Palestine campaign
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-02-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page (Kinnock backs SAS, Clive Bradley on Lebanon and Paddy Dollard on the Irish contraceptives vote, which now have their own pages).
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 9
AT ITS Annual General Meeting last Sunday, 24th, the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine was able to register some successes since its last AGM in 1983.
The major one was the Labour Movement conference on Palestine, organised jointly with the Palestine Solidarity Campaign last May.
The AGM resolved to take up the tasks set by that conference — a labour movement delegation to Palestine, and a campaign for the disaffiliation of Poale Zion (overseas branch of the Israeli Labour Party) from the British Labour Party.
The Labour Party leadership has ignored the policy passed at the 1982 conference, in the aftermath of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon. This policy supported the establishment of a democratic secular state in Palestine.
There were two main political discussions at the AGM. One, on the current situation in Israel, centred on the dire economic position there and the possible development of a fascist movement around Kahane's Kach party and elements from the right-wing Likud coalition.
PLO
The other discussion looked at the rightward shift in the Palestine Liberation Organisation following its retreat from Lebanon. This shift has strengthened Arafat's hand, enabling him to convene the 17th Palestine National Council and get support for PLO links with Egypt and its 'special relationship' with King Hussein of Jordan.
Although these policies do not command a majority of the organisations in the PLO, the opposition is currently fragmented.
The sharpest debate was on recent events at Sunderland Polytechnic. The Union of Jewish Students has been banned by the Students Union there on the grounds that it is Zionist and Zionism is racism. Socialist Organiser has argued against this ban.
Although the Israeli state was established by racist means and is racist, Zionist organisations cannot be equated with racist groups of the type of the National Front. Unfortunately the vast majority of Jews are Zionists: they are by no means necessarily racists. To ban Jewish organisations for being Zionist means to ban nearly all Jewish organisations and thus actually to infringe the democratic rights of Jews.
Two resolutions were put to the AGM. Unfortunately the better one was defeated.
Wrong-headed
The defeated resolution, moved by Andrew Hornung, described banning of Jewish and Zionist organisations as "wrong-headed and counterproductive". An amendment defending the autonomy of student unions was carried before the resolution was defeated.
The successful resolution, moved by Tony Greenstein, advised against moves to ban Zionist organisations but went on to welcome "the victory of Palestinian/anti-Zionist forces" at the recent Sunderland Poly student union meeting, and offered "full support to Sunderland Poly in any confrontation with the National Union of Students executive" arising from the ban.
An amendment moved by Bob Cullen, a delegate from Oxford, would have removed all reference to disagreement with the ban, thus in effect offering uncritical support to Sunderland Poly. It was narrowly defeated before the resolution was carried.