Banned for being Jewish
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026: the machine reading had run Edward Ellis's “Bigots latch onto AIDS”, printed below it on page 8, into this article column by column. Both transcribed from the scan; Bigots now has its own page. The photograph beside it is captioned “The Battle of Cable Street when the Jewish communities and the labour movement mobilised against the fascists.”
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 8
THE Union of Jewish Students is still outlawed at Sunderland Polytechnic. Over 500 students at the almost 1000-strong general meeting voted last Friday to continue the ban.
Student Union President Andy Burke, who opposed the ban, now faces a no-confidence motion at the Executive and intends to take the whole matter to the union council later this week.
During the week leading up to the general meeting, the Union of Jewish Students organised a national rally in Sunderland which was leafleted by Socialist Students in NOLS (SSIN) supporters from the North East and Manchester.
Unfortunately, there is now the danger of the Polytechnic's management stepping in. The leader of Sunderland Council — Jim Slater — is a Zionist and a right winger who sits on the governing body. It is feared that the ban will be used to further erode the union's autonomy.
The ban has more serious implications than at first seem obvious.
The confrontation at Sunderland started when the general meeting passed a motion saying that Zionism is racism. So it followed that the UJS, which is a Zionist organisation, should be banned.
But that simple equation is a nonsense in principle. Certainly Israel is a racist state, but to say that Zionism — the belief that Jews have a right to a state — is racism is ridiculous. The subsequent ban at Sunderland Poly is bordering on anti-semitism.
Large numbers of Labour Party members are Zionists. And not just right-wingers. Tony Benn, Eric Heffer, Jo Richardson all support the continued existence of the state of Israel. In that, they are Zionists, even though support for Israel is only one part of their politics, they are still Zionists.
Many of the comrades at Sunderland who voted to ban the UJS are also on the left of the Labour Party. Some will be supporting the campaign to pressurise Tony Benn to run against Kinnock for Labour Party leader. That Benn is a Zionist doesn't stop them supporting him.
So the only objection they can have is to organised Zionists. But that doesn't hold true either. Benn and Heffer are members of Labour Friends of Israel, so in that sense they are organised Zionists.
When it comes to wider politics, then the misguided comrades at Sunderland do not think that being a Zionist puts you beyond the pale.
Zionism is not such an issue for them that everything else is always secondary.
So to say that Zionism is racism, and to mean it, must lead the comrades to want to ban large chunks of the Labour left.
It would also mean that the comrades would want to ban a Labour Club which supported the continued existence of the state of Israel.
But Sunderland wouldn't carry that out. Certainly they may choose to leaflet or picket a Tony Benn meeting, but to talk about banning him is clearly ridiculous.
The only people Sunderland want to ban are the Jewish Zionists!