Scargill and the rise of the NUM left
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
Prison warders confront demonstrators outside Wandsworth Prison where Kent miner Terry French is imprisoned for fire vears. Photo:
when confronted with 400 student protesters.
Heseltine's meeting.
Confronted with the protesALL local miners' support groups have now been banned from sending delegates to the Glasgow Miners Support Group (MSG), by origin a joint Trades Council-Glasgow District Labour Party body, but now a Communist Party-controlled rump.
Most people active in support of the miners in Glasgow are in one of the ten local support groups. At one fell swoop, therefore, virtually the entire miners solidarity movement in Glasgow has been disenfranchised.
There were just ten people -present at the MSG meeting which took this bureaucratic decision - two of them were - from local supportgroups, four were Communist Party (CP) - members, and two were Labout Party members who, given thei politics, should be in the CP. The guilt must be laid directly at the feet of the CP.
A fortnight earlier, at the previous MSG meeting, the CP had pushed through a resolution banning attendance by delegates from the local Mineworkers' Defence Committee (MDC). A Socialist Organiser leaflet subsequently distributed at the AGM of Glasgow Trades Council warned: "If MDC delegates are banned from meetings of the Glasgow MSG — who will be next?
The CP was pretty quick in - coming up with the answerthe better part of valour. (Is this really the spirit that won us back the Falklands?). He offered to meet a delegation of six protesters if, in exchange, he was allowed in to address the Partv faithful.
His less than generous offer got the thumbs down from the protesters. Flanked by Tory Club stalwarts, Heseltine held a perfunctory press conference on the steps of the building he had failed to enter and retreated to the more comfortable surroundings of his hotel room.
The Tory Club is now denouncing the successful demonstration as an infringement of In any case, no denial of freedom of speech was involved.
Meanwhile, various Labour So far, though, the Tories RAYS just about every miners' solidarity activist in Glasgow! So much for the idea of a "broad democratic alliance"
The threadbare motivation for the decision was the need to exclude "disruptive elements" from MSG meetings (i.e. people who ask questions or voice any kind of criticism). A variety of lies, half-truths, and stock-in-trade denunciation of "ultraleftism" were thrown in for good measure.
Tonque-in-cheek, the CP has declared that delegates from trade union and Labour Party branches will still be accepted at MSG meetings. But the local support groups unite the activists in the two wings of the movement. And the right-; wing nature of local Labour Parties has often necessitated the setting up of local miners' support groups as a precondition for building support for the It is particularly ironic that the CP should decide who can and cannot attend MSG meetings -only 23% of its 4,000 members in Scotland pay membership dues! This is hardly a recipe for democratic viganisation.
Labour Party and trade union branches should nove as quickly as possible to get the ban overturned - before they find themselves banned from MSG meetings as well!
IN A dozen years Arthur Scargill has risen from rank and file branch member at Woolley in Yorkshire to the position of leader of one of the longest and most bitter strikes the British labour movement has ever seen.
The bosses and their press — and their toadies in the Labour and trade union movement -now call everything that is best in the British labour movement by the name of "Scargillism"
Scargill is the hero and champion of militant workers throughout Britain. The story of Scargill's rise from the rank and file is much more than an interesting tale of one person's rise to power in a union. It is the story of how the left organised to free the NUM from the old right wing leadership and how they turned it into the most militant trade union in Britain.
The NUM (then the Miners Federation of Great Britain) had a very militant reputation for a long time. But after World War Two and nationalisation the right wing gained a grip over the NUM, turning it into a very passive organsation.
This "right wing" included some Stalinists like Arthur Horner who were in practice for to the right and working very closely with the Coal Board.
Inactive
The union was largely inactive as its members jobs, wages and conditions were attacked and eroded.
Between 1957 and 1971 the NUM tolerated pit closures and a contraction of the industry which would be unheard of todav. The industry was decimated and the union - then led by "Communist" Will Paynter did nothing. The miners' inability to fight back continued while the right wing ruled over the union.
Then the left began to organise to confront the old right wing leadership. This movement started in Yorkshire where: the area union was still controlled by the right.
The real shake-up in the Yorkshire area and in the NUM as a whole started in 1969. In October unofficial strike action started, organised and led by the Yorkshire left. Flying pickets were used to spread the strike to other areas.
It lasted two weeks. Some of the demands fo the strike were not won, but the full wage claim was agreed to. This was the spark which reignited the latent militancy in the Yorkshire area and soon, in other areas.
During the strike the official union structures were used as far as was possible to organise the action. But where the right wing could use the official structures as obstacles, an alternative unofficial organisation was thrown up to spread the strike throughout the industry.
This militancy in unofficial strike action was followed up by an offensive at Conference. The left won NUM commitment to strike action if the wage claim was not met.
This led the NUM-to the 1972 strike. At the start, the strike was very disorganised. Then left wing militants organised the flying pickets.
The crunch came at Saltley Gates in Birmingham. There, with the backing of the Birmingham labour movement the miners' flying pickets closed the last major coking plant left open.
71.
Battle of Saltley. 1972 Victory at Saltley Gate was clinched by strike action by the local labour movement. This solidarity action had to be fought for. It was only after Arthur Scargill haranged the AUEW local leadership that solidarity strikes and victory were en sured.
In his recent book on Arthur Scargill. Michael Crick quotes what Arthur Scargill said to them:
Demand *Will you go down in history as the working class in Birmingham who stood by while the miners were battered, or will you become immortal? I do not ask you - 1 demand that you come out on strike.' TI Andrew Moore The 1972 strike saw the rise of Scargill to national prominence both within the NUM and in the wider political arena.
Then in 1974 the miners took on and defeated the Tory government. When Prime Minister Heath decided to "go to the country" to strengthen his hand with an election victory, he lost the election. Labour formed a minority government.
The 1972 and 1974 strikes together put the power, strength and militancy of the miners centre stage in Britain's industrial and political life.
The left was on the ascendancy within the union and it could only be a matter of time before they took the national leadership positions. Michael McGahey had already been NOTICE KEEP OUT elected as Vice-President in 1973. In 1981 Scargill was elected President with a triumphant 70% of the vote.
The left in the NUM had understood and acted upon the great lesson of British trade union history: that the left must combine the fight for elected leadership positions in the unin with campaigns to commit the union to a militant fighting strategy based on organising the rank and file to defend their interests.
The major failing of the left in the NUM was that it did not organise their large numbers of supporters into a national rank and file organisation.
With the absence of rank and file organisation, the militancy of many miners was isolated and underused. The militant national leadership was also 'isolated", cut off from certain key areas.
Campaign
The Scargill leadership tried but did not get the necessary backing for strike action in a series of ballots in 1977, January 1982, October 1982 and March 1983 over pay and closures. If an organisation of active and coordinated militant miners had existed, then they could have strengthened the campaign and organised to get a yes vote to back Arthur Scargill.
A rank and file movement could have organised miiltants in areas such as Nottinghamshire and Lancashire to win miners to militant trade unionism.
It could have fought to replace the area leaderships.
The history of the left in the NUM over the last 20 years has been a history of learning from its experiences and making good the union's weaknesses. The high point of this story of the renewal of NUM militancy was the election of Scargill in 1981.
One of the main lessons of the 1984-5 strike is that the left in the NUM should now create a rank-and-file movement - to back the leaders who fight and replace those who won't.
Which way forward for the NUM left? What do you think? Let us have your views.
Scan page 5
Paul Whetton Police occupy Houghton Main. Photo: John Harris. M.& S. SCOTT Grocers Sandwiches Jean Lane spoke Catherine Black, an NUM member sacked for being on strike I WORK at Bevercotes canteen as a canteen assistant. I've worked there for about three years before the strike started.
I got a letter last Tuesday saying that they wanted us to state, our intention by Friday doing the same. the strike.
With the sacking, 1 think we're a test case, because the striking women at the other pits, Ollerton and Bilsthorpe, haven't had the letter. But they may sack them if they get away with it on us.
Getting the letter has made
----- pull-quotes -----
Tarzan turned
for striking
Organiser no.217 Back iner's