Labour and the
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Throughout the miners' strike he has cut a very unheroic figure — viewed from either side of the class lines. Thatcher and her ministers have abused and flayed him for not roundly condemning the miners. Militant miners and the serious Left detest him for his timorous havering and dithering in the middle of a great working-class battle, when he should be at the head of our side of it.
Kinnock has trod his lonely road, in the middle of the industrial and political minefield, under fire from both sides.
Kinnock says, and probably thinks, that he serves the Labour Party's interests by this behaviour; more, that the very future of It seems to be a matter of fact that Labour (and Kinnock) have lost much support in the opinion polls because of Labour's links with the miners. To win elections Labour needs to gather votes from beyond the broadest parameters of the trade union movement. Kinnock and his friends conclude from this that the miners' When the miners were on the offensive, they resolutely refused to hoist their flag over the miners' army. Now that the strike is on the defensive, Kinnock and his co-thinkers attack the Tories as But they don't stand fully with the miners now, either. They stand for 'reason' , 'moderation', and 'conciliation' The latest MORI poll shows Labour' s loss of support being reversed, as people now blame Thatcher for the continuation of the strike. Things are now going Kinnock's way. So it is a good time, having looked at the question from Kinnock's point of view, to nail The idea that Labour can rise electorally if the miners go down to If the miners are beaten, then it will justify Thatcher's attitude in the eyes of many who wanted a Tory victory if it could be bought cheaply but are now turning squeamish. People who regret Thatcher's break with the old 'British ways' , because the break has so far brought no benefits and increasingly horrible conflict, will be silenced by success. If Thatcher wins, the grouses will stop and the Worse than that. If the miners are beaten and the Tories come out of their war against the 'Argentinians at home' successful, then there may well be a cumulative effect on the labour movement. We will go into the Tory-imposed plebiscites to decide whether unions should have a political fund — that is, if the Labour Party should be permitted a trade-union base — in the most unfavourable condiThe chances of defeat, and of a scrious erosion of Labour's organised trade-union basę, will be massively increased in the industrial and social climate produced by a Thatcher victory over her More: Thatcher has the nerve of a leader. From her own ruling-class point of view, she would be mad not to inflict as much damage Three years before an election, it will take more than the swings of volative public moods to get Thatcher to call off the dogs. She knows very well that victory will not only settle accounts with the labour movement for now, but will also provide a basis to restore If Kinnock chases helplessly after public opinion and the polls, the Tories don't. Thatcher and her Cabinet base themselves on solid ground. They know what side they are on, and that the conThatcher doesn't weasel or vacillate, wishing that the conflict would go away and let her get on with her parliamentary statesmanship. She recognises that the substance of that statesmanship Thatcher is a leader in the class war. But Kinnock thinks he is an aspirant leader of a 'national community', with a 'national interest' that stands above the raging class struggle. Labour should not take sides with the miners, but should seek instead to secure the The class consensus is spurious. The national interest is mythi cal. Nothing solid can be built on the opinion-poll swings and movements which Kinnock and his co-thinkers guide themselves by. If the miners lose, any Labour gains will quickly vanish.
Electoral support from beyond the labour movement will not automatically come with industrial victory; but it will come a lot more easily to an industrially victorious labour movement than to Victory in the miners' strike would put new heart into the whole labour movement. It would shatter the Tories' appearance of strength and invulnerability, destroy their mystique of knowing what's best and having policies where Labour has none that carry It would mean that we went through the Tory trade union plebiscites on political funds when the spirit of cohesion, solidarity, and arpose in the labour movemeni had been given a firm boost rather mmock's strate has never been right, never far-sighted, LET US pause for a while and ponder on the dilemmas of Neil Kinnock, mustering as much sympathy and understanding for him as we can. the Labour Party depends on it.
strike must be kept at arm's length.
Army unreasonable and bloody-minded.
this nonsense.
industrial defeat is doubly false.