Better times
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
"We are very glad you all understand why we are here, we have not done anything we are ashamed of, our action was against bad, wicked laws and all good men and women should protest and refuse to obey laws which are unjust and bad...
"We are in prison because our people in Poplar are cannot pay the rates and taxes and we shall not do judges told us we must do until Poplar gets money "When you leave school join a trade union ...
"When you have joined your trade union, go to the meetings, learn all you can about the labour movement Excerots from the letter iailed Poplar councillors wrote Christopher Joyce in Washington. pinpoints the responsibility , of Union Carbide for this "accident"
Firstly, warnings of just such a disaster were issued in 1984 bui were not passed to the Indians.
Secondly, the Union Carbide plant in Institute, West Virginia, was far from safe, having had 28 leaks in five years.
Thirdly, the safety mechanIsms in the Institute plant would not have been capable of deal-ing with a Bhopal-type disaster.
The warning and its failure to be passed on are perhaps the most poignant parts of Joyce's report. In July last, engineers at - Institute warned of the danger of "runaway" reactions in the tanks containing methyl isocyanate (MIC). They told Union Carbide that the MIC tanks had been contaminated several times, with water and other reactants. They advised that "all operating personnel" be warned as there could be "catastrophic" consequences.
Warning
The warning was never transmitted to the similar plant at Bhopal, and on December 3 : Last year at least 2,000 people were injured fatally, and 200,000 more injured as a result of just such a runaway reaction.
But what of the safety mechanisms designed to deal with emergencies such as these? The trouble is that in the parent plant (and presumably in Bhopal) they were not so designed. In a runaway reaction where a gas is produced mixed with a liquid, just like a por boiling over, the mixture should first go to a "knockout" tank. This separates the gas from the liquid. The gas, MIC in this case, should then go through a "scrubber" of caustic soda, to neutralise it. Any surplus gas would be burnt or •-flared" as it left the scrubber.
At Institute, the knockout tank was after the scrubber. The system was designed only to deal with gas leaks, and would soon be overwhelmed by a mixture of gas and liquid.
As the company's own saftey ram report, the parent plant mas by no means a safe place. The cooling system, designed to keep the MIC liquid, reducing the pressure, was one problem area, giving rise to the leaks referred to previously. The storage tanks and pipes were also the process" and might result in • or so. major and 39 "less serious" concerns over safety and health.
A report by the US Environmental Protection Agency is more soothing but apparently did not see the company's safety team report. However, it did note 28 leaks of MIC in five It would have taken only a small further relaxation in safety standards for a disaster at Institute, but this is what occurred in bhopal.
According to New York Times reporters, the Bhopal plant had been making a loss for two years, had lost key staff, and was under pressure to cut costs.
Whether or not for this reason the Bhopal management was demoralised, there was little proper training of new staff, and, possibly crucially, the refrigeration unit keeping the MICC liquid had been turned off.
Then when an untrained worker washed out a pipe, a small amount of water - as little as one pint — was all that was necessary to cause the poison gas cloud.
Without training or proper warnings, the workforce mostly fled.
The accident had found where to happen.
THE medical effects of MIC poisoning are gradually becoming clearer, though there is still a good deal of uncertainty.
The Indian Council of Medical Research has studied the bodies of gas victims and found "devastating" damage to brain, liver and kidneys. In all 20 of the post mortems carried out, severe pulmonary oedema (filling of the lungs with fluid) was found. This is a symptom of poisoning by phosgene, a poison gas used in the First World War, which was a chemical used in the manufacture of pesticide in Bhopal.
Many survivors are unfit for work, suffering from breathing difficulties that leave them weak. In view of the inadequate or non-existent support they receive from the government, some survivors are now going hungry.
Good news is that eye problems seem to be temporary, despite the extreme pain and ulceration initially suffered.:
Genetic effects of the MIC poisoning cannot be assessed yet. Most deformities arise in 1h- Saunt thour Susan Carlyle Barry Keeffe's Better Times, at Theatre Royal.
THE three women in the photo are Labour councillors for the Borough of Poplar. It is 1921 and they are in Holloway Jail. Together with the rest of the Poplar Labour Council, led by George Lansbury, they have opted to go tó jail rather than comply with Tory government cuts.
In the photo, Councillor Nellie Cressall, who is heavily pregnant and disoriented by her treatment in prison, is being persuaded by councillors Susan Lawrence and Julia Scurr, that she will not be deserting the cause by signing a piece of paper that will secure her release and allow her to go home.
Barry Keeffe's play, "Better Times" tells the story of Poplar's fight. Unfortunately it does not adequately convey the clear determination of councillors like Nellie Cressall. At times it presents the characters as if they were participating in some kind of routine enjoyment of domestic harmony, with everyone agreeing rather too easily. 1 bet it wasn't quite like that!
All of them, with the exception of eccentric Susan Lawrence and sharp Julia Scurr are presented as rather pompous and self-important, that is as the classic councillor stereotype.
The focus is very much on Labour leader George Lansbury's character. So other councillors pale in comparison. Where in life disagreement and discussion would have decided actions, the play personalises it play, the rich to help the poor ...
"We want you to grow up women. We want you never to single man or woman starving.
to their children. in Lansbury, swinging along his reputation.
The play addresses itself to political questions that are very much alive today, and present-day parallels are not hard to find. While Lansbury personifies the left and the working class Igners, Tulure Labour alana Filtrior C..t..un I harro Cabinet m Minister Herbert Morrison represents the "realists" and the compromisers.
Conciliator
To the figure of Morrison, in the play as in history, falls the role of class conciliator and class traitor. Morrison doesn't want to fight or confront the government. An ex-Marxist, he thnks Labour councils should do the best they can within the framework laid down by a hostile government, running between the Poplar councillors and Lloyd George, looking for "compromise' ', Morrison gets no thanks for it.
Morrison demands that Poplar should stay within the law are resisted. but the play gives him the last word in the final scene where he talks about Lansbury's demise and Blunkett, Knight and Livingstone ar and Attlee.
poor and what the from the strong, active, loving men and be contented while there is one branch the rise of fascism in the End.
was like that in life too. Morrisonism prevailed in the Labour Party. Labour leaders, trained in local government "realism" to operate the capitalist system and not seek too much change — Labour's 1945 Prime Minister Clement Attlee was one of them — came to dominate the Party. Morrison' policy in local government came to dominate the national labour movement.
Most of the scenes that linger from the play are those that detail their everyday life: how they dodged arrest; how tired at meetings one councillor usually was from grinding shift work as a postman; the insults Julia Scurr would hurl at Morrison; the letters written from prison to their children (see box above).
They must have been marvellous times to live in. Despite overwhelming odds of unemployment and poverty, thousands took to the streets. Laws were changed by such commitment and by the will to take on the government.
The Poplar councillors achieved their goal of equalisanot in the tradition of Lansbury (righi tion of rates by refusing to charge their own people on the same terms as the rich London boroughs. At the same time they provided houses with gardens, opened public bath houses and sustained working class self-reliance and hope for the future.
That tradition, "Poplarism" should be revived in the present struggle for local government.
With the Tory government bearing down on 12 London boroughs and four metropolitan councils, a good play about ''Poplarism" militant defence of local working class interests by a Labour council — would be apt and timely. Barry Keeffe's play doesn't quite rise to its theme.
But 'Better Times" should be seen. The production is good, and there are some fine believable performances. When labour movement play actually sees the light of day then it is to be welcomed.
"Better times"' proved a rare example of positive drama amid the current excess of fantasy and fatalism in theatre.
Perspective
It is also worth some councillors taking a visit to the Theatre Royal - especially waverers such as Blunkett and Livingstone. Seen in the perspective of working class history the startling thing about Livingstone, Knight, Blunkett and others today is that — despite left talk - when it comes to action they are not in Lansbury's Poplar tradition, but firmly in the tradition of Herbert Morrison. And that's a lousy tradition. • but in that of Morrison
Scan page 11
Socialist Organises Do 215 Fear a: 51985 Page