Two books on the NUM Blind to rank and file
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
John Douglas reviews 'Scargill and the Miners' by Michael Crick and The Politics of the 'Scargill and the Miners' is a bit of a yarn with just enough of a plot to stop it becoming a yawn. Crick works for ITN/Channel 4, and it shows.
The book reads like a telescript. Facts are quoted. like confetti but there isn't much. analysis. What little there is, is derived from Scargill - interviews, speeches and writings — and from academic books like The Politics of the Yorkshire Miners by Andrew Taylor which read like a Ph D thesis.
Taylor made a detailed analysis culled from the official records of the Yorkshire NUM and Crick follows him closely, reproducing even some of Taylor's own words.
Although it starts with the Labour government of 1945, neither Taylor nor Crick analyses the famous Grimethorpe strike of 1940. It was then that the flying picket was first used.
They don't tell us about the strikes of 1955 and the early "60s either. Perhaps they were deemed to be not political? A more important limitation in Taylor's book is his failure to analyse the Barnsley Miners' Forum or what Crick calls the Yorkshire Left. Indeed he only mentions it once.
Forum Centring on Arthur Scargill's role in the Barnsley Miners' Forum, Crick's exposure journalism does in a sensational way what Andrew Taylor failed to do in recording this important aspect of recent working class Crick deals with the role of Scargill in the manner of a drama-documentary. For example:
*Inside the hall, the miners of Woolley Colliery were gathering for their monthly meeting... Outside an eighteen year old apprentice was arguing with the men on the door who seemed determined not to let him in. At last that night, the young man gave up arguing and went home in anger, determined he would get his way - eventually"
The above was gleaned by Crick from an interview in New Left Review given by Arthur Scargill in 1975. Crick dramatises it to give his yarn a plot.
Taylor gives a similar example of the machinations of the right wing in Yorkshire. An Area Compensation Agent had to face an inquiry because he attended a Daily Worker sponsored conference - so it is understandable that the Left had to keep its head down.
But the Left in Yorkshire won the leadership at least ten years ago, and only now has "all been revealed" to Crick, by participants who range from the current Mayor of Barnsley to the Yorkshire Communist Party organiser of the '50s and "6üs.
Crick makes the ritual comparison between AJ Cook and Arthur Scargill Arthur Scargill, but he does not refer to the Minority Movement of the '20s in which AJ Cook as general secretarv of the Miners' Federation of Great Britain was involved.
The Minority Movement was a united front of Labour Lefts and the young Communist Party which had a revolutionary programme that included the nationalisation of the coal industry under workers' control.
Workers' control
Scargill is, as Crick notes, very hostile to the demand for workers' control, seeing it as a form of participation, akin to worker directors on the board of workers Steel. The question of British workers capitalist demand is therefore not discussed.
In fact, the involvement of Trotskyists in the Yorkshire NUM and the NUM nationally is ignored by both books Crick does mention the efforts of one-time Socialist Organiser supporter and Dinnington miner John Cunningham, to raise within the NUM the fate of the Ukrainian miner Klebanov who attempted to set up an Independent Miners' Union in the Soviet Union. He shows that Scargill has been a bit ambiguous on such questions.
Both books show too that the Yorkshire NUM under his leadership has a sterling record in supporting strikes (Grunwicks, British Steel and the Health Service) and single issue campaigns (CND, the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy).
Yet even under Scargill's leadership pits closed in Yorkshire. Deals were made, of course — Selby is an example of that. But neither Crick nor Taylor consider the implications of the new technology. This question - dealt with consistently by Socialist Organiser — has been dropped during the strike and the most recent negotiations by Scargill. Therefore NUM militants should argue for an open, democratic Broad Left in the NUM, particularly in Yorks.
Crick concentrates on the undoubted qualities of leadership in Arthur Scargill but nowhere considers the qualities of the rank and file miners themselves, nor the women organising against pit closures. They are mentioned only in passing as a stage army, holding spears, while 'the King' plans his campaigns.
Crick thereby presents a typical capitalist view of trade unions and their leaders. Both writers admit to the paradox of the Yorks NUM in the '50s and '60s - a militant rank and file and a right wing leadership — not all that unusual.
Then came the strikes of 1972 and 1974, but as Taylor notes, "On average, over the last the years, 58% of recruits were new to the industry. This percentage is all the more important when we remember that in the last ten years the total workforce has fallen by 50,000 (18%)...
They weren't expected to strike, especially after three ballots in which they voted against action over wages.
Failing But the rank and file rallied to defend their union and the NCB were building up towards a major attack on the NUM. a fact the two authors are unable to appreciate.
Here is the basic failing of both these books.
However, as part of the fight against the Tories, make sure your library orders copies of them - though the Taylor book alone might put a penny on me rates...
Psst. Anyone want to buy a secondhand book?
----- pull-quotes -----
Yorkshire Miners' by Andrew Taylor