Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Glasgow strike bulletin

Socialist Organiser no. 215, 6 February 1985 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,691 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Subscribe!

Please send me .. ..months' sub. I enclose f .... To: Socialist Organiser, 214 Sickert Court, London summed up the anger felt by the strikers at the betrayals of their union executives: "Don't forget the executives who failed us in the fight! Those elected servants of ours who have become our bosses are not too favourable to the 40 hours' movement. If we don't put our executives in order we will get nowhere, as every time we make an effort to gain an improvement in our conditions they generally assist big business to keep us from winning."

And the Labour MPs? Did they use Parliament as a tribune to denounce and disrupt the government's efforts to break the strike or to campaign for support for the strike movement?

This was how the Glasgow Herald reported from Westminster on the day following the end of the strike:

"The debate was conducted in admirable temper and left the impression that it must be productive of much good in favourably influencing the atmosphere on both sides in the industrial world" The Labour MPs condemned the use of "unconstitutional methods" by workers to achieve their demands, and stressed that the use of strike action must always be subordinate to the "welfare of the state". . Bonar Law, an arch-Tory, commended their attitude.

Kirkwood and Shinwell, the union executives, and the Parliamentary Labour Party all lived in fear of the power of or class which was thrown up by the general strike. They used their positions in the local leadership of the strike and in the national leadership of the labour movement to weaken and betray the, genetal strike, instead of organising to defeat the ruling classes' counter-offetisive.

It would, however, be a crude oversimplification to say that the strike failed simply because it was stabbed in the back by the mis-leaders of the British labour movement. Their treachery was certainly a crucial factor in the strike's eventual outcome, but it was only half the picture.

" Many of the strike leaders were sincerely hostile to capitalism and committed to the struggle for a socialist society, but their politics were so influenced by the ideas of anarcho-syndicalism that they were unable to build on the dual power situation created by the general strike and unable to raise the conflict to the level of a conscious revolutionary confrontation with the bourgeois state. Anarcho-syndicalism is based on the idea that the working class, if well enough instructed and educated through propaganda, will spontaneously overthrow capitalism. All that is necessary in the meantime is for socialists to explain' to workers the nature of capitalism and to build industrial unions which embrace all workers in a particular industry. Once the class is organised in "one big union"

the cataclysmic upheaval which overthrows capitalism takes place of its own accord.

Due in particular to the strength of the Socialist Labour Party (SLP) in Glasgow, anarcho-syndicalism had a strong influence on the Glasgow labour movement throughout the early part of the century. The SLP had been formed in 1903 as a break-away in the direction of anarcho-syndicalism from the Social Democratic Federation, the only Marxist national organisation in existence at that time.

Anarcho-syndicalism was partly a reaction to the class collaboration practised by the labour movement leaders. As such and in its emphasis on the need to organise at rank and file level, there was a positivé side to the work of the SLP and others on the Clyde influenced by anarcho-syndicalism. It was central in generating the wartime unrest and struggles.

But the anarchosyndicalists also suffered from political weaknesses so serious as to prove fatal in Glasgow 1919. The SLP did not exist to give leadership on day-to-day issues in the overall framework of working for the overthrow of capitalism; it existed only to carry out a propaganda role of lecturing workers about the evils of capitalism and the need to overthrow it.

Strike or revolution?

In Glasgow 1919 the leaders of the movement influenced by anarcho-syndicalism floundered helplessly: Gallacher — wordly-wise, as ever, after the event — writes, "we were carrying on a strike when we ought to have been making a revolütion...such was the condition of our leadership [that there was] no plan, no unity of purpose, we were watching one another and waiting for and wondering.. what was going to happen. rising should have taken place. The workers were ready and able to effect it, the leadership had never thought of it."

Only a hopeless romantic could believe that the 'situation in Glasgow was as clear-cut as the quote from Gallacher implies, with the workers just waiting to be told to carry out a revolution but the leaders unfortunately having forTanks on the streets of Glasgow gotten such a possibility.

But the situation did demand a clear, revolutionary leadership which the anarcho-syndicalists were unable to provide. The ruling class displayed a ruthlessness and determination which demanded a similar reply from the strike leaders if defeat was to be avoided. Passive propaganda about the need to overthrow capitalism was meaningless when a counter-offensive by the ruling class was under way to beat back the threat posed by the general strike.

But there was no attempt to shut down the press and thereby deprive the enemy of its main instrument of propaganda. There was no attempt to win over the troops in the Maryhill Barracks who vere so close to mutiny that the government dared not use them against the strikers. There was no attempt to establish armed workers' militias despite the availability of weapons and ex-soldiers trained in their use. And despite the anarcho-syndicalists' emphasis on organisation at rank-and-file level, there was a particular failure to tap the discontent of the unions involved in the Triple Alliance. In a situation of dual power where the balance could be tipped in either direction - a revolutionary restructuring of society or a return to capitalist stability, at least temporarily - the inability of the anarcho-syndicalists to sharpen the conflict and draw in wider forces proved a crucial weakness. '24 hours can decide the fate of a revolution" wrote Lenin, and Glasgow 1919 proved it, negatively.

In both its strengths and weaknesses the strike contains a wealth of lessons for the labour movement of today. •The knowledge we have gained will not be wasted. Be ready!", the Strike Bulletin had told its readers. But it is up to the revolutionary socialists of today to draw the correct lessons from Glasgow 1919 and thereby ensure it is not a wasted chapter in the history of the struggle for workers' power. FOLLOWING your recent articles on the shorter hours strikes of 1919 in Belfast and Scotland. particularly Glasgow, your readers may be interested in the following gleaned from the 'Strike Bulletin', organ of the 40 hours movement.

In the issue of January 31, 1919 it reports that Belfast 'is practically in the hands of the strikers...(and) The Belfast members of the unskilled unions have compelled their executives to recognise their strike, and the union funds are to be used to pay benefit."

The Bulletin calls for similar action in Scotland and for "Executives to act as the servants of the workers instead of allowing them to boss the show...

Strike patrols On February 2, 1919 the headline of the Bulletin is Machine Guns No Remedy, and it also reports that the Scottish TUC had called a general strike. In Belfast it reported that there was "organised a body of pickets to maintain order in the streets...The Belfast Strike Patrol is 2,000 strong...what about Strike Patrols for Scotland?"

The next day, the Bulletin reports that a trade union secretary from England was sent over to upbraid local union officials for their encouragement of the strike. He was met at the boat and "escorted to the offices of the local branch engineers, where they promptly locked him in a room. There he was kept prisoner till the time of departure of the next return steamcr. The issue of February 9, Get SOCIALIST door by post.

RATES: £8.50 Name .

Address 1919 replies to the threat of further state intimidation: 'The awful tanks cannot destroy the human wall which we have built to support our demand." It reports, too, that in Belfast 'The strike committee receives aplications for electric current and refuses some, but allows hospitals to take current for X-ray purposes during the daytime as well as for light at night...

Not only do the Bulletins provide up to the minute strike news, but also sharp, pungent stories from the ruling class press, which are given a class struggle content, as are reports from South Africa, Japan and India. The issue of February 11, 1919 under a headline about women's pickets reports 'With over 500,000 women in the country unemployed, the women realise that the only way to provide useful work for all is to reduce the hours of labour all round.

By February 12, 1919 the strike had ended in Scotland. The last issue reports that the Bulletin's circulation reached 20,000 daily, and its last editorial expounds the dignity of better having fought and lost,: than never having fought at all.

•The strike is suspended until we reinforce our ranks. We have retreated in good order and without any intention of subexploiters wish to impose mitting lo ule aujeer certio "ei.- in tha nhient terme nur VUL on us...The strike has taught us power; has developed capacity; has shown where organisation is weak; has.g ven us valuable experience. The knowledge we have gained will not be wasted. Be Ready."

Yours fraternally, JOHN DOUGLAS ORGANISER each week delivered to for 6 months. £16 for one year N1 2SY.

Scan page 8

no. 215. February 6 THIRTEEN years ago, on January 30, 1972, the British army shot dead 13 unarmed civilians. The place was Derry, northern Ireland; the occasion was a demonstration against internment without charge or trial. It has gone down in history as Bloody Internment had been introduced - exclusively for Catholics - six months earlier, in August 1971. A peaceful demonstration was called in Derry. The Northem Ireland Unionist government in Stormont banned the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 215

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →