Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Women's fightback dayschool Many more battles to be won

Socialist Organiser no. 213, 23 January 1985 · scan pp. 5–7 · Jean Lane · about 2,605 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Jean Lane reports on the highly successful Women's Fightback day school held in Stoke last weekend WOMEN'S TOBACK New issue, no.37, out now. 20p plus postage from 8 Aubyn OVER 100 women, including women from eight different miners' womens' action groups, attended a Women's Fightback day school in Stoke-on-Trent last Saturday, January 19.

Women from Notts, South Yorks, North Staffs, Keresley and Bedworth were there, as well as women from Greenham Common, from local Labour Parties and two women from Kurdestan.

Theme

The main theme of the day school was the problem of how to link up working class women into a national working class women's movement. There were workshops on many different aspects of the women's struggle including Women Against Pit Closures, women in the Labour Party, women in Ireland (and particularly the women in Armagh prison), women fighting the cuts and rate-capping and the women at Greenham Common women.

There were video films including Framed Youth - a film made by and about gays and lesbians, Carry Greenham Home and videos made during the miners' strike.

sue ndon SW

Detailed

A detailed discussion about how we could organise to continue was carried over into the Women Against Pit Closures workshop where we discussed how to link up with other working class women in struggle. Most of the women there felt that the existing national Women Against Pit Closures group should be widened out to more women's groups and be run more democratically.

At the moment only one delegate per area can go to the meetings and that one woman may be representing up to 30 pits and as many food centres or women's action groups. A lot of wife from North Staffs women's action group, talked about the need for the women's struggle to continue after the miners' suike is over. There are many more battles to be won, she said, and we are all fighting the same enemy. down to the women doing the work in the villages.

Many also felt that the way the national organisation is working at the moment doesn't hold out any perspective of continuing after the strike. Some of the women present in the discussion, particularly those from North Staffs, have been fighting on the national committee to get it widened out to more pit areas but also to other support groups.

Sanctions The workshop also discussed the decision to expel the Notts union and re-start the NUM there. Almost everyone felt that the national NUM had not been hard enough on the scabs. Some felt that they shouldn't be allowed into the new Notts NUM at all, while others thought that other sanctions should be made against them.

The women also felt that they did not have enough say in the decision-making inside the NUM and most agreed that women who have worked to hold the strike together and keep the battle going should be represented in some way on the NUM committees and union meetings.

For example, the idea was raised that while a new NUM branch was being formed, there existed the possibility of making sure that it was democratically constituted by electing officials every year rather than every five years — but also of forming a women's section of the union to which miners' wives could belong.

Everybody felt that the discussion had been usetul. Not just a talking shop but with positive suggestions as to where to go from here.

One idea raised was that the strikers' wives could form Labour Party women's sections in their areas, not just to organise support for the strike in the Labour Party, but also to fight for better representation of women in the Labour Party and to have a go at the careerists in the Party.

One woman was so pleased with the way the school had gone so far that she suggested organising one every month!

The discussions in the other workshops went just as well with everyone taking part and in all of them the need to link up the different struggles came across clearly.

The school heard a speech from Neda of the Kurdistan solidarity movement who told us of the oppression by the Iranian Islamic system and how this was particularly oppressive to women. But she also told of how the struggle there, including the armed struggle of women, had raised people's political consciousness - just as political consciousness here had been raised by the miners' strike. She showed how the struggle for women's liberation and for socialism is an international one.

Socialism The day rounded up with Kath Crosby from Women's Fightback drawing the conclusions from the day school, talking of the need to kick the Tories out and to democratise the labour movement as part of the struggle for socialism and calling on women to join the Labour Party, and to join Women's Fightback. Many did.

A collection raised £80 and as eight pits were represented, £10 was taken back to each one.

The success of the day has made us all the more determined to fight for the linking up of working class women into a movement and we plan to follow up with more schools an meetings soon.

Scan page 6

IF THE labour movement lets the miners go down to defeat, then we will have to pay dearly for i miners, the Tories and the bosses would go on an industrial rampage. Strikes would become bitter and scab-herding would become a regular part of the British industrial scene.

