's CP & LCC The aead hand
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Age KARL MARX once wrote that history repeats itself, the time as tragedy, the second as farce.
But there is nothing humorous about the way in which the current miners' strike is, in Scotland, a repeat of the campaign of 1980/81 for increased democracy and accountability in The latter campaign, organised at national level by the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Party Democracy (RFMC), succeeded in winning significant advances, such as the electoral college for election of Party leader and deputy leader, and automatic reselection of MPs.
Those advances, and the campaigning work which achieved them, saw a shift in the nature of the Labour party towards a more campaigning, class struggle-related type of party, however limited the extent of the shift.
But in Scotland the RFMC never got off the ground. Whereas in the rest of the country the RFMC united the Labour Left, in Scotland the Labour Coordinating Committee (LCC) successfully argued that establishment of the RFMC was superfluous on the grounds that the LCC itself was perfectly capable of fulfilling the role played elsewhere by the RFMC.
Non existence
The non-existence of the RFMC in Scotland meant that the democracy campaign there of 1980/81 was only a pale shadow of its counterpart down South. Consequently, the impact of that campaign - shaking up the Labour Party and making it more responsive to the needs of the class struggle - was infinitely weaker in Scotland than elsewhere.
In short: the transformation of the Scottish labour movement lagged far behind that of the movement nationally.
Today, in many areas of the country the miners' strike is playing the same role as the RFMC in taking forward the transformation of the Labour pit villages with local support groups and failed to even attempt to organise consistent mass picketing of pits and power stations, whilst the Scottish TUC has focussed its efforts on achieving an "amicable resolution to end the dispute rather than on raising the level of solidarity action to win the strike.
The role of the Communist party has been to attempt to wall off the strike from Labour Party activists and the rest of the labour movement. Thought not fully successful in this endeavour, the CP has succeeded in generally reducing the miners' strike to an object of admiration, instead of being an agency for driving forward the transformation of the Labour Party.
The LCC has played a secondary, back-up role, sniping at Scargill in the pages of "Scottish Labour Activist', , demanding that all funds raised for the miners be sent to NUM head. quarters rather than local pits, and backing a resolution at Glasgow District Labour party opposing the existence of local miners' support groups.
Enacted
It is not coincidental that the role played by the LCC in rela tion to the RFMC is now enacter by the CP in relation to the • Some of the more prominen Scottish LCC supporters have : background in the CP. Other: share the CP's politics on : number of issues. More impor tantly, the same political methor is employed by both the Scottisi LCC and CP: maintenance of : tight bureaucratic grip on devel opments in the labour move ments — even at the expens of stifling combativity and there by helping pave the way fo victory by the labour movemen right wing or the Tories.
As the internecine warfare i the CP escalates, with an oper split increasingly likely at it special conference in th summer followed by the collaps of a substantial section of th present CP membership into th Labour Party, a not unlikel development, in Scotland a least, wuld be a fusion/alliano between the LCC and the ex CP members inside of th There is already a good bast for such a development: shared political method, a com parable track record, the LCC domination of the Labour Part Scottish Council, and the CP ability to provide the foo soldiers in the union and (in th event of collapse into it) th labour Party to regiment th rank and file in line with the LO inspired decisions of Scottis The result would be strengthening of those force which have already played sud a destructive role in holdin back the politically nécessar transformation of the Labou Party in Scotland.
left in the Labour Party an unions in Scotland to so organis itself as to be capable of thrust ing aside the bureaucrati impediment constituted now b an organisationally separat LCC and CP but in the future b a possibly coalesced LCC ex-CP bloc.