Tyranny and murder in the name of communism
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-20Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Read SO's
new monthly magazine supplement. 50p plus 13p postage from SO. 214 Sickert Ct. London NI he truth DURING 1985 we will hear the official story of World War Two over and over again, as we come up to the 40th anniversary of the end of the war in Europe. A lot will be glossed over -like the bombing of the German city of Dresden on February 1414 1945 by British and US planes.
That air raid killed between 100,000 and 250,000 people — as many as the Hiroshima atom bomb, and more than twice as many as died in all the air raids on Britain during World War Two put together. Practically all were civilians. Many were refugees. The city had no air raid defences.
Dresden had little significance as a military or strategic target. In fact the air raid was concentrated on the city centre and residential areas: rail links through Dresden were cut for only three days, and most of Dresden's major factories were hardly touched.
The raid was deliberately designed to cause huge civilian casualties, in order to demoralise the Germans.
The air raid used conventional bombs - but concentrated in such numbers that they caused a fire-storm. Whole blocks of buildings caught fire. The fire heated the air above them so much that an artificial tornado was created, pulling air, objects 50p Labour Left The and break up the Communist Party and people from round about into an inferno which eventually covered at least eight square miles of the city.
In those eight square miles it was practically impossible to survive. People who had found shelter in cellars died from lack of oxygen.
No-one knows exactly how many people died because the pre-war population of Dresden - 600,000 - had been swollen to at least twice that number by refugees. But the terrible effect of concentrated bombing and fire-storms was well known.
Firebomb
The RAF had fire-bombed Hamburg, killing over 40,000 civilians, in July 1943. It also fire-bombed Kassel, Darmstradt, and Brunswick, thoug with smaller casualties. A US fire-bomb attack on Tokyo in March 1945 killed almost as many as the Dresden raid.
At about this time the Allied air forces were rejecting frantic demands from Jewish organisations that they should bomb the railway lines leading to the Nazi death camps. Not enough planes, they said - not enough bombs.
The British and US governments did not fight World War Two for democracy and civilisation. For them, all that was secondary: their chief aim was to defend and strengthen the world position of British and US imperialist capital.
a FORUM 1985 Number 1 February 50 years ago Stalin's Great Terror was getting under way.
-The isolation of the Bolshevik Revolution in the backward, war-ravaged USSR had already shifted power from the working class to a privileged bureaucracy. The Terror consolidated the bureaucracy's rule and destroyed its last links with working class politics and with Bolshevism.
Patrick Murphy tells the story.
BY 1934 Joseph Stalin had eliminated the most serious opposition he had faced within the Soviet Communist Party and was clearly the leading figure in the Soviet Union.
Trotsky had been exiled, oppositionists associated with him had been arrested, exiled, or murdered. The less committed had confessed their mistakes and begun to pay homage to Comrade Stalin.
However, none of the ruthless faction-fighting, persecution or repression of the first ten years of Stalin's leadership could compare with the vicious reign of terror that was unleashed In December 1934 a leading Communist Party boss, Kirov, was killed by a young oppositionist. There is still argument about who was behind Kirov's death, but on balance it seems that Stalin himselt ordered the murder.
Kirov was a rival to Stalin within the Party. He represented a faction which had had some success at the recent 17th Congress of the Communist Party in urging moderation and less repression.
The assassination gave Stalin the excuse to unleash one of the most brutal and widespread purges in human history.
Immediately the murder of Kirov was blamed on a 'terorist conspiracy involving foreign powers, tascısm, Trotsky and internal dissıdents. Iwo promınent old Bolsheviks, Zinoviev and Kamenev - broken and defeated oppositionists - were arrested and forced to confess to conspiring with Trotsky and foreign powers against the Soviet Union.
Throughout 1935 loyal Stalinists took all the major positions in the Party: all members were encouraged to join in a witchhunt for secret 'Trotskyists' By 1936 the leading Stalinists were complaining that the ranks of the party were filled with too many liberals, and that there was too much reluctance in unmasking traitors, Trotskyists and spies.
It was, therefore, in 1936 that the most thorough and indiscriminate purge began. No section of Soviet society was safe from persecution - not even those who were carrying it out.
The chief of the secret police (NKVD), Yagoda, was eventually arrested and executed himself.
Leading Stalinists were executed or jailed for being disloyal. Most of the Central Committee of the Communist Party and the senior layers of the military were swept aside. Scientists, engineers and managers were shot or imprisoned in their tens of thousands.
The treatment of fellowStalinists was the farcical side of the Terror. The terrible tragedy was the destruction of communist militants. Most oppositionStalin. gravedigger of the revolution ists were wiped out ruthlessly.
So were foreign communists who had taken refuge in the Soviet Union. The entire leadership of the Polish Communist Party, which was in exile in the USSR, was executed.
Millions Millions of people died in these purges, party members and non-members. Communists with foreign connections of any kind were particularly suspect. This was used to lustitv the execution not only of Soviet diplomats but also of many soldiers returning from service in the Spanish Civil War.
The more prominent Communists were 'tried' in a series of show trials, beginning in 1936.
In the first trial, Zinoviev, Kamenev and 14 others were brought into court. All but one were executed after 'confessing" and being found guilty.
In the second trial, 17 people. including the former Bolshevik leader Karl Radek, were accused of conspiring with Japan and Germany to divide the USSR between those two powers. They were found guilty. 13 were executed and four sent tu camps. None survived.
Both of these trials "evidence which implicated Nikolai Bukharin, an old and respected Bolshevik and Stalin's partner in the battle with Trotsky in the 1920s. He had so far escaped the investigators. In the final show trial, in 1938, Bukharin was sentenced to be shot.
When the Great Terror (as it finally became known) finally ended, Stalin blamed the new head of the secret police, Yezhov, for the excessive brutality. He had him replaced by Beria, a personal friend of Stalin, and then executed Yezhov.
Purges continued right up to Stalin's death in 1953. Widespread purges were carried out against old Pers in the East European Stalinist states. But the scale of the 1935-8 Terror was unprecedented and remains unsurpassed.
Elimination One result of the Great Terror was the almost entire elimination of the old Bolshevik party.
Of the membership of the CPSU in 1939, 80 per cent had joined since 1930. Of Lenin's Central Committee, only one member - Stalin - survived after the assassination of Trotsky in 1940. Thus, practically everyone who had any independent communist tradition or status in the Soviet Union hád been removed.
By the time Stalin's successor, Krushchev, confessed Stalin's crimes to the Soviet people in 1956, it was clear that the entire structure of the CPSU had been changed beyond recognition in the years of the purges.
There is no doubt that Stalin was an odious and brutal character, a tyrant and a man who contributed nothing positive to human history. Comparisons made by bourgeois historians between Stalin and Hitler are quite justified. But this alone cannot explain the depths to which he - and the USSR -sank in those years.
Stalin was a mediocre man who had played a secondary part in the Bolshevik revolution. After he became dictator, he had had to falsify history enormously to make it seem that his role had been much greater.
Links Even when all effective opposition seemed to have been defeated, there were people in the Communist Party who still believed in communism in some sense — people who had some links with the revolution and with the old working-class movement. Most of these had joined the party before 1917 or in the immediate aftermath of the revolution.
Stalin had to rid the party and the state of these people if his dictatorship and the rule of the new bureaucratic elite were to be stabilised.
Those who were left when all this was done were worthless anti-communist, anti-working-class bureaucrats, who had achieved or held their positions by obeying orders and wiping out anyone with a fragment of commitment to Bolshevism.
Many Communist Party members today still wish to deny or gloss over the crimes of Stalin. Nikita Krushchev denounced Stalin's crimes at the 20th (1956) Congress of the CPSU and at the. 22nd (1961). But today Stalin has gone a long way towards being rehabilitated in the USSR.
This is not all that surprising. It suited Krushchev to break with Stalin in 1956 - but he did not break with Stalinism.
Nine months after he denounced the bloody tyrant Stalin, Krushchev himself sent the Russian tanks to crush the people of Budapest. Stalin was dead; Stalin had been denounced and 'repudiated' by his hand-picked successors - but Stalinism was still alive.
That was the message of Hungarian experience for labour movement.
The likes of Krushchev, Brezhnev, Andropov, Chernenko and the modern rulers of the Soviet Union, are the sort of corrupt degenerate characters whom Stalin considered it safe to tolerate.
They took part in or encouraged the destruction of the Soviet communist tradition, and they benefit from its destruction.
Working-class communism will return to haunt those. bureaucrats, who are — despite what they call themselves -among the world's leading anti-communists.
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser no. 217. February 20 1985. Page 11
----- pull-quotes -----
«THE BRITISH ROAD TO NOWHERE