The situation cries out for a general strike — a great rallying of the battalions of Labour to back general strike possible? In the slump-weakened state of the labour movement, is a general strike co This week we continue the discussion on the general strike. Jackie McDonough argues that to c nonsense, and Gerry Bates replies on behalf of the Socialist Organiser editorial board.

Troops escort scab convoy through the East End of London 1926 Riot police during the 1968 Frenc I don't agree with the whole of John Mollroy's analysis ("The new Realism... ", SO205), or with the main thrust of his conclusions. But on one point Mellroy is absolutely right: *To call for a general strike as an immediate demand is pissing in the wind".

The crucial need at the moment is to stop the movement of coal and substitutes, and to prevent it being used in the power stations. So far, success on both these fronts has been very patchy, and of course, the blame for that lies to a large extent at the feet, of the union leaders.

But it is also a reflection of the demoralisation that still permeates the rank and file of the unions, due to years of defeats and sell-outs.

Rosa Luxemburg, writing in 1902, outlined two preconditions for what she called the "political issue" general strike: "popular political demand and a favourable balance of forces materially". At the moment, quite clearly, neither of these preconditions exist.

To demand of the TUC leadership that they call a general strike (the only meaning that can be attached to the headline in SO209, "Demand a General Strike") not only seems ludigeneral strike - a familiar scene now crously unrealistic to most miners and rank and file activists, out actually lets the leaders off the hook.

Like Kinnock, they can plausibly (if hypocritically) dismiss such a call as being beyond their power to deliver. Much more effective, therefore, is the demand for the union leaders to implement their own TUC Congress policy: to stop all movement of coal and substitutes and to prevent the use of coal and oil to generate eler.tricity.

This more limited demand, combined with a vigorous campaign amongst the rank and tile for mass picketing of the power stations, corresponds much more powerfully to the requirements of the present struggle, than do grandiose calls for a general strike.

Of course, the situation could change very rapidly. The use of troops to move coal from the pitheads, the jailing of anNUM leader or another major section of workers coming into struggle alongside the miners, could give the general strike slogan an immediate resonance. That is why we should continue to discuss the issue in our propaganda, explaining its implications, how it can lead to the creation of a network of working in many of Britain's mining areas class organisations that can challenge the whole capitalist state and pose the question ofwhich class rules.

Rosa Luxemburg The paper should continue to look at the historical experiences of general strikes, the role of the trade union bureaucracy, the possible responses of the ruling class, etc.

But "simply to incant truisms (as Colin Foster does in SO209) like: "A minority of workers could initiate a mass strike movement in support of the miners" , "despair and cynicism can turn rapidly into hope and confidence" , and (best. of all) 'it is possible", is not good enough. All this leaves aside any serious analysis of the relevance of the general strike slogan as an agitational demand at the moment.

If we followed the logic of namindo Facter'c collu auc through to its conclusion, then we would always raise the general strike slogan, regardless of the particular situation facing the working class.

That would make as much sense as continually calling for socialist revolution on the basis that we live in the "epoch of imperialism" , and that "the objective prerequisites for the proletarian revolution have not only ripened; they have begun to get somewhat rotten"

The continued use of the general strike slogan in our headlines, apparently as an immediate, agitational demand (and I take Colin Foster's point that "SO's slogan has generally been "organise for a general strike") can only discredit what could be a very valuable slogan.

It could also lead us into lining up with posturing ninnies like the Workers Power group, who would divert the next Mineworkers Defence Committee conference away from organising solidarity and into a fruitless wrangle over the general strike slogan.

Ăs Rosa Luxemburg wrote in the 1902 article referred to above, "one only has to cast one's eye over the variety of experiences of this form of struggle (the general strike) and one will see how mindless is ¡ any stereotyping, summary dismissal or glorification of this weapon. THE fundamental case for a general strıke is that it is a logical conclusion from what we say about the stakes involved in the miners' strike.

We say that it is not just a dispute about conditions in one industry. It is a watershed confrontation between Capital and Labour. It is a crucial battle in the Tories? drive to cripple the unions.

That's what Socialist Org aniser says, and that's what most people on the Left say. But then what follows? Either this assessment is wild scaremongering, or we have to campaign for the labour movement to throw its full forces into this battle.

Is a general strike possible? I think so. Jackie McDonough complains that Colin Foster cites only general "truisms" in favour of the possibility of a general strike. But in a situation like the present -where the labour movement is involved in a decisive battle, but the majority even of the militants think that full mobilisation of our forces is 'unrealistic' those 'truisms' about the explosive potentialities of working class action are the most important thing to argue.

Moreover, it is not just a matter of 'truisms'. I accept that the working-class self-confidence for a general strike does not exist at present: but there is recent evidence to indicate that a campaign by top trade union leaders could generate that confidence, and that even a spontaneous explosion from the rank and file is possible.

Look at the one-day strikes called by regionąl TUCs and, last week, by the rail unions.

The regional TUCs are weak bodies anyway. They campaigned very feebly.

Theised by ins certal Try leadership. They didn't have the same possibility that a national all-out general strike would have, of combining a wide range of demands and discontents into a single mobilisation.

Nevertheless, there was a good turnout. There is a solid core of tens or hundreds of thousands of militants who could, be the backbone of a general strike.

Tony Benn Already in the course of the miners' strike there have been several flashpoints where we came close to dramatic extension of the action: two docks strikes, the Austin Rover strike, the possible NACODS strike, the possible industrial action on the railways.

Until recently Tony Benn habitually rejected calls for a general strike on the grounds that it would be an illegitimate "industrial short-cut' around parliamentary politics. After the receiver was sent fin to take over the NUM's funds, he called for a general strike. So did Dennis Skinner, Audrey Wise, anc seafarers' leader Jim Slater.

Why? Are they all ultraleft windbags? Or were they pushed into such calls by the logic of the situation?

What about the defeats and demoralisation that the wörking class has suffered since 1979? Those are real factors. But they should be , kept in perspective.

In relating working-class history we always lay stress on the high points, the aspects and * the incidents which show what the work• ing class • can achieve once stirred to action.

But this can lead to an 'optical illusion' - a mistaken picture of a golden age when every worker) was militant and class-conscious. It was It never like that.

Read, for example, the story of the Belfast and Glasgow general strikes of 1919, currently serialised in SO. Even in 'Red Clydeside' there were plenty of scabs and sellout leaders.

Take another• example. The material conditions for a general strike Were not demonstrably better in 1926 than they are today.

. In the engineers'»lock-out of 1921-22 the trade union movement had suffered a blow greater than any we have had since 1979. The engineering industry had been the backbone of the shop stewards' movement. The great majority of the militants were sacked; the stewards' moverhent was crushed.

Up to 1925, railworkers had freely moved coal during every miners' strike, The general level of unionisation throughout the working class was only half of what it is today. The right wing had just consolidated its hold on the Labour Party, decisively excluding the Communists.

And yet the general strike happened, and was still growing on the day that the TUC leaders sold it out.

Jackie McDonough could still reply that a general strike depends on initiative from the TUC leaders. They won't take that initiative: and so whatever the generalities, the call for a general strike is empty words.

There is the other pessibility, of a general strike spontaneously exploding. from below, as in France in 1968 But in any caserthe behaviour • of the TUC leaders is not so •cut-and-dried.. After wtheir *spectacular sell-out of the * NGA at thew end of 1983 - who would have thought that they would call a 'day of action' over GCHQ in February 1984. Yet they did At present there is very little pressure from below or the TUC leaders to take ar initiative. So they don't. But the question for us whether we become part or that problem, or part of the solution to it Even if all our argument

Scan page 7

Civil Civil Civil ILS hts gits CCR Tor Tor Civ iervan ery Having beaten the heroic nd prolonged; strike-brea up the miners. But is a ceivable?

I for a general strike for a general strike should fail Civ

----- pull-quotes -----

the information doesn't filter Brenda Proctor, a miner's

essa on?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 213

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →