Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Scots teachers: a flat rate rise!

Socialist Organiser no. 214, 30 January 1985 · scan p. 11 · about 420 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

IN Socialist Organiser no. 210 lan McCalman criticises me (and Lothian Rank and File) at length for counterposing a straight cash pay claim to the official call for an independent pay review' which he, with the Glasgow Campaign for a Fighting Union (CAFU) supports.

I do not intend to reply to everything he says because the context of the debate has now changed somewhat.

But Ian accuses me of being "guilty of a certain naivety" in my contention that an 'independent pay review would probably offer a trade-off of conditions for money.

"Management try to link the two issues under some sort of 'producitivty deals' at any time, irrespective of pay reviews". , he says.

But then in the next sentence he admits that "There are added dangers of such an approach with the pay review tactics, and that to counteract this CAFU moved a 'no trade-off motion at the EIS AGM which was defeated (albeit by only 30 votes).

Ian defends the pay review call as a tactic around which we could mobilise at the end of last year, rather than waiting for the annual pay claim in February of this. Yet surely, if the membership accepted, as they did, that they needed a substantial rise as a catching-up exercise, that should have been our demand and our focus for Callum Macrae continu a debate over strategy action there and then.

Why substitute instead call for a pay review?

I said in my letter In 208 that "in calling fo pay review instead of straight claim, the E right wing leadership cle sow illusions in the ability such bodies to serve the in ests of teachers, or any wo ers for that matter." An stick by that.

I said earlier that situation has now chang While still sticking by demand for a pay rev body, CAFU have a demanded an interim claim 15 per cent for this y albeit with the proviso t there be a weighting towa "the upper end of" the promoted salary scale.

I welcome the decision go for an interim claim : the call for intensified unp action, but I am very appointed, and I trust lat too, that they have gone a percentage rather than f rate claim.

I believe that they deci on the 'weighted' percent formulation because it already union policy - bu they are calling for a co in union policy to go fo interim claim at all, why also call for that claim to distributed in a princ manner?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 214

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →