Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Why the Tories don't like iuries

Socialist Organiser no. 217, 20 February 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 1,343 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

THE jury in the Clive Ponting trial slapped Mrs Thatcher's government in the face when it ignored the judge - who came within an inch of directing them to convict - and acquitted Ponting. As Tony Benn indicated in last week's Socialist Organiser, there have been many famous examples in history of juries defying judges and governments like this.

Such a case was that of the Mangrove Nine in the early '70s when a mainly white, mainly working class jury threw out police charges against black militants and by implication The jury system is one of the best bulwarks against state and police tyranny - which is why they have abolished it for THE Old Bailey trial of the Mangrove 9 in 1971 took the fight of Notting Hill's black community against police harassment right into the nerve-centre of the British legal system, challenging the Judge, the Police and the Court procedures, and disrupting the smooth routine of Police repression.

With the unexpected help of a mainly white, working class, jury, the Nine won at least a partial victory: they were cleared of 25 out of 31 charges, including the most serious ones. Five were acquitted and four got suspended sentences.

The jury simply decided that the police were liars. And, indeed, the evidence in support of this view was overpowering. The charges were of riot, causing an affray, and causing grievous bodily harm. The police brought these charges in order to hit back at the black community in Notting Hill which had dared to stand up to them.

In June and July 1970 the Mangrove Restaurant was raided nine times by police supposedly looking for drugs, which they never found, and its licence to stay open after 11 p.m. was revoked when the police lodged an objection. Thereafter, those who ran it were repeatedly dragged into court, accused of serving food after hours.

Marched

On August 9, 1970 the local black people marched in protest at this police harassment. Without any provocation' - other than the outrageous sight of blacks daring to protest — police baton-charged the march. The marchers naturally fought back.

The charges against the Nine arose from this battle. The first time the police brought the charges they were thrown out by a local magistrate, and it is pretty certain that it was on the initiative of Scotland Yard, backed up by the Director of Public Prosecutions, that other charges were then substituted and a decision to press ahead with prosecutions taken. Later, by a legal trick, the original, more serious charges were reintroduced at the Old Bailey.

Neither the harassment by local police bully-boys, nor the Honest copt is on the beat? accused the police of framing them.

Republicans in Northern Ireland.

Constance Lever wrote Mangrove 9 trial.

Darius Howe intervention of the higher polic authorities in pressing 3 thi changes was accidental.

The police must protect thi private property system of th wealthy against its victims. T forestall trouble they tend ti pick most on those who stan out, who have the rawest deal and try to terrorise them int submission.

Their first targets are th homeless, the unemployed, th Irish labourers, the blacks. Ani when such people fight back, i worries them.

The Mangrove was a com munity restaurant, one of a net work of community organisa tions. The Nine included mel and women, youth and adults workers and students, th highly political and the politic ally inarticulate: the restauran and its clientelle were harasse so as to stamp out a centre c black consciousness.

This sort of insolent thugger and racist provocation is regular part of the sporting lif enjoyed by the honest-copper on-the-beat in all the cities c this account England.

When the Mangrove blacks responded militantly, refusing to be cowed, the police countered first with a baton charge and then by mobilising all the power the police and judicial establishment could muster.

Because the police threw all they had at the Nine, the result of the ten-week trial was a serious smack in the face for the The trial itself was not quite what the police had bargained for. The accused did not act like frightened and malleable pawns of the Court, silent and kowtowing.

Instead, they turned the trial into an indictment of the police and the system. Three of them, Darkus Howe, Rhodan Gordon and Althea Lecointe, conducted their own defence. They all refused to shut up when told to. rejected the Judge's rulings that statements about police brutality in Notting Hill were irrelevant, and even provoked "His Honour" on several occasions into walking out of his own Court.

Ritual

With these tactics they broke through the hidebound ritual of Court procedure and managed to actually talk about their lives and experiences, and about their conflict with the police, to the ordinary men and women of the jury.

Normally the jury is segregated in its box, silent and forbidden to ask questions. The accused are in the prisoners" dock, silent and forbidden to explain themselves or address the jury directly: they answer only when spoken to, and only to the point of questions put to them.

Both jury and accused are in the hands of the Judge, the lawyers and the police, who understand eachother well and are accustomed to the rituals of the courtroom - rituals strange and inhibiting to the laymen involved.

The officials and police are members or servants of the ruling class, either hostile to, or without real understanding of, the lives and experiences of most accused and also of most jurors, the majority of whom are from the working class.

The mumbo-jumbo and ancient ritual of the courts serves to block direct contact or real communiction between the accused and the jury.

The Mangrove Nine cut through the barriers of courtroom procedure.

They refused to behave as individuals charged with crimes, unsure and apologetic, but acted instead as representatives of a militant black community challenging police and Court intimidation.

And their community backed them up: every day of the 49day trial they packed the public gallery to give solidarity.

The acquittals proved that it is possible - sometimes - to beat the police frame-up system, and to disrupt the rusty machinery of the courts. But not only that.

Class lines

A majority of the Mangrove jury were workers, and only of the eleven were black. It is known that the jury divided along class lines, with the middle class members inclined to believe the police and favouring conviction.

It seems that some of the workers knew better. Eventually they compromised on the basis of agreement on acquittal on the most serious charges.

And when the trial ended, seven jurors joined the Nine to spend three hours chatting and drinking, like old friends long kept apart.

Whatever element of accident there may, have been in the Mangroye verdict and in the composition of the jury, the trial does show that the jury system can be a weak link in the chain of boss-class control, which can sometimes be used to their advantage by militants.

Nor is this new: in 1794 a London jury acquitted Hardy, the Republican, of treason and the London crowd carried him in triumph through the And in 1833 a jury of Clerkenwell tradesmen took over the conduct of a trial, insisted on asking their own questions and brought in a verdict of justifiable homicide on the killers of a policeman who had taken part in an attack on a demonstration.

They were themselves feted as popular heroes.

That is why in times of social crisis the rulers can no longer use the jury system and must substitute the blatant repression of internment without trial or martial law.

Meanwhile the courts are their courts, the law is their law. And our strength - the strength of the working class and of the oppressed minority groups — is in the factories and on the streets. But when we are forced onto their ground we must know how to fight there too.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 217

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →