Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Bad news or workers

Socialist Organiser no. 215, 6 February 1985 · scan p. 2 · about 746 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

'Bad news for Britain is bad news for all". So said Neil Kinnock last week, Thursday January 31, in a miserable flop of a censure of the Kinnock's speech was a flop, but not only because Tory backbenchers drowned him out. He made a mess of it anyway.

Kinnock fluffed it because what was required of him was that he boldly spell out an alternative to Thatcherism — a convincing alternative, rooted in the realities of the situtation Britain is in — and Neil Kinnock doesn't have an alternative to Thatcher.

Neil Kinnock came across as someone who can criticise the frills (and even Ted Heath or a near-senile Harold McMillan can do that)

Kinnock and his co-thinkers in the leadership of the Labour Party can't get to the heart of the matter. And the reason he can't is contained in that little give-away phrase: "Bad news for Britain is bad Kinnock and the Labour Party leaders look at 'the country' and 'the economy' as a happy family — or one that could be happy with better management. Bosses and workers all do their jobs, and so long as no-one oversteps the mark, everything will be fine.

Right now, things are not altogether fair; and 'monetarism' -the Tory's economic philosophy — is a bad thing.

But juggle about with public expenditure, interest rates and the balance of payments, and all your problems will go away.

The Thatcherite Tories look at things differently. Society, for the Thatcherites, is divided into classes. If the bosses are to restore profits, and nudge themselves out of the recession, they must take on Thatcher is right — although she and her party act more by good class instinct than from worked-out theory. In fact their theory also But unlike Thatcher, Kinnock accepts the theory and lacks even the faintest flicker of class instincts. Kinnock can't see that 'Britain' is not one big happy family, but a society — like any other capitalist The capitalist crisis cannot be resolved in the interests of 'the nation'. Either the bosses resolve it in their own interests — by beating down the working class, and, right now, the miners in the first instance; or the working class destroys the whole crisis-ridden The difference between two world-views, two different bases for organising economic life is at the centre of the miners' strike.

The call for pit closures on 'economic grounds' expresses the very basic guiding force of the capitalist economy: that people's needs are subordinate to economics — that is, in the final analysis, profit.

From the point of view of 'the national economy' , the NCB and the Tories — and now, of course, Kinnock - are right. Keeping pits open is 'bad news for Britain' 'We' can't afford it.

The aim of the strike — that the needs of people in their communities take priority over such considerations — expresses the basic principle of working class socialism. It is working class "economics"

Kinnock cannot understand that. He doesn't knowwhat is wrong with capitalism; so he can't offer a remedy. Socialism for Kinnock is something you occasionally talk about, not something realisable which must be fought for as the working class answer to the crisis of The remedy is for the working class as a whole to follow the example of the miners: to refuse to accept the logic of the profit system. Every time the bosses or their governments try to make the working class suffer for the crisis, they should be fought. Instead we must impose our logic — the logic of a system based on rational But Kinnock's non-solution is not just the stuff that flops are made out of. It is poison to the working class movement.

The miners' strike has been a tremendous example of the international solidarity of the working class. In fact, solidarity from foreign workers has been, if anything, better than from other British The best allies of the British working class are other workers. have no common interests with British or any other bosses. It is 'Britain against the rest of the world' — it is class against class. but not supply an alternative.

news for all" and defeat the working class.

says that 'the economy' is a big family.

country — torn apart by class conflict. British capitalism.

planning to meet people's needs.

workers. Tories over their handling of the economy. system and reorganises society completely. versus the economics of the ruling class.

Poison

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 215

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →