Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Contraceptives vote: a major defeat for the Church

Socialist Organiser no. 218, 27 February 1985 · scan p. 9 · Paddy Dollard · about 685 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

In the North and South column. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into Palestine campaign. "pretentions" and "welsh" as printed.

Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.

Scan page 9

LAST WEEK the Dail (Parliament) in Dublin voted to make condoms available to people over 18.

This was an important political event. Until 1979 all contraception was banned in the 26 Counties of Southern Ireland. In that year a bill brought in by the present Fianna Fail leader, Charles J Haughey, made contraceptives available to married couples who could find a doctor willing to write them a prescription. Even to do that he had to defy the Catholic Church's ban on contraception.

Haughey described it as "an Irish solution to an Irish problem", and there is no reason to think he was being humorous.

The new law will not open the floodgates of revolution. Far from it. It is a miserable law, which sets the minimum age for sexual activity at 18. Millions of illegal contraceptives were easily available, anyway.

The important thing is that the Dail voted against the wishes and in open defiance of the instructions of the Catholic hierarchy. It stood up to a brutal public campaign of arm-twisting and attempted intimidation of Dail deputies.

Bishops made pronouncements that it was the duty of Catholic legislators to be guided by Catholic moral teaching. A number of deputies received death threats. Many received convincing indications that if they did not toe the bishops' line then they would pay for it at the next election, and some of them no doubt will.

Despite all that, Dail Eireann voted against the Church. No such direct defiance has ever happened before.

For a decade or so, the bishops have been cautious, claiming to have given up any pretentions to a direct political influence. Early in the '70s they agreed to changes in the Irish constitution which removed the reference to a 'special place' for the Catholic Church.

The days seemed long gone when the hierarchy would send for a minister and tell him what they wanted him to do, or would break him if he refused — as they did notoriously in 1951, when Dr Noel Browne tried, against their wishes, to bring in some free health care for pregnant women and new-born babies.

The Church began to welsh on its promise to keep out of politics during the national debate and referendum on abortion in 1983. It came back in with hobnail boots to stop the 'condom bill' — and suffered the clearest defeat it has ever experienced in independent Ireland.

One of the worst effects of the partition of Ireland was that it segregated off the bulk of the Protestant population and thus destroyed the possibility of cultural pluralism in the south.

In the North the prime minister could proclaim "a Protestant state for a Protestant people", and repressed the one-third Catholic minority. In the South, they talked about a 'Republic' and appealed to the Republican tradition of Tone and Davis, but what they created was 'a Catholic state for a Catholic people'.

The largely upper-class Protestant minority was marginal. From the mid-1920s, when divorce was abolished, Catholic dogma shaped social legislation. Obviously this Catholic rule in the South widened and deepened the gulf between North and South.

It has taken a long time for the power of the Catholic hierarchy to weaken and begin to crumble. It would be wrong now to exaggerate the extent to which that power has been eroded.

Nevertheless, the fact that the hierarchy couldn't muster the power to get its way on an issue it considered fundamental and campaigned on vigorously — that's progress.

Des O'Malley, a former contender for the Fianna Fail leadership, was the hero of the Dail debate. Defying the Fianna Fail whip to vote against the government, O'Malley made a thoughtful speech and then abstained. For that he has been expelled from Fianna Fail.

He put the issue starkly when he said that the issue was not the condom bill but whether the Dail could rule, and, beyond that, whether Ireland could ever unite into a democratic republican society in which Catholic and Protestant could coexist as equals.

That was the issue, and that's why the vote against the hierarchy is so important.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 218

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →