Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[THE FRENCH Communist Party congress on February 6…]

Socialist Organiser no. 216, 13 February 1985 · scan pp. 8–9 · Martin Thomas · about 1,344 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

THE FRENCH Communist Party congress on February 6 to 10 was as dramatic in its way as the British CP's present crisis.

For the first time since the Stalinisation of the CP in the 1920s, the Central Committee did not come to the congress united. Pierre Juquin, Marcel Rigout, and other prominent CP leaders openly challenged general secretary Georges Marchais.

The French CP, with 600,000 members and over 20,000 full-timers, is much stronger than the British CP, and the party machine was able to keep a big majority behind Marchais. But rank-and-file discontent is certainly much wider than the 3% vote against the Central Committee majority, and the 7% abstentions, which the party officially admits.

The broad lines of the division are similar to those in the British CP, but the details are different.

The French CP leadership has a similar line to the Morning Star in Britain.

In the 1970s it officially abandoned the dictatorship of the proletariat' and declared its willingness to work within NATO. But since 1977, when it broke away from the 'Union of the Left' (an alliance with the Socialist Party), it has stayed quite close to Moscow.

It supported the USSR's invasion of Afghanistan and the martial law in Poland.

The opposition within the CP leadership is similar to the 'Eurocommunists' of Marxism Today in Britain. They are not happy about the CP's withdrawal from the Socialist-led government in July last year and its subsequent shift to a more militant line in industry. They talk about the danger of the CP marginalising" itself and becoming "the biggest grouplet of the far left" rather than a major parliamentary party.

Pierre Juquin calls for an alliance of "the socialist parties, Greens, pacifists, Third-Worldists, and some religious forces"

But, as in Britain, the "working class" rhetoric of the pro-Moscow wing is pretty shallow. The official line is a "new majority popular rallying". As with the "broad democratic alliance" in Britain, no-one quite knows what it means.

The difference between the British CP and the French CP is that the French CP has a mass working-class base. It is also less rare in France than in Britain for CP workers to see themselves as revolutionaries. The up-beat, declamatory style of the French CP daily L Humanité contrasts with the lame, 750 ANS DE FIDELITÉ A LA hangdog manner Star.

What do the CP workers think about it all? It is difficult to tell. Some agree with Alain Amicabile, a former electrician who told the Central Committee last June: "For the youth, we are not the party of human rights, we are not the party of democratic socialism; we are the party of the Gulag and of Afghanistan"

But most are just disillusioned. The CP officially admits to having lost 100,000 members since 1980, and dissidents claim that only one-third of the branches, and one-third of the members in those branches, are active.

The CP vote has declined dramatically. Up to 1979 it was around 20%. But during the 1970s the Socialist Party -which had been down to 5% of the vote in 1969 - overtook the CP. In the 1984 Euro-elections the CP got only 11% of the votes cast. As a percentage of the total electoral roll - 6 percent - the CP's vote was the lowest ever.

Even that minimal vote is pretty disillusioned. Opinion polls show that between 35% and 50% of CP voters have a 'negative' attitude to Marxism, dislike the USSR, think the public sector should be rolled back, and consider that sexual liberalisation has gone too far.

In a way the French CP's crisis combines the crises of the Labour Party and of the CP in Britain. Like the Labour Party here, the CP has been the major party of the working class - but its drab, bureaucratic and timid version of socialism (1945 vintage) is less and less attractive.

Like the British CP. the French CP has the problem that its main point of distinction from a bigger social-democratic party — its link with Moscow - is now a liability. (The French SP has suffered electorally since its 1981 peak of 38%, but still has many more voters than the CP).

The CP is caught both ways. Either it distances itself from Moscow and moves closer to the Socialist Party - in which case it looks like a second-rate SP, and loses support. Or it moves away from the SP and closer to Moscow - in which case it looks like "the party of the Gulag" ...and loses support.

The crisis could go a lot further yet. The collapse of the Spanish CP is an indication. Since 1977 it has gone down from 200,000 to 40,000 members, and from 9% of votes to 4 per cent.

The question is whether the decline of the CP will yield new recruits for the revolutionary left, or only for the SP and for political apathy.

Scan page 9

4 TILEDE QURE DISTRATRI THE lights went out over the Peruvian capital of Lima last week while the visiting Pope was castigating radical Catholic priests. The culprits were an organisation of rural guerrillas known as Sendero Luminoso who had blown up the pylons providing electricity to the city.

In Peru, as in many Latin American states dictatorships come and go, violence flares across town and countryside: chaos rules.

A new Special Brief from the Latin American Bureau -"Peru: Paths to Poverty" — explains the historical background to the apparent chaos and makes sense of it.

Peru is one of the poorest countries in Latin America. And as elsewhere in the Third World, there is great inequality of wealth: the poor are extremely poor, and getting poorer. Purchasing power has fallen by over 50% over the last ten years, leading to widespread malnutrition.

In 1983, the minimum wage paid for less than half of the necessary family food baskets. Peru has a high death rate, and a low lite expectancy.

Meanwhile the state spends only 4.1% of its budget on health (as against 12% on the armed forces).

But it is also a country with a long history of popular struggle.

A relatively advanced social system, ruled by the Inca kings, was conquered by the Spanish in the sixteenth century.

In Peru, the native Indian population was not wiped out, as it was, for example in Chile and Argentina. The colonial class system was moulded on ,to divisions between the Spanishdescended conquerors and the Indians. This relationship continues to be important for Above: general stri 1977, belo peasants mobilising in the sierra.

216. February 13 February proved a failure.

However, strikes continued including an 81-day strike by the Maoist-led teachers' unior SUTEP. The SUTEP strike had wide support and received powerful solidarity action During its course, a 48-hour general strike protested a new austerity programme. The strike was solid, but the governmen turned to repression in its after math.

The labour movement wen onto the defensive. A nationa miners' strike was defeated after 32 days, and a three-day general strike for the reinstate ment of those made redundan proved unsuccessful. A second SUTEP strike, backed up by the fifth general strike in two years also failed.

This was a bad period for the labour movement, and for the Left. In the 1980 elections, the far left vote declined; and the left as a whole was seen to he extremely divided. The victor of AP led to Belaunde Terry': return to power after twelve The new government opter for an economic programme modelled on that of Chile: ultra-Thatcherite 'Chicago Boys — that is a vicious, anti-working class monetarist policy. In part no danht no uvuul, encourageu vy cucu working class defeats, thei attempted a restructuring of the cconomy in the interests foreign and domestic capital and in particular financia interests.

But they could not implemen their programme. And it ha proved economically catas trophic.

Severe recession has led alsi to repression. "The deploymen of riot police equipped with tea gas and water cannon, violentl

----- pull-quotes -----

970, N5O ANG BE: FIDEN VIRSE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 216

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →