Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Throwing in the towel

Socialist Organiser no. 215, 6 February 1985 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,799 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

When the South Wales NUM funds were seized. Photo: M.Shakeshaft,IFI. After a long period of pessimism, the Socialist Workers Party (SWP) was taken by surprise by the miners' strike. Then - eventually - they threw themselves into it. Now, they are once again preaching doom, gloom and despondency. Jack Cleary reports.

"THIS IS the time that tries men's souls" , wrote the famous pamphleteer Tom Paine when George Washington and the fighters for American independence were struggling to survive and it looked like they were faced with defeat.

Today the setbacks suffered by the miners' strike are putting the Marxist groups in Britain to the test, and forcing them to declare what they are made of.

On the one side there are those - the Newsline is the most prominent example — who refuse to recognise the real difficulties of the strike or to register what the slump and mass unemployment have done to the working class in the last five years. They make a religion of the call for a general strike. Socialists need realism, honesty and candour in assessing the world around us. Newsline and others like it do not have that.

But at least they do not spread defeatism: miners and other workers will not feel additionally deflated and depressed as a result of listening to what they have to say.

The Socialist Workers' Party, and its weekly paper Socialist Worker, on the other hand, spread a depressing defeatism. The defeatism is disguised with militant headlines, to be sure. But anyone reading what Socialist Worker says could not avoid the conclusion that there is no hope, that the strike is lost.

Socialist Worker's Februarý 2 issue, for example, has good headline advice for striking miners: 'No Surrender' '. The basic idea of the article is also sensible, though a little deflated: "The miners must stick together. This is the only way to stop the Tories breaking the power of the union to defend jobs and conditions:

•'This is no time for unconditional surrender by the miners? leadership"

But there are no grounds for tional surrender' (and when exactly would it be a good time to. consider unconditional surrender?)

Autopsy The underlying train of thought, behind this, is made clear in articles inside that issue, under the heading, 'The knives are out for the NUM". They. state: "The media and the right wing in the labour movement have already started their autopsy on the miners' "strike". Socialist Worker then proceeds to do exactly the same thing, conducting its own 'left wing autopsy.

Their own inner collapse and acceptance of defeat while over 100,000 miners and their families are still fighting is unmistakeable.

For example, talking about the ballot and the right wing, they say: "They are trying to create the impression that it Photo. Rick Matthews, IFL was the failure to hold the ballot which led the strike to defeat"

Under the headline 'Who is to blame?", they talk about the "very powerful criticisms to be made of how the NUM leadership have handled the strike"

Arthur Scargill is seen as being in some ways an exception, but 'he failed to deliver the leadership which could have taken the strike in a different direction"

They are entitled to their opinion, and these are things that will have to be discussed after the strike. But the Socialist Workers Party are not entitled — while continuino to nresent themselves as militants — to give up before the hard core of the miners give up.

Over the last few years the SWP has been in a deep political depression, talking as if no ECOTTISH AHEA BARGOED SURFACE LODGI major working class action could even be considered. They correctly registered the downturn in the working class movement, but magnified and exaggerated it into a deep depressive pessimism which led them to outright defeatism towards everything alive in either the industrial or the political wing of the labour movement.

Preaching defeatism, they became a force, so far as they had influence, for demobilisation and passivity in the labour movement.

They criticised the Benn current in the labour move: ment for losing contact with the v vorking class. It was too left, and INL LUE CCI therefore out of step with a depressed and defeated working class.

The SWP ran parallel - albeit in its own sectarian groove -to the Communist Party Hobsbawmites with their talk of 'The Forward March of Labour Halted'.

While the Hobsbawmites concluded that a coalition with the SDP was necessary, it was not clear what the SWP concluded other than a withdrawal into self-centred 'party' concerns. They had an attitude of snobbishly frigid disdain towards the left wing struggle in the Labour Party. They wound up various rank and file trade union groups.

The miners' strike - the fact that it could happen at all -flatly contradicted the SWP's assessments of the state of the movement.

For a while they seemed to abandon their prostration, and responded energetically to the strike. But they never corrected themselves or criticised their previous assessments, taking refuge in statements that the miners' strike was a 'defensive' strike. (Which is only partly true. The NUM's position on pit closures does not correspond to any 'normal' trade union defensive movement).

Now things are coming full circle. The strike is in serious difficulties, so the SWP relapses into defeatism. It tries to fulfill the ABC duty of a socialist newspaper with cries to 'hold firm' - but its underlying defeatism shows through. It starts a public autopsy on a defeat that has not happened yet - a defeat we must continue to fight to avoid.

An extreme expression of the terrible confusion that the SWP is now helplessly wallowing in was an article by Socialist Worker editor Chris Harman in the January issue of the SWP magazine 'Socialist Worker Review".

After a two page long ramble on the history of the general strike, Harman comes to the point in the last five paragraphs.

He says that today the slogan the general strike comes from Livingstone and Benn, who continue to think that 'what matters is parliamentary action reinforced by extra-parliamentary activity. On the other [hand] it comes from sects who refuse to look the reality of the class struggle in Britain today in the face"

And what do the 'good guys of the SWP say?

'Revolutionary socialists should argue that the slogan does not fit at the moment because of the way the Labour Party leadership and the TUC general council have sabotaged the movement in solidarity with the miners. But we also have to go on to say something else: if the slogan did fit (and it will do one day) then it would be necessary to raise alongside it slogans about rank and file control and about confrontation with the state"

Cretinous

Harman is perfectly right that in a general strike revolutionary socialists would raise slogans to take it forward -argue that the workers take control, organise their own defence forces, etc. But it is nothis sho one erenoon to use as one the call for a general strike cannot now be raised for the limited immediate objective of defending the NUM.

If a general strike got started and began to unfold and develop in mass action, then other slogans and issues would arise in the course of the strike, and socialists would respond to their expanding possibilities.

No less ridiculous is the notion that socialists do not call for a general strike because the Labour Party and trade union leaders have sabotaged solidarity with the miners. When was it otherwise? Mass strike and solidarity action is possible without the leaders and can pressure the leaders into calling for effective action. That is what happened in Britain in 1972 when one quarter of a million workers struck on hearing that five dockers were in jail under the Tory anti-union laws.

Certainly it is a different situation now, centrally because o the slump and the accumulater setbacks and defeats of the las six years. That's the stronges argument against the genera strike call - the objectiv difficulties. But it does not fol low that we do not call for a gen eral strike.

A general strike is objectivet necessary for the self-defence o the working class now, and with out it serious further blow will be struck at the labou movement.

What Marxists conclude fror the combination of the need fo a general strike with the ba state that the working class is in is not that we do not dare sa what is in the objective interest of the class, and call on militant to work for it, but that we mak propaganda for it.

We explain why it is neces sary. We link it to events a they unfold. We break it dow into warm-up demands lik the call for a one-day gener; strike — on February 11, fc example.

The SWP's rejection of th call for a general strike is jus part of its crippling defeatis - its fatalistic inner acceptanc of defeat.

Looking in the face the realit of the situation the working clas faces now is an irreplaceabl activity for Marxists. Bein hypnotised and paralysed by th difficulties, like a rabbit me merised by a snake - that i not Marxist realism. That i throwing in the towel.

The SWP "towel' has a fe Marxist-sounding consider tions and ideas printed on it, br it is nevertheless a signal to giv in and give up. Despite the mil tant headlines, Socialist Workt picks up, magnifies, and refled back onto the miners the sa of pressures that are leading th strike to crumble in certai areas.

For what other message ca striking miners get when, entir ed by the militant-soundin unhortations to 'stand fir and 'no surrender", they ope the paper to find SW attemptin to conduct a premature autops un the still-living - and sti fighting — body of the miner: strike?

Scan page 10

- Revi wavoidable Organiser no 215: February 6 1985 Page An DISASTERS often seem to arrive like bolts from the blue — a product of sheer bad luck.

Closer examination, however, shows how various factors conspire to produce an "accident".

So it is with the Bhopal tragedy, as reports in the Guardian, New York Times and New Scientist make clear.

New Scientist, in a report by 1985 Page transmitting vibrations to more dangerous parts of the plant. It was also easy to overtill the tanks.

Workers received no emergency training and were in any case overexposed to MIC and chloroform, a known cause of cancer. The report listed four 1120 *4 & *÷ax 4xx.x% 4÷÷ 2 00

----- pull-quotes -----

thinking that the miners' leader- ship is about to go for 'uncondi-

act of God"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 215

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →