Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Cuts: medical nonsense

Socialist Organiser no. 218, 27 February 1985 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 842 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The Tory assault on the National Health Service has led to many far-reaching and sometimes unexpected consequences for patients. Last week, I looked at the way cuts had led to longer waiting lists and attempts to close vital facilities. This week, I will describe how the cuts are affecting the quality of week, I will describe how the present day treatment and the Centralisation.

Closing smaller hospitals and centralising services into ever arger hospitals may make economic" sense. However, it makes medical nonsense.

For instance, the ten year plan for the West Lambeth Health District leaves the area with just one hospital, the massive St. Thomas's Hospital. This is extremely inconveniently placed on the south bank of the Thames with out-patients facing long journeys by public transport.

Concentrating large numbers of sick people in one gigantic hospital is a dangerous policy, with many diseases being passed around, despite precautions.

Some infections are only found in hospitals, as only here can the bacteria gain access to people's bodies through operation wounds.

Recent outbreaks of fatal food poisoning seem to have been uts are affecting the quality of raining of future doctors. made worse by the large numbers of sick and elderly patients sharing the same food.

Cutting staff and beds One response to bed shortages has been to speed patients' passage through hospital, as reported from the Camberwell Health District. This may result in patients going home before they are well enough or where there is inadequate after-care.

Patients may need dressings changed, etc., and yet Camberwell's Community Nursing Service has received no extra funding to cope with earlier discharge of patients. Indeed, Camberwell is short of 16 District Nurses.

Standards of hygiene, which need greater attention in larger hospitals, are damaged by rundown of staff. For instance, it is thought that staff shortages led to the food poisoning outbreak mentioned before through food being left out for hours before SCIENC being served.

Privatisation Strictly speaking, is not 'privatisation" but *costcutting" that is the name of the game. Some hospitals have used privately-employed domestic staff for years but the current policy has led to the replacement of low-paid but dedicated staff by even lower-paid, semicasual staff who often don't even have time to fulfil their workloads, let alone chat to patients or take an interest in the hospital.

Unrealistic Unrealistic contracts have resulted in situations like that at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge. Last October, the Guardian reported that Bags of soiled linen [urine, vomit, faeces] are piled high in a corridor. Cardboard boxes full of rubbish, sacks of surgical waste are stacked against the wall. It is 7 am and they must have been there all night."

This was the result when a new firm took over from domestics employed by the hospital and by Crothalls. Pay cuts and redundancies resulted in a strike and in the resignation of Professor John Davis, one of Britain's leading child specialists. He criticised the "political decision" to bring in "so-called privatisation, stating that workers' conditions of service should allow them to focus their main concern on patients" wellbeing. This would not happen if domestics were turned into casual labour. He added, "On mv wards we value verv hiohlv the responsible and loyal work of our cleaners and the personal help often given to our patients and their parents.

This is not just one isolated scandal. Privatisation at High Royds Hospital in Leeds resulted in human excrement and vomit being left on floors, while at Barking Hosptal, where Crothalls renewed its existing contract, slashing wages and conditions, inexperienced scab cleaners have allowed cockroaches and other insects a free run.

Not only does this increase the risk of contracting infections in hospital, but patients have lost the important psychological benefit that domestic staff often bring.

Medical teaching harmed.

A perhaps unexpected side-effect of reduced stays in hospital is the harm done to the education of medical sfudents.

Students need the time to examine and learn from patients before, during and after treatment.

The King's College School of Medicine and Dentistry stated recently that there was already a shortage of beds for teaching. With reduced stays in hospital, students might find the patients in and out before they had had a chance to be taught anything about the physical signs of their illness.

The General Medical Council has already commented on the lowered standards of students' physical examination of patients, due to inadequate practice.

Progress The School is also worried about the progress of doctors in their compulsory year in hospital after qualifying. This year is supposed to consolidate the practical aspects of doctors training but at King's. "House officers are now spending too high a proportion of their time on administrative tasks, particularly in the often fruitless endeavour to find beds for their patients.

Next week. I will look at how the cuts have prevented urgent improvements in treatment and are destroying medical research.

Scan page 11

reachers fight for pay THE teachers' action over pay Its coli la lasdaca 1.0u ga Socialist Organiser no. 218. February, 27 1985. Page

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 218

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →