Left Press Unrealistic?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
to produce action, they will still have fulfilled a purpose: to convince a minority of militants about the potential power and strength of our class, and how it could be used, and thus to make sure that there is more pressure from below on the TUC leaders next time.
If we content ourselves Civ with proposing only such action as the militant rank and file can carry out within the limits of the TUC leaders' lack of initiative, then we will never even begin to challenge GCHO and replace those leaders. We need to propose a policy for the whole labour movement.
It does not follow that we call for a general strike all the time, or for an immediate socialist revolution now.
Leon Trotsky formulated a good rule: "to base one's programme on the logic of the class struggle".
Leon Trotsky® Because of the watershea of the class struggle" specifically now. It is the logical assessment that we = and thousands of others - make of the miners' strike.
That is why we can rationally hope that what is today a minority slogan could CONO within a relatively short time become a mass call to action; and why we have a duty to "blaze a trail' for it as a minority slogan today ban (Below). GCHO MOST of the revolutionary left does not call for a general strike.
Socialist Worker carried a major editorial on January 12 with their proposals for the miners' strike. Quite rightly they stressed the need to relaunch mass picketing, especially at the power stations. But not once in the editorial did they mention industrial action by other workers.
It is not just a matter of that one editorial: for example, SW's advertisement for the TUC lobby on January 23 called by the Broad Left Organising Committee mentions only the slogans, "Stop the power stations! Implement Congress policy!" and omits BLOC's appeal for a 24 hour general strike to "link every struggle with the miners"
Socialist Action summarised their view of "the four key steps to winning the dispute" on January 18. Curiously they omit all which leaves their our steps somewhat up in the air. But in any case the most radical of those "four steps" is "a national day of industrial action in support of the miners"
When trade union leaders call "days of action". , the lett usually criticises them for being mealy-mouthed and demands the more clear-cut formula of a "24 hour general strike". But Socialist Action makes a "day of action" its own proposal. • And it proposes that day's action not as preparation for a full mobilisation, but as the sufficient climax of "steps to winning the dispute" • Such an approach blatantly contradicts what SA - like Socialist Organiser - has been saying about the high stakes in the miners' strike. If the stakes are that high, a one-day strike will certainly not be sufficent to rout the Tories.
Neither SW nor SA spell out why they don't call for a general strike. Probably they would say that this call is "unrealistic" and add that there is a danger of slogans about improbable general strikes substituting for more limited but concrete action.
It is indeed possible for the call for a general strike to become phrasemongering. If the editors of Socialist Action look through the files of its predecessor Red Weekly for 1973-4, they will find a good example.
But the decisive argument against SW and SA comes from what they themselves say about the pivotal nature of the miners' strike for the whole labour movement. Unless the labour movement is absolutely shattered and broken - which it isn't — then it should respond with a full mobilisation.
In 1938 Leon Trotsky had a discussion with some US co-thinkers about the slogan of workers' defence groups against fascism, which they thought unrealistic.
He replied: "Naturally if I close my eyes 1 can write a good rosy programme that everybody will accept. But it will not correspond to the situation... We must tell the workers the truth, then we will win the best elements...
*The mentality of the working class is backward, but the mentality is not such a substance as the factories, the mines, the railroads. It is more mobile and under the blows of the objective crisis, the millions of unemployed, it can change rapidly.
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser no. 213. January 23 1985 Page 8 dward Ellis reviews Improper Conduct, a film by Imendros and Orlando Jiminez Leal (Spanish and ith English subtitles) ICA Cinema, London.
HE American 'Militant', which — nominally at least — is associad with 'Socialist Action' in Britain, said of this film that it was designed to promote the imperialist war drive against Cuba". . It is, ey say, "a counter-revolutionary propaganda tract."
The film consists of a series of interviews with Cuban exiles and an terview with American writer Susan Sontag. It is intended to be a (Left) police prepare to charge at pickets. Photo, John Harris. (Right) victims of police violence in Northern Ireland. Photo: I.D.Swindale.
istering attack on the Cuban regime's treatment of intellectuals, Violenc and hypocrisy tists and - most notoriously - homosexuals.
Some of the personal stories are poignant. A young gay man desibes his many arrests in Cuba before he finally managed to emiate. An ex-prisoner recalls how a 12-year old boy was thrown into 1, raped, classified as homosexual: he cried for his mother all day _essons Jean-Paul Sartre is quoted as having said: "In Cuba there are no ws but there are homosexuals". And this sums up the message of' e film - that lesbians and gay men suffer the brunt of oppression Cuba; and - in many respects a more dominant theme of the film that the charge of homosexual is a stigma to be used against all Many people have started to question the British presence in Ireland since the miners' strike began. The hypocrisy of the Although the film has generally been treated as a 'gay film', it is press about violence on picket lines has called into question fact an indictment of Castro's Cuba altogether - it sees the ban Revolution as having betrayed its promise, and Castro as Patrick Murphy looks at the issues of democracy and Consequently, it has proved extremely controversial. Many violence in Northern Ireland and draws out some lessons for luding the Cuban Communist Party itself - have denounced the Victims speak of their time in 'UMAP' camps — little better than centration camps, where many gay people were sent in the 1960s. ese no longer exist; and the film's critics object to its claim that An ex-courier describes the absurd deception practiced by official rs of Cuba. The film's critics protest that any visit to the country It is certainly true that some of the claims made do seem a little probable. The idea that Raul Castro would need detailed advice m the Bulgarian Communist Party on how to set up camps for mosexuals, is silly, for example: if the Cuban authorities are that 1, presumably they could work it out by themselves.
But the argument that the film is "designed to promote the perialist war drive" is far more unconvincing than even the Some of those interviewed are bourgeois exiles, for whom it is ficult to feel much sympathy: Others are not. Ex-leading artistic ures, writers, journalists, who had supported — indeed been part - the Revolution, speak out. What about them? Why should they A young woman intellectual, whose aim had been to radicalise the volution (which she regarded as 'petty bourgeois'), not turn ainst it, speaks of her shock at discovering the extent of hidden rsecution. She was arrested for associating with "individualists' One young exile in the US makes a telling point: "We [the exiles] = all supposed to be delinquents. If we are — who made us delinEqually telling is a scene of a huge Congress — a unanimous vote And even the film's fiercest critics, like the American 'Militant, nnot deny that lesbians and gay men do suffer oppression and rsecution in Cuba. The most that they can claim is that it's a But it is a fact that homosexuality is illegal in Cuba. And whether ings are better than in the 1960s or not, the persecution gay people ce is still notorious. There can be no doubt that a large part of this Clearly, the makers of the film do not consider themselves 'friendly itics' of Castro's Cuba. They are extremely hostile.
But why "pro-imperialists" should choose to hang their attack on luba around a defence of oppressed gays is a mystery There is nothing in this film to suggest that Cuba was better efore the Revolution, that other countries are better or anything like nat. Its message is simply that the Cuban Revolution has gone off 1e rails. Those who have heaped abuse on the film in the name of defending the revolution' are like the friends of the USSR' in the 930s, who denied the existence of repression and joined the Stalinits to accuse those who told the truth of being 'counter-revolutionarThey are equally sycophantic and pathetic. Like Stalin's apologists hey prove to be very bad friends of the Cuban Revolution, and he nennle who suffer under Stalinist tvranny. To tell the truth is a Nestor the next cell.
THE distortion, hypocrisy and isidents. straightforward lies published by all the papers and reproduced daily on TV during the miners' strike have been well ving sold Cuba into a new slavery prepared for over the last 16 years in Ireland.
In the six occupied counties n as consisting simply of lies. of the north-east of Ireland, a Camps vicious and bloodthirsty police force has been portrayed as the protector of law and order, and Catholic victims of Republican violence have been used by the ilar places continue under a new name. media to justify British rule which has callously murdered and systematically intimidated uld disprove his claims. And so on. many more Catholic victims.
Paisley While the more extreme Loyalist leaders, like lan Paisley and George Seawright (who called for Catholics to be incindest assertions made in the film. erated!) are either playfully ridiculed or ignored, the protected bigotry of their supporters is used as the clinching argument against all those who be liars? suggest any progressive changes in Ireland.
At a time when the Tories, their media and right wing Labour politicians use the catchphrases of democracy, the rule of law, non-violence and justice ents? Cuban society made us deliquents. against the miners, Northern Ireland gives us a measure of :; no abstentions; no votes against. how serious they are about these principles.
Undemocratic gacy of capitalism.
The state of Northern Ireland is a more undemocratic. unit than any trade union. It is a more uneconomic, subsidised m deals with the truth.
pit than any British coal mine.
And it has been willing to dispense with British legal norms Pro-imperialist? long before the most militant labour leader.
But those who have tried to bring attention to this have been beaten off the streets, first by Northern Ireland's B Specials in 1968 and ever since by the RUC and the British Army.
Those who protest about the blatant discrimination in the legal system, the non-Jury 's' and 'fascists'.
courts and the endless periods on remand, often find themselves called up before the same Loyalist judges to face the same revolutionary act. trumped-up charges after the same painful experience on remand. If the miners are now experiencing *supermarket justice" which will be used against all trade unionists in the future, it's about time we ! began to impose sanctions on the parent company and supplier of this supermarket, Obviously Northern Ireland is an uneconomic unit which the Tory government supports. 'Mrs Thatcher is especially keen to state her personal commitment to the most undemocratic union of all, the union between Britain and Northern Ireland.
Castro The British Army, the Ulster Irish what they say about everything else.
Defence Regiment and the RUC are deployed at fantastic expense to ensure the continuing life of this particular uneconomic pit.
Those who argue that this state is unviable and uneconomic are branded as supporters of terrorism. The Republican movement claims that all of Ireland's people have the right to determine their own future.
This government and previous Tory and Labour governments in Britain have denied that right.
As a matter of fact, successive British governments have been acting in total contempt of a national ballot held in 1918. The last national ballot permitted in Ireland returned a massive majority of candidates, 78%, committed to the independence of Ireland from Britain. Two years later, the British Liberal government led by Lloyd George ignored that ballot and partitioned Ireland, creating a Catholic state in the south and a Loyalist Orange siege state in the north-east.
Why? Home Rule had had overwhelming electoral support in Ireland - and a sympathetic Liberal government in Britain. The Liberal government had even put a Home Rule Bill through Westminster in 1914all entirely legal, parliamentary and constitutional.
Violence
But the Liberals retreated in the face of threats of violence from Loyalists in Ulster, supported by influential sections of the Tory Party. Andrew Bonar Law, then leader of the Tory party, summed up their attitude when he threatened the Liberal and Nationalist Home Rulers, saying: "There are things stronger than Parliamentary majorities"
He encouraged Ulster Loyalists to take up arms. The Tories also applauded a mutiny by British Army officers in Ireland when those officers told the government they would not enforce Home Rule.
A national ballot overruled by the intimidation of a small minority supported by political extremists? As Mrs Thatcher so eloquently put it, it just isn't British. And I suppose she's right, it isn't British.
Colonialist
It's partly American, partly French, Portuguese, Spanish and partly British. It's imperialist, it's colonialist, it's good old-fashioned class warfare and the subjugation of small nations by the "bully-boy" tactics of the anarchy that is capitalism, but we will not be defeated simply because our enemies have violent forces at their disposal.
Finally, we must never be the accomplices of our own violent, undemocratic rulers when they want to use their violence against other members of our powerful capitalist states. class.
Those who defend capitalism We can never support or even defend a system which inevit- tolerate the wars fought by the ably produces and even encourruling class, employers and their ages violence against and generals. We happen to live in , among the poor and the working the same country as them, but class. If this violence is used to we have infinitely. less in fight wars against the poor and common with our 'own' ruling working class of other countries, class than we have with the it is 'patriotic'. workers of other countries.
If it is used amongst our- Today the Irish republican selves, at football matches, movement is trying to force against old people, in the home, democracy on an unwilling it is a scandal for the press to be British administration. The indignant about (and seek majority of the Irish people are scapegoats for), but nothing is trying to enforce the results of done to tackle its causes. their 'national ballot' and free And if working class violence themselves of British rule. is organised and used against Their methods are not always the state and for our own what ours would be, and certaindefence, then it is "just not ly the conditions in which they British" and it is ruthlessly and operate are much worse. Their efficiently crushed. politics are nationalist, but not nearly so narrowly nationalist and patriotic as the loyal British What do socialists say? We labour movement.
We canot proceed by trying are against violence. We are fighting to build a society where to establish exactly what kind of Ireland is being fought for or is the brutality and violence most likely - a capitalist or engendered by competition, socialist Ireland - and decide poverty and ignorance have whether to support them on that disappeared. We hope to turn basis. What those people who the violence of capitalist society fight against partition and against its creators, and by against British rule in the Six doing so we hope to end it.
Counties of Northern Ireland by No-one who has lived through whatever means want, is the the miners' strike or witnessed the last 20 years in Northern right of the Irish people as a whole decide their own Ireland can believe that Neil Kinnock is really opposed to all future.
So when the battle is between violence *without fear or the army and government of favour". Such hypocrites who invent their "principles" day to desperate working class of the day to fit their main purpose, Catholic ghettoes in Northern which is to preserve their own Ireland we wholly and unashampower. edly stand with the Catholic As socialists our attitude to community. violence, law, repression and democracy has to suit our main There is nothing whatever undemocratic, unprincipled, interest, which is to liberate our "terrorist" or extremist about class from the suffocating, corrupting life that is all we are supporting the republican moveallewed to live under capitalism. ment.
Forget the hypocritical rant That means that we live by Kings of "concerned" politicians our own values, we live by our and remember instead our own own laws. For us, democracy is experiences of the media's a principle, but real democracy, representative, informed biased reporting, of the police "keeping the peace', the judges democracy. enforcing the law with iustice.
Our democracy always and the feeling of anger and includes discussion and argumilitancy that grows in comment, our representatives are munities constantly under elected as often as possible, are brought to account, are sub- attack.
Then decide, independently, ject to recall and live the lives whether it is outrageous and of their communities.
extreme for working class We, as socialists, wish to people to fight back for their avoid violence and repression.
But we will defend ourselves. own survival.
We will use whatever means necessary to defend our right to BLOODY SUNDAY organise, to speak, to withdraw commemoration our labour and to decide our Sunday February 3. Assemble future. 12 noon at Spinney Hill We do not rely on violence, Park, Leicester. March to like the state and the Leicester Prison.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser no. 213. January 23 1985 Page 9
----- pull-quotes -----
character of the miners' strike, the call for a general strike follows from the "logic
next step. It follows from the Andrew Moore