Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Miners' Video

Socialist Organiser no. 215, 6 February 1985 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,809 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

URGENT APPEAL TO ALL MINERS SUPPORT GROUPS The Mineworkers Defence Committee Video Group was formed after the Mineworkers Defence Committee's December 2 conference. We aim to assist in the solidarity work and campaign for an NUM victory.

We are producing a newsreel video for immediate distribution to striking NUM members. Like all of us, the mining communities are forced to rely for much of the news about the strike on the Tory press. The government is using the media in their present campaign to create a false impression of isolation and despair in the miners. We want to show them the real extent and diversity they have among trade unionists, women's support groups, local support groups, Black delegation groups.

We are gathering together and editing a 40-50 minute tape of amateur and professional film, video and photo material from all areas where solidarity and support activities are coming. *Existing video (preferably) or film material about solidarity *Photos, leaflets, posters, etc., as a record of support in your area. *Off-air recordings of TV news items about support for miners, powe cuts, the effect of the strike on the pound, etc. (We don't expect mu If you have anything (however slight or "poor quality'), please contact us immediately. All material must reach us. by the latest on lesbian and gay groups, internationally, etc.

WHAT WE NEED URGENTLY:

and activities.

here, but sometimes something slips out...). *Material on international solidarity.

Friday February 22.

Itsper With thanks, in solidarity DAVE TURNER. for the MDC Video Group

Scan page 6

on the Glasgow general strike of In addition to using the army, the police and scab organisations, the government was also prepared to introduce a whole new battery of legal restrictions on basic trade union activities and rights. Although never actually carried out, because the strike ended before this was possible, they illustrate the lengths to which the government was prepared to go:

*Striking railway workers were to be conscripted into the ärmy and then ordered to keep the trains running.

*General mobilisation and demobilisation of the labour battalions was to cease during the strike.

*Legal sanction would be given to industrial agreements and criminal proceedings begun if the unions did not keep to them.

*All strikes "endangering the public interest (i.e. effective ones) would be "dealt with" under the Defence of the Realm Act (i.e. banned).

*Union funds would be seized if used to finance such strikes, and union officials involved in them arrested.

Apart from preparing new laws the government also used the existing ones to carry out a decision made at the war cabinet meeting of January 31: arrest the strike leaders to weaken the strike movement.

The next day Gallacher and Kirkwood were arrested while trying to stop the fighting in George Square, and in the following days the rioting was used as an excuse to pick up other leaders including Shinwell, Ebury (national secretary of the Marxist British Socialist Party) and Hopkins (Glasgow secretary of the Amalgamated Society of Engineers)..

Thus while certain laws were used to pick up the strike leaders, the same laws were ignored when broken by the scabs and the police themselves; and when existing laws looked like being inadequate to deal with the strike, the government rushed to put new ones on the statute book. As the strike showed, there is nothing neutral about the legal system; it is a weapon in the hands of the ruling class.

Press

classes classes press, too, joined in the ruling general strike, and presented a totally false picture. Workplaces and union branches voting to join in the strike were ignored, while news about the Patriotic Workers League and individual workplaces that had voted not to come out got the front pages. Especially towards the end of the strike, reports appeared about various factories having gone back when in fact they were still on strike.

Often the reporting was just plain hysterical. The Glasgow Herald put the strike down to "the clap-trap nonsense of Trotsky" and "the studious inculcation of the temper of revolt" and described its leaders as "a gang of political revolutionaries who have contrived to exploit: the industrial: weariness of Scottish workers...notorious rebels against the social order"

Stan Crooke concludes ''Terrorism on the Clyde" proclaimed one headline in the Scotsman, and "Glasonw Rolshevism: disgraceful scenes" proclaimed another in the Evening News, over an article which claimed that the troops had been sent in to protect "life and property" from ''the rabble".

Even detective stories were used as agitation against the strike movement. The Weekly Record published a detective serial about the "famous detective and crime investigator" Derek Clyde, who bumps off a jew called Finkelstein (who of course isn't a Jew called Finkelstein at all but a Bolshevist agent called Vladimir Tolstoi) and impersonates his contact man Lucas in order to track down the other five Bolshevist agents who, under the leadership of the tanatically they naa. Police truncheon striker, 'Black Friday' 1919.

This series mad medical doctor tron Petrograd hiding in Newcastle, are ehind all ti unrest.

The police, troops, new legisiation, a press witch-hunt - these and other similar tactics were used by the government and the employers to smash the strike movement. The action taken by the ruling class during the strike, and the measures in the pipeline when the strike was finishing, amounted to total military suppression combined with the outlawing of free trade unionism. Far from meekly giving in when confronted with the strength of the strike movement, they fought back with everything 11. - 1_ The strike ended officially on February 11, sixteen days after it had begun. The Strike Bulletin did the best it could to put a brave face on it. "The strike is suspended until we reinforce our ranks. We have retreated in good order without any intention of submitting to the abject terms our exploiters wish to impose on us...the knowledge we have gained will not be wasted. Be ready!"

But it was making a virtue out of necessity: in the days leading up to the 11th, there had been a gradual return to work, although hardly the avalanche portrayed by the press, and the only alternative to instructing a return-towork would have been to leave the most militant workers isolated and therefore an easy prey to victimisation.

The press had a straightforward explanation for the failure of the strike: it had never had any support to begin with in Glasgow; there had been a lack of support outside Glasgow as well; the government's firm stand had convinced the strikers they were not going to win; and the whole thing was totally unBritish: the strike was "a symptom of incipient revolutionary tendencies wholly foreign to the good sense and the political and social beliefs of the The talk about the "un-British" nature of the strike was superstitious nonsense; the claims about the lack of support in Glasgow were only a continuation of the propaganda pushed by the press throughout the strike; and a resolute strike leadership would have answered the government's counter-offensive by escalating the struggle into a direct confrontation for power.

But did the strike movement possess such a leadership? And, more generally, were the leaders of the British labour movement outside of Glasgow prepared to lead a fight for such high stakes? No: and that was the real reason for the strike's failure to achieve the 40 hour week, never mind the overthrow of capitalism.

Fear

Many of the local leaders went in fear of the massive social upheavals unleashed by the general strike, and did everything in their power to prevent the strike being pushed forward to its logical conclusion. Left-talking demagogues, their practice put them in the camp of David Kirkwood was a typical example. Before and during the war he had built up a reputation for himselt as a left-winger, and in his speeches to the mass meetings in the strike he would declare himself a revolutionary socialist. But in the same breath he would say that the strike was not a revolutionary situation, so everyone should be sensible and concentrate on no more than trying to get a shorter working week!

The plea made by his lawyer at the trial for his alleged crimes on Bloody Friday sums Kirkwood up. With •a tremor in his voice and a sweep of the hand, the lawyer cried out: "Look at him, he's a Christian. 1uN has i Thrictian. His dear old mother who sits at home waiting for him is a Christian. You cannot send a man like this to prison."

The role of Emmanuel Shinwell, ethe chairperson of Glasgow Trades Counci (and now a Lord), was a lot worse He had the same myopic view of the strike as Kirkwood: 'There was no clas: war, no plans for revolution — simply : wish to make life in Britain a sembland of the Land Fit For Heroes so glibly promised by Lloyd George."

Shinwell excelled in doing deal behind the strikers' backs. It was Shin well who was responsible for getting full time officials onto the Joint Committer set up at the January 18 meeting, ans for doing a private deal with the Lorr Provost whereby the latter would appea for government intervention, whils Shinwell would dampen down the strik movement until the Lord Provost got i reply.

Union officials, both locally an nationally, fell over themselves tr prevent workers from striking and to ge those on strike back to work. Thi applied in particular to the miner officials: in Cambuslang they made a appeal for police protection — for scab! In Lanarkshire they opposed the strik until an occupation of their offices b their members forced them to bac down.

In East Fife they tried the routine ‹ holding a ballot before deciding o whether or not to support the strike. An the members of the Scottish Miner Executive publicly denounced the strike -But the national leadership of th unions played the crucial role in th strike's failure. Instead of campaignin for suppor for the strike and spreadin it, they ordered their members to stay: work and refused strike pay to those o strike, save in the rare cases when the gave in to the membership and paida strike benefit.

The most scandalous role of all wa played by the executive of the AS which even went so far as to suspe! Harry Hopkins, the Glasgow distri secretary and the whole of the distri committee, for supporting the strike. was a green light to the police: two da after the suspension of the strike thi arrested Hopkins and threw him in prison: *The final edition of the Strike Bullet

----- pull-quotes -----

1919 by drawing out the of the strike for us today.

«We were carrying on strike when we ought to have been making a revolution." Willie Gallaghe

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 215

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →