Fighting rate capping
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Ion Bridge committee, in personal capacity)
'Save Liverpool' demonstration. November 1983. Photo: John Smith.
By THE PHONY war between the government and the ratecapped local authorities is fast coming to an end .
March 7 is the day that the non-precepting authorities (i.e. those that levy their rates directly, as opposed to the GLC and ILEA, who collect a 'precept' via the borough councils) have chosen to set their budgets without setting a rate.
Underneath the present shouting match between the councils and the government, three different groupings are beginning to take shape on the labour movement side.
On the extreme right is the the Labour Party leadership - John Cunningham, the Parliamentary Labour Party spokesperson on local government, and Neil Kinnock.
At the recent Labour Party local government conference Kinnock called on Labour councils to stay within the law and do the best they can by benevolent administration within the limits set by the Tory cuts. A "dented shield' is better than ething, he said.
This speech gave a boost to the right wing among Labour councillors. But they do not hold the majority. The biggest grouping among the councillors follow the line of the Association of London Authorities (ALA: a grouping of Labour councils in London). They hope that by tactics of calculated defiance and 'going to the brink' they will be able to force a deal with Tory Environment Minister Patrick Jenkin This deal would include an upward revision of their ratecap limits, thus enabling them to raise the rates further. The shortfall between the increased limit and their desired budgets will be made up by selling off council property, by raiding reserve funds, by 'creative accounting', or by cuts in services.
The official ALA line is "no cuts' • but their real bottom line, it seems, is no compulsory redundancies.
For most of the rate-capped councils, this scenario is a viable proposition - this cil elections, the Council leaders decided not to use their now-solid majority to set a rate, but instead to negotiate with Jenkin. They came up with a deal in July But that deal leaves Liverpool in an even worse position this year: according to council deputy leader Derek Hatton, they need a 220% rate rise or 6,000 job cuts to balance the books.
Similar deals in the ratecapped authorities this year will have the same effect. They will not be a victory, but in many respects a defeat Individual councils will be isolated. Many will push through cuts in services. The discipline of the Tories' Rates Act will have been accepted. And the chance to open a second front alongside the miners will have been missed.
As in Liverpool, demoralisation will develop among workers, who will see that they have been the councillors' foot-soldiers.
Last Wednesday, 1 3th, Jenkin ordered very big LIVERPOOL increases in the rate-cap limits for three of the councils. Hackney's limit has been raised from 114p to 147p; Lewisham's from 87.5p to 99p; and Leicester's from 16p to 25p. Islington was also granted a small increase, from 111p to 112p.
These moves indicate that Jenkin sees deals of the sort described above as an acceptable outcome, and is prepared to manoeuvre to make them possible. They also show Jenkin's awareness of the tremendous power that a united stand by the councils would have, if they remained solid.
Last year he had to send an emissary to the City of London to assure them that he would get a deal with Liverpool. At the same time he could not find anybody to take over running Liverpool if he got the councillors legally disqualified Jenkin will probably let March 7 come and go, just waiting for the councils' united stand to fall apart.
But there is a third element on the labour movement side. Underneath the councils, a powerful movement is reginning to emerge within the Labour Parties, and more importantly within the council unions.
Joint Shop Stewards' Committees have been formed in the boroughs, and the London Bridge combine committee across London.
At the stewards' level, the opposite trend to that of the councils dominates. It is against any sell-out, and determined to fight on the principle of the Rates Act.
This militant mood is also spilling over into other issues. Under the auspices of London Bridge, dustmen are beginning to meet to discuss the problems of privatisation. The Local Government and Land Act - one of Thatcher's earliest major laws, but to this day unchallenged - is being taken up.
In Sheffield, after a discussion on rate-capping, the stewards adopted the London Bridge policy and added in their own demands for flatrate pay and single status.
All this has been able to develop because of the broad unity achieved around ratecapping, at least up to the point of defiance on March 7 The key, of course, is the shop floor. While the situation there remains uneven, the months of propaganda work carried out against ratecapping and against any council sell-outs have laid the basis for a mass movement.
The first major test will be March 7, when major demonstrations will take place in all London's rate-capped boroughs.
These demonstrations will be organised not by the coun cils but by the local joint trade union committees, and coordinated by London Bridge, If we have done our work properly, then the councils' limited stand will have opened a Pandora's Box, with workers mobilised, willing to fight, and looking to the councils to stand by their promises of no sell-out, Miners in Armthorpe protest at Photo: John Harris (IFL). Continued from The good news for the miners is that the power to make "peace' rests with the NUM and not the TUC.
Willis claims that the NUM has made significant concessions to the NCB and the Tories. He says they now acknowledge and endorse the NCB's commitment to "an economically sound industry" , and accept its right to make the "final decision"
Certainly, these are concessions made against the advice of Arthur Scargill. But the NUM EC changed the "compromise document's" main references to pit closures on economic grounds with the result that the Coal Board refused to start negotiations.
Whatever Willis says the NCB insists that the differences were still "of principle". . NCB mouthpiece Eaton said there was still "a yawning gap". dian).
Striking miners have also made their position clear, time and again. Last Wednesday, the South Wales delegate conference decided that there would be no return to work until all those sacked have been reinstated.
Courts The legal assaults on the union continue. The latest legal blow is the granting of injunctions to scabs from both South Wales and Yorkshire to limit picketing in their Areas. The ruling on Yorkshire limits legal pickets to six at 11 pits.
This ruling forbids the Area to organise mass pickets or guarantee to pay fines for arrested pickets.
Last Wednesday, the South Wales area delegate conference voted to comply with the court and appeal against their ruling. On Thursday the Yorkshire Area