Is Zionism racism?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page. Unsigned in print: the standfirst gives it as Andy Burke's account to Socialist Organiser of why he opposed the ban. Photographs captioned: "Top: Fascists attack Jewish shops in the East End in the 1930s. Below: The Jewish community and the Labour Movement fight back, Cable Street, 1936". "the only way to that consistently" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 8
Two weeks ago, Sunderland Polytechnic decided to ban the Union of Jewish Students (UJS) because they are Zionist. Andy Burke, currently president of Sunderland Poly, and a SSIN supporter explained to Socialist Organiser why he opposes the ban. The Executive meeting on February 4 defeated Andy's proposal to recognise the UJS. The matter now goes to a general meeting this Friday.
BANNING the Jewish Society at Sunderland Poly was wrong in principle.
A general meeting passed a motion saying that Zionism is racism. The Jewish Society constitution gives support to Israel. So the society was declared racist and banned.
But that motion should not have been passed.
Saying that Israel is racist and saying that everyone who is a Zionist is therefore a racist are two totally separate things.
Israel is certainly a racist state; it discriminates against Palestinians and the present Israeli state denies a homeland to the Palestinians it drove out.
Victims
But most Jews — many of them are the victims or relatives of the victims of the most terrible act of state racism in recorded history — believe that they have a right to a Jewish state. Apart from far left socialists and religious sects all Jews are "Zionists".
Consequently they accept the legitimacy of Israel. Most Jews do not know the real history of the driving out of the Palestinians.
But of course it is not true that all Jews or all supporters of the right of Israel to exist agree with Israel's policy. It is not even true that all Israelis agree with the Israeli government's policies. Between 300,000 and half a million Israelis demonstrated in protest at the 1982 massacres of Palestinian refugees by Falangist Lebanese in areas occupied by the Israeli army. That is a proportionate equivalent number for Britain of between three and five million demonstrators.
Many thousands of Israelis recently turned out on a counter-demonstration against a fascist demonstration in a Palestinian village.
These are Zionists, i.e. people who believe that Israel has a right to exist. They are not racists, despite the racist character and basis of the state. The whole question is a very complex one.
Since World War 2 and the Nazi holocaust it has become a part of the Jewish identity to look to the state of Israel. We may not agree with this, but it is not difficult to understand why it should be so.
It is not possible now to demand that all Jews separate out Jewish identity and culture from the question of Israel and to ban those who won't.
That's the mistake Sunderland made, insisting that the UJS became anti-Zionist, which in effect meant insisting that the Jewish students rejected a very great part of their religious and cultural identity.
I think the Jewish people, like everybody else, should be committed to fighting what Israel does to the Palestinians. And I think the only way to that consistently is to be opposed to Zionism. But I don't think Jews can or should be forced into being anti-Zionist or that passing resolutions telling them not to be Zionists is a sensible way of going about it. Convincing Jews to be opposed to Zionism can only be done through argument.
Reverse
Sunderland Poly should reverse its decision to ban the UJS and we should change our policy on Zionism. We should still say that Israel is a racist state and that we support a democratic secular state. But we should get rid of the clause which says that everyone who is a Zionist is a racist.