and file strike committees will serve as a basis for that reorganised area, and make it more democratic than union structures usually are? SC: Possibly. But one thing I would love to see is total recall so that anybody who is elected into any position in Notts would be subject to instant recall by the rank and file if they decided that what the official was doing was wrong.