Fear and hatred in New York
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-01-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
ON DECEMBER 22 Bernhard Goetz gunned down four black youths in the New York underground.
Since then he has become a sort of folk hero. He will appear in court, but the charges against him have been reduced from attempted murder to illegal possession of a firearm.
The New York underground is notorious for crime and violence - many people are too scared ever to use it - and the four youths had demanded money from Goetz. Goetz, it seems, is a fanatical racist and law-and-order man. He kept on shooting until his gun was empty, and one of the youths will be paralysed for life.
Racists
-Racists, of course, have applauded Goetz. By all accounts so have many New York blacks. The 'Guardian Angels', a right-wing vigilante group which patrols the underground and which has applauded Getz, has recruited many blacks and Puerto Ricans.
US blacks do not have to look very far back into history to have horrific memories of the time when people like Goetz ruled in the Southern States, and black people supposed to have committed crimes would be lynched by racist mobs. Yet revulsion and fear at the state of US city streets is more powerful than such memories.
In Detroit more people die violently in a single year than have been killed in the whole 15 years of simmering war in Northern Ireland. New York is little better. The police, more interested in guarding the property of the rich few than the lives of the poor many, give no protection. Especially not to working class people, and most especially not to working class blacks.
So when Goetz fired his gun, many black and working class people in New York applauded the act of self-defence - even if it was done by a racist.
Britain's cities are not quite at the same stage of decay yet. But you can see it coming.
Police forces are a modern invention - only about 150 years old in Britain. Instrument of class rule though they are, in one way they were a progressive development - replacing naked violence and personal power by more-or-less impersonal, objective rules and mechanisms for social regulation.
What happens when the decay of capitalism corrupts those mechanisms? We can argue for reforms in police methods, accountability and so on, but isn't that erecting walls of paper against chaos? What else? More police powers? Vigilante law?
In France the issue has been taken up by a right-wing group called 'Legitimate Defence' -and shootings of North African youths are becoming more and more frequent. In Brazil it is an everyday event for petty thieves to be beaten to death in the Self-defence The answer is in a new society based on solidarity and cooperation rather than the rat-race and the rip-off. Labour movement/ community patrols - organised forces, but based among the local people rather than standing above them like the capitalist police - would ensure law and order' in such a society, and can be developed in particular areas even now.
Right now, everyone should be taught to defend themselves - and to defend themselves where possible without killing or maiming.
People need defence* -against petty criminals, against trigger-happy Goetzes, and often (as mining communities have found out during 1984) against the police too.
And no-one is going to provide defence for working-class communities except themselves. theirs.
Many long-term unemployed now permanently claiming social security have less bare essentials, have experienced homelessness and hardship for years, with no family support - you met these people when you came to London.
You talked to black people suffering constant abuse and danger from racist attacks and racist police. You identified the miners' treatment at the hands of the police with all trade unionists and black people. You even said at the time how difficult it was to take money from such people who were obviously so much more oppressed, poor and with less hope for the future than yoursell.
What have you done for them, Reg? Kicked them in the teeth!
What is worse is that in going to the Daily Express you have added further propaganda for the bosses' side.
Next year you'll be going for a deputy's job, perhaps a job in management? Scabs like you can go far. They're like gold dust for controlling and persuading other men and demoralising trade union organisation.
You used to talk about the heroism of the Polish workers in solidarnosc. especially the Polish miners. Three years ago in Poland the Solidarity miners in Katowice were shot down when they occupied their pit in the struggle for a free democratic trade union: So much for Susan Carlyle Back in June, when thousands marched for the miners you were amazed by the support -especially from white-collar workers. You were part of building that solidarity.
But don't worry. One scab running to a newspaper won't destroy the support there is in London for the miners. The entire labour movement and the whole working class owes the miners a debt we can never repay.
But no-one round here who used to know you and respected you as a militant and fighter will want to know you now - Reg Moss, a scab, a defeated man who pulls tricks with national newspapers. Your integrity and reputation as a union activist is shattered.
Individuals come and go in the struggle, but the tight goes on. because working people have no alternative — the working class which has little to lose, but a world to gain. We are sorry. Reg. that you are no longer fighting alongside us, that you have crept off. leaving the striking miners of Kiveton Park in the lurch.
We in East London will continue to do our best not to leave the striking miners in the lurch